Software
Houzz Logo Print
melissaaipapa

Rosa foetida (good); box (bad; also OT)

I have a couple of negatives re the garden on my mind, both burdening me. One is so negative I don't want to talk about it; the other is box and the current box moth infestation. This is my equivalent to John's losing gigantic climbing roses to a Polar Vortex: hard, and for a while you feel blackly discouraged. Last year we gave up spraying for box moth, which we had been doing for perhaps seven years or so previously. The resulting damage was real, but tolerable. This year, instead, the box moth has hit its stride. Some plants are completely defoliated, almost all have a degree of damage; my fear is, none will escape, either being killed, or so badly harmed they will lose all their ornamental value. We have perhaps 80-90 box plants in the garden, many used for hedging and a fair size. I love box, or I did back when I could grow it, and there's no ready replacement for it. All the same, I think I'm going to have to find one, My current idea, if it can be called that, is gradually to cull the box, cutting the worst-hit ones to the ground, and replanting with something (what?) suitable. If a plant isn't badly damaged, I'll leave it.

The garden is magnificent this spring, by the way.,box moth notwithstanding. My capacity for gratitude is at a low point at the moment.

Now, Rosa foetida. We planted this early on, in a part of the garden that, basically, was one of our (many) failures: the plants failed to grow, died, the weeds flourished, etc. So we did what we do, which was abandon that area and work in other parts of the garden where things were going better. This morning I went back take a look at it. Rosa foetida and its double but otherwise very similar relative 'Persian Yellow' were in fine fettle: healthy, suckering out from their original point of planting, full of buds and, in R. foetida's case, showing its first blooms. Fine roses, full of character and beauty. They're healthy in our climate, not particularly susceptible to the fungal infections that I gather plague them elsewhere. There were also a few other rose survivors, possibly the start of a renewed bed, and a clematis, not yet in bloom but a large-flowered kind, that looked quite happy. The weeds are more lush than they once were. I enjoyed the meadow flowers in the beds and walks--really, they are beautiful--and the shrubs and trees that back the bed are growing, and in time will offer protection and mulch. So, perhaps it's time to start thinking about starting work again on this area.

Comments (6)

  • 3 years ago

    What a shame about your box hedges, Melissa. I've no idea what you might replace them with, aside from a Japanese holly that I saw last year at Christianson's Nursery in the Skagit Valley when I was looking at interesting bushes there. However, I'm not sure how it would respond to your conditions or being sheared back. It looked wonderful when taking its own form though.

  • 3 years ago

    I love your posts, Melissa. I am sorry about your box troubles.

    Other years your garden and mine are synchronized. This year my Rosa Foetida are way slower with our cold Spring. I love them here too.

  • 3 years ago

    Oh Melissa, I'm so sorry to hear that you are losing a favorite plant that makes up a great part of your garden. I have no advice, only sympathy. I am looking out the window at a 30+ yr. old camellia, about 9' tall that has now lost all of its buds and most of its leaves. I don't know if it will come back. I am so, so sad but still let myself hope a little bit.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    The yin and yang of life is painfully evident in our gardens where we would like to exert some control in order to fulfill our vision, and literally dozens of things can go wrong, although thankfully not all at the same time. Global warming in now another factor, and who knows how that will play out. I'm learning (the hard way) that setting aside expectations, and enjoying the beauty to be found here and there, which by and large is best achieved by working with nature, and not against it, is much the least painful way for me to go forward. Easy for me to say as I don't have a gorgeous garden as you do, Melissa, but I feel your pain and hope that nature overall will be kind to you and all the beauty you've created over the years, with a great deal of hard work. May the garden gods bless you and show a great deal of mercy.

  • 3 years ago

    Oh, Lord! I just lost answer I was writing!

    In brief, thanks to you all, K S, Sheila, Karen, Ingrid, for your wise and kind answers, coming from those who know. Ingrid, I hope your roses grow and bloom! I was writing about possible substitutes, which I won't set down again, and mentioning how much excellent sense Sheila shows in growing Rosa foetida, and mentioning the other forms, 'Persian Yellow' and 'Austrian Copper' and wondering whether she grows them, too.

  • 3 years ago

    Yes, Melissa, I have them all. None blooming yet this year. Mine are all doing very well here. I also have Hazeldean. I love them all.