Software
Houzz Logo Print
lilmcnugget

Which Bold Blue to choose ?

4 years ago

Repainting our exterior trim. Front of the house is N facing. Switching from a boring monochromatic light & dark brown color scheme to something more lively. All of our neighbor houses are still having the paint slapped on by the same builder, in various shades of brown.


Having a major choice paralysis between SW Salty Dog vs. SW Endless Sea to use as accent and for the gable Hardi shakes. Salty Dog has only a LRV of 5 while it is 11 for Endless Sea; not sure if it will cause problem on the Hardi.


Pls note we are not painting the taupe vinyl siding.


Appreciate your feedback here.





SW Salty Dog
SW Endless Sea

Comments (9)

  • 4 years ago

    I dont think you can go wrong with either of them, but, my personal preference is the endless sea.

    Maggie L thanked cat_ky
  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I am taking into consideration the siding you are not painting. I see beige and not convinced either of your choices of blue is quite right. Would you add one more to your list? S.W. Waterloo. It has just enough of gray in it to work with the siding.




    Maggie L thanked elcieg
  • 4 years ago

    I understand your desire to change things up but imo go carefully with such contrasts especially on anything other surface than a door. A color consultant at a good paint shop might help you achieve the results you are looking for. I like Endless Sea the best and I like what judianna20 said.

    Maggie L thanked D Bee
  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Dark colors on your gables will make them appear smaller. That is what I'm not liking about it. I had navy blue on my gables (two houses ago) and it was gorgeous, but my gables were huge and doing them darker actually made them look better to scale with my house. I feel like white on your gables would be prettier...but do them in a SHAKE style to add texture and interest.


    Here is my current 1925 house...just had it resided with vinyl. All old house character was stripped from it in the 1960s when they did aluminum siding. I tried to fix that with bandboards and brackets...and the shake style gables. I also had vinyl crown molding added to the windows and got ride of the shutters which didn't match my house.


    Here's some pics I took right after they finished.





    The new deck is almost done. Might as well throw that one in. LOL






    Maggie L thanked The Kitchen Place
  • 4 years ago

    @ The Kitchen Place - Have not thought of white shakes on white trim & beige/taupe siding. Give it a try here. sorry have to say it looks odd... and hence the color dilemma continues


  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    @elcieg - SW Waterloo is a pretty color. Slapping it on for a quick look.

    What do you all think of painting the 3 gable brackets, and the vent same color as the door?

    Visually, at least on the visualizer, painting these the same contrasting color seem to tie in much better than just having the door painted orange.


    I know many would just paint the gable brackets & vent the same white as the trim color.


  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    @Kat Loop Yeah. same here, not a fan of black, white, brown and grey, even they are the most "widely accepted" colors. But I have way passed the internal struggle of trying to please the greater majority for reselling purpose. I had my laminate floor in white aspen when the trend at that time was all expresso brown and dark grey. Fast forward 10 yr later, now everyone is having some form of light color white floors. Now I just hoping I don't need to sell the house for sometimes haha

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Yah I can see why the white might make the rest look dingy. But definitely consider the shakes.