Do you have any inspiration photos of the look you are going for?

Maybe because the picture is in shade, but I think the house doesn't need more dark. I'd go with creamy white.

Have you taken a look at what colors and color placement this type of house would have had? Not to do an exact reproduction necessarily, but just to inform you what the design intention was, and following that will get you better results rather than just randomly applying different colors in different places. This is a great site which illustrates what I mean - note there are 34 pgs of the befores/afters (links on bottom of page). Oddly by switching to a more historically accurate pallette, the house often looks so much fresher than had they stuck wtih boring greige or whatever the current fad du jour is. As the saying goes - what's old is new again! ETA - take a look at the 1916 brick at the very bottom of pg 1 - is this kinda what you are after? Red brick with what looks like hague blue + a cream -beautiful!!!

Exterior Paint Color Portfolio Archives - OldHouseGuy Blog

Some inspro

Front Facade · More Info