Lower one

Second (lower) photo. No question.

Another vote for the second one.

Bottom picture!

The lower one for sure!

I prefer the bottom picture

Definitely the lower one with the cohesive roofing material.

The pics are all dark. Everyone, including me likes the one with less dark siding. Maybe you should pick something less dark and dreary for the dark parts.

3 siding types are too many in my opinion. Lose one of them. And something needs to be brighter with more color.

The bottom one. The proportions of the siding finishes are better.

Lower pic