Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_928049337

Help choosing between these 2 counter stools?

3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago

Hi Everyone - this group is always so helpful! I am buying 6 new counter stools - 4 for one side of my kitchen counter and 2 for the opposite counter which faces an open walkway/pass through room. My kitchen was updated awhile ago by the previous owner and I’m not ready to renovate it yet, but just looking to modernize here and there where I can. Here are some pictures - which counter stool would you choose? I am also including a picture of the Pottery Barn rug and gallery art for my pass thru room as I’m sure that will impact the decision. thanks!!


p.S. I should mention that I have 3 young messy boys. The first option below is a performance fabric, but I hope it would withstand my 3 kids! my decorator gave me option 2 as a practical alternative.









4 Kitchen Stools I’m replacing:



2 stools on this side (currently 3):



Another view of open walkway area which will soon have gallery art and Pottery Barn rug:



Open area faces dining room:



Comments (12)

  • 3 years ago

    I like the first option pictured. Open, lighter looking.

    the rug is pretty.

    I am not a fan of gallery art, a large single art canvas is a real statement.

    HU-928049337 thanked Lyn Nielson
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    I agree on a large piece of art vs gallery art - my decorator recommended a gallery wall. when I asked for a large art piece, she recommended this. I like it, but it’s a bit too traditional for me. Then I get stumped and not sure what to do!


  • 3 years ago

    greatbigcanvas.com has so many affordable options. take a look at the site and see options that suit your colors or interests.

    I have a very subtle Beach morning sunrise 60" in my bedroom very subtle colors,

    my sister in law got an intense Blue afternoon sunlight 60" in her greatroom. there is something for everyone!

    HU-928049337 thanked Lyn Nielson
  • 3 years ago

    Thanks Lyn!!

  • 3 years ago

    I prefer the first, but something along the lines of the second will be better suited to 3 kids and the look of the kitchen.

    HU-928049337 thanked Anne Duke
  • 3 years ago

    Hmm i have 2 boys and we eat in the dining room nightly - we have velvet chairs in there and its a bit of a struggle to keep the chairs looking nice and the dark gray velvet is VERY forgiving — anything super messy like cookie decorating we do in the kitchen and those chairs are hard backed and can be easily wiped down - based on my experience I would be afraid the top one would get grimy fast, the 2nd one seems like it would be a lot more forgiving (feels a little heavy to me but that’s just personal preference)

    HU-928049337 thanked la_la Girl
  • 3 years ago

    I have leather dining room chairs for this exact reason la_la Girl! My kids do eat on our counter stools as well and do homework there. I like the Option 1 chairs above better than the 2nd option. wondering if they work in my space aesthetically…and practically. or am I force fitting too hard?

  • 3 years ago

    You might consider getting one stool for the kitchen and the other near the dining room. Too much matching is being avoided now.

    HU-928049337 thanked kl23
  • 3 years ago

    Thank you everyone! @ Maureen - where can I get those rust stools and those square picture frames? love that look…And definitely, the valences need to go :-)


    @ K L…Do you think I can do the top/brass counter stool on the side with the rug and another counter stool on the other side? my decorator recommended that I get the same ones all around for consistency. I am open minded.


    In general, I am concerned that I am ending up with a very traditional look when I was hoping to refresh/modernize a bit. Thanks for all the ideas!


  • 3 years ago

    From what I can tell, the two stool locations are on opposite sides of the kitchen and barely visible at the same time. I would think it would be ok to have two different stools. I would think the ones near the dining room should be consistent with dining room decor more than kitchen decor. The ones deep in the kitchen by the TV just have to go with the kitchen. Maybe your decorator was thinking you would use them together at some point? I don't know. Ask her/him about it again.

    HU-928049337 thanked kl23
  • 3 years ago

    the first one w/the gold or brass metal.

    HU-928049337 thanked hbeing