Software
Houzz Logo Print
729zoom2

Will this floated shower wall fail?

3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago

I am getting bids on correcting a very bad border tile installation and one of the tile contractors just told me that the wire mesh that was used to float the two walls (including the shower area) is also wrong and that it will crack/fail. The squares of the mesh are 2" x 2" - and told it should have been diamond shaped metal lath - that the 2 x 2 is too big to use on the walls and was meant to be used only for floors.

I was hoping to not tear out everything - just the part of the wall that would allow us to redo the border tile - but if what this guy is saying is true, maybe I have to remove the entire thing and start over but wanted to ask others to weigh in and let me know what is standard?

FYI: the picture below shows where the float ended and was left to allow for the vanity and countertop to be put in and then the last row of tiles would be added over the countertop.



Comments (12)

  • 3 years ago

    Raimondi - is that what you call what he used? Concrete wire? Do you know a specific reference that states this does not meet the industry standards so I can try and find it? If I need to redo all of this (feeling sick as I write this), I will need to ask for some money back to cover it and I need proof that he didn't follow the correct method. Because he insists the job is just great. Here is a picture of what he thinks looks like a great border install. :( the field tile was also not installed level either.


  • PRO
    3 years ago

    Standards Requires 2.5 galvie diamond lath or galvie stucco netting for walls.(not chicken wire either) that is NOT the correct lath for walls yet acceptible and preferred for floor screed if placed in the Middle of mortar bed..

    H Briz thanked Mint tile Minneapolis
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Hi Mint. thank you for sharing that. It sounds like what he used is not industry standard? and I assume if something is not industry standard, that there is a good reason for that and that maybe the guy who told me it all needs to be taken out is correct? Before I go farther, I need to know if this needs to be corrected or, if it would be safe to leave it. And when I say safe, not failing anytime while I am alive, which I hope will be at least another 20 years.


    One more thing - is it possible that what he used is stucco netting? I am looking up pictures and it looks similar?

  • 3 years ago

    I found this link of products that look similar but not sure if any of these are OK for shower walls? I do see another brown paper that looks like it was attached but it doesn't have red on it like in these pictures. https://www.treeisland.com/products/stucco-reinforcing/welded-wire/?utm_source=pocket_saves

  • PRO
    3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    You asked for the tile industry standards. There is no Standard for stucco wire in the TCNA or ANSI specs for A tile WALL assembly.. This wire is heavier and typically used for 3 coat stucco. It is not 1 of the 2 types for tile assemblies..

    Will it fail? dunno . ......is it Netting? NO.

    Depends on the weight of the concrete, type and thickness., the way in which wire its fastened, lapped and tied off at laps, stud size and spacing . and the shear strength of the FINISHED installations total weight including tile and tile mortar.. One would have to know every detail and compute numbers to even wager a guess..

    based on the horrendous tile install, your previous posts..... id not have much faith that all things are done correctly.

    Lets say you live in California??? some cities have lath inspections for interior shower builds for just these very reasons. Other states do not and well many folks dont bother with permits.

    Nobody here on houzz can tell you it will fail. nor the interweb.

    H Briz thanked Mint tile Minneapolis
  • 3 years ago

    Thank you again, Mint - it sounds like the wire he used would probably fail inspection and would not be considered standard. I am thinking that I may need to find a way to get my money back from him so I can redo the walls. What a nightmare. The tile guy I hired is licensed and I would think he would have to know all of this so I don't understand why he would do this. I can't imagine that he saved much money - would think the price for the correct materials is the same.

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    I've stepped into other's failed tile installations. I offered the customer a repair with no guarantee or a more expensive tear out with a gaurantee. Since I haven't gotten a callback in 6 years, she apparently made the right call with the former. You're faced with a similar choice.

  • 3 years ago

    Hi Joseph - it sounds like I need to tear out the tile walls and start over. Since this guy is licensed, do I have a case for him to pay for some or all of it? And what would be my strongest argument for him to take responsibility for the mess he left me? Is it using the wrong wire to float the wall? Or that his floated wall isn't plum (it dips in at the top at least 1/4")? Or that he didn't install the tiles level or even and the joints are all different sizes? Just the thought of now having to redo and fighting him to give me money back exhausts me even more.

  • 3 years ago

    Locale dependent you may owe him the opportunity to redo the entire thing before you get attempt to get any dollars from him.

    H Briz thanked millworkman
  • 3 years ago

    Hi Millworkman - I did give ask him to fix it. And his "fix" is the picture above, which he grouted because he thinks it is good. He has screwed up more than the tile - he told the plumber the wrong depth for the valve - the mud ring stuck out 3/4" past the float - and changed where he wanted the electrical box and made a mess of the drywall and didn't set the box right and I could go on and on with the stress from this guy. I don't have any confidence and not about to buy more tile for him to butcher or waste more time with him. I need to get this done and I think he has had plenty of opportunity to do this job right already.

  • PRO
    3 years ago

    H Briz:


    Type up a formal complaint to the licensing agency, but send it to him first with a warning that if the issues aren't addressed to your mutual satisfaction, you'll drop it in the mail.

  • 3 years ago

    Hi Joseph - I did send him a list of the problems and told him that I would go to the license board if he didn't work with me to fix this and his position is that it is fixed, fine and he "isn't worried." I think he does a lot of big commercial jobs and installed the mosaic in a matter of a few hours instead of taking the extra time to make sure it was right. He just wanted to get it done as fast as possible and doesn't care to make this right for me based on his responses to me.

    So, I am trying to find out what parts of the job that I should list in a formal complaint with small claims (told the license board doesn't have ability to make him pay) to present to the judge proof of what was substandard. I am not a pro so that is why I am hoping the pros can point out the specifics of what is wrong and point me to what I could cite as proof that it is wrong, I think I could get some of my money back.