Software
Houzz Logo Print
lucieanna28

Quartzite kitchen countertop seam?

4 years ago

Hi there! Looking for advice on seam placement for my kitchen countertops.


I purchased Calacatta Luxe Quartzite. Each slab is 110”x74”.



My sink is an undermount cast iron sink (Kohler Riverby 33").



My countertop fabricator highly discourages placing seams at the sink area. He says it is too wet and it will eventually fail. He says that once it fails, there’s no fix and you must replace the countertops. He recommends placing the seam above the dishwasher, as this seems to be the only other spot based on the slab size. For aesthetics, I prefer a seam at the sink because it's less visible. Is this a bad idea? Will it really fail? Here's a view of my kitchen and the seam options. The blue line indicates the seam at the sink, and the red line indicates the seam at the dishwasher.







Comments (20)

  • 4 years ago

    If he's telling you his seam will fail, that's a red flag ... seams at the sink are very common and I don't see a flood of posts on here about them failing. I do see a ton about conspicuous seams and how this, that, and the other vein or variation didn't align.


    I would also argue that if the seam at the sink fails, you could potentially resolve it with a new sink ... apron front, maybe faucet deck across the back ...

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Very common to seam at sink. Seek a better fabricator. A seam at the dishwasher will be very noticeable with your stone. The stone is gorgeous. Hope you can resolve this properly. Beautiful stone!!

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    i am a fabricator. A competent fabricator could put a seam in either location. Properly installed there is no mechanical load on the countertop seam so there is no reason for the seam to fail.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    "My countertop fabricator highly discourages placing seams at the sink area. He says it is too wet and it will eventually fail."


    Wrong.


    "He says that once it fails, there’s no fix and you must replace the countertops."


    Wrong again. I've remade plenty of seams at sinks.


    "He recommends placing the seam above the dishwasher, as this seems to be the only other spot based on the slab size."


    This guy disagrees with him.


    "For aesthetics, I prefer a seam at the sink because it's less visible. Is this a bad idea? Will it really fail?"


    It is not a bad idea; properly done it will not fail.


    I'd suggest a change of sink. If you switched to a Kohler 6488, you'd get a 36" sink in a 36" cabinet, and eliminate the seam at the front rail:




  • PRO
    4 years ago

    lucieanna28:


    Have you personally tested your slabs to make sure they're really quartzite please? Have you tested for porosity? You cannot assign these tasks away; the neglect could be catastrophic as evidenced here repeatedly.


    How large is the island cantilever please? Are your slabs 2 or 3cm? Please post the range top manufacturer's installation instructions.

  • PRO
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I agree with all these comment sna dfor sure the one about the seams at the sink failing That is IMO the best place for a seam and as you understand the least visible. BTW IMO cast iron emanmmelled sinks are a chip waitig to happen and IMO these sinks with the grids and addons are just a pure PITA to clean and even use .The grids get gross so they need daily cleaning so does the sink and IMO just double the work of a good lage single bowl stainless sink. I aslo agree you need to consider steel supports for any overhang with quartzite since it is a stone filled with fissures that can cause cracking.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Agreed. A stainless steel sink will scratch without a basin rack. We always include them for both stainless and cast iron sinks. Kohler offers a lifetime warranty for their sinks against chips.

  • 4 years ago

    I am not getting a farmhouse sink (hindsight being 20/20 - design fail). Is a seem at the sink still the best location? I have a 130” piece of quartzite and from wall to end of counter (wall contains my sink) is 128”. The stone shop is telling me a seem is needed to prevent the stone from cracking during transport, and that there is a risk with having one solid piece. Does this sound correct?

    Also, I’m torn on what kind of sink to get. I’ve read every review out there for enamel cast undercount, stainless under mount. Not sure what to get. I had a no-brand stainless in my last house for 20 years and it was so durable no issues ever. Now I’m not sure if a basic stainless will work with my really nice brand new kitchen.

    Thank you!!

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    "The stone shop is telling me a seem is needed to prevent the stone from cracking during transport, and that there is a risk with having one solid piece. Does this sound correct?"


    No. It is incorrect.


    You can't go wrong with a stainless steel sink, however, it you're looking for color, check out the Elkay Quartz Luxe line please.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    It's correct if they say it is. They don't want to take on the liability of transporting an 11' piece of quartzite with a sink cut-out in it. You can either sign a waiver that they are not liable if it breaks or you can find another fabricator that will agree to transport and install it in one piece.

  • 4 years ago

    Thanks - Joseph what makes it incorrect? Genuine question. Do you think it’s feasible to transport without the risk of a crack?
    Also, I’m not sure I want a seam at my sink?? Maybe somewhere else would look better.

    I decided to just do a undermount stainless.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    It is incorrect because if you utilize a Sink Hole Saver, you could push the top off the back of the truck at 80mph and the sink rail would not break.


    Fabricators do the things that benefit them, not necessarily the customer. Lowering risk is a smart business practice, however, use of the proper tools like the SHS, lowers risk and makes customers happier. They are just being cheap and turning their problem into yours. Don't let them please.


    Sinks are excellent locations for seams. Lowest visiblity and when the sink is strapped, not blocked or clipped in place, become one of the strongest parts of a countertop.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    My last fabricators (who weren't what I would consider top notch, compared to others I have used) had no problem doing a seam in the middle of my sink and this was for a 48" opening. They cut it, transported and installed without breaking anything. The thin rail pieces were supported, clamped and strapped in all directions to avoid any stress that might have broken them. The left side rails are 32.5" long. The seam is through the first faucet hole on the left. Show your fabricator this photo!

    You need a different fabricator, one with more confidence and less excuses!


  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Finished photo

    30" Julien sink with integrated 18" drainboard. Sink is also 18" wide and 10" high.

    I was constantly reminding my GC, cabinet maker, appliance person and counter guy that the drainboard was going over the DW, to make sure everyone triple checked their numbers. It worked, but we did have to remove the feet from the DW and adjust the cabinet panel on the DW.


  • 4 years ago

    Thanks for sharing. My fabricator is willing to put the seam in the center of the sink but I’m not sure I want it there.

  • 4 years ago

    I asked them to move the seam to the corner L shape but maybe it would be better in the center of the sink?? They already told me they will not do it in one big piece.

  • PRO
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    It all depends on how many slabs of stone you want to purchase to get what you want. And how many extra hands you want to pay the upcharge to carry it into the house. Also, there is nothing wrong with a seam at the sink.

  • 4 years ago

    We have two slabs. I was willing to pay the upcharge to have extra guys carry it into the house.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    "They already told me they will not do it in one big piece."


    Find a fabricator who uses Sink Hole Savers please. Other than site conditions, there is no reason the sink section needs a seam.