I always prefer a chandelier over a dining table.

another vote for chandelier

Chandelier over the dining table would be the best variant.

agree with the Chandelier over the table.

I'd switch the rugs, too. or get a lighter rug, the Blue solid is too heavy for the room.

if it is that chandelier, than no I would go semi flush. I would like to see a chandelier here but that one is a bit too heavy.

How about something more like #2, but a chandelier?