Thank you for your response!

Agree with the light gray. I would paint the aprons under the two longer windows the same color as the brick so they would disappear. Then add shutters to fit the exact size of the windows. Good luck!

It feels to me that your shutters don't work with the front windows. They're either to long or too short, not to mention too narrow. I might shorten them and put some shingles, or something, in the bland, blank space below the windows.

Taupe would work with your brick

or muted green

Here is sage green

I'd consider a bluish gray or grayish blue. Peach might also be good, but you need a fairly muted shade.

I would start the face lift by removing the long shutters. They don't fir the windows...too short.

Leave the box paneling white.

Paint the two side shutters white. Remove the shutters on the little window (they don't fir the window, either...too narrow.

Paint the vertical paneling white. Choose the white paint to work with the white of the windows.

Big job to restain the shingles, so leave it until last. You may not need to do anything. Weathered cedar shingles turn gray, anyway and all shingles on the house will be the same color.

Thanks everyone! Lots of great ideas to think about!