I agree, the color that is there, looks good. White will not look good. A darker brownish color from the brick, would also look good, if it really needs to be painted. Leave the windows white like they are. And leave the columns white too. Everything just like it is. As for the door, if you really want to paint it, paint it a bright color so it will stand out and lead guests to your door.

I like the mocha fascia with black windows & a black door. But if you want to be edgy, I love black walls. It’s not for everyone but, I love it. You could also do something like this. But not sure if you’d like it with more brick though.

Probably too late for your quick help request, but I would want to change the orange, too. I would at least darken it to match the brick, or maybe something more like this. I like the dark trim here:

Here's the house in Alabaster & Black...

I dont like the alabaster on your house. Its a beautiful color, but, it makes your house look disconnected.