Software
Houzz Logo Print
tamaranc

LP, Hardie, Everlast… or something else?

3 years ago

Hello all - looking for input on siding choices. We are about to start on construction of a 4000 sq ft classic-style farmhouse in a river valley in the mountains of Western NC. Fully custom build, so of course our builder will use any material we choose. His preference is LP Smart Side. We’ve built custom before, and only used Hardie. We just learned about another product, Everlast. I’d love to get your feedback on these products. Our concern with LP Smart Side is the finickiness of the product regarding installation (prime and painted, caulked) not to mention it just seems like it’s going to rot at some point. Additionally, LP does not offer a smooth board which is our aesthetic preference. We had good experiences with Hardie, but of course we weren’t the installers, and it seems like a lot of installers are just refusing to work with it now. We appreciate the installers’ concerns with silica as well as the weight of the product increasing labor costs. As I mentioned, the Everlast product is totally new to us. We do not know anyone who has used it before. From our reading, it seems as though it’s more expensive than Hardie, but requires no maintenance or painting over the lifetime of the home. What else should we be considering? I’d love to hear some recent, first-hand experiences with these products.
Thank you in advance for your time!