Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_29405466

Separate volume controls vs diverter for separate shower functions?

3 years ago

I'm choosing shower fixtures, and I'm looking at thermostatic controls, so separate volume and temp controls for fixed showerhead and a handheld, which will be on a different wall of the shower.


In one plumbing store they recommended a Hansgrohe fixture that had a single volume knob with a diverter from which you'd control both the fixed and handheld showerheads. That seemed fine to me. I like the brand, and the controls seemed easy to use.


At the other store, they encouraged me to get separate volume knobs--one for the fixed showerhead and one for the handheld. (I saw a California Faucets setup like this, which is a great brand but a lot more expensive than the Hansgrohe.) They insisted that if you have a single volume knob with a diverter instead of totally separate volume controls, you'd only get 85% of the total waterflow available to you in your shower, as opposed to 100% if you have two separate controls. Is that true, or is it hogwash? (It sounded like hogwash, but I'm prepared to be wrong.)


Seems like separate volume controls could be slightly more convenient, but only if I'm able to put the volume control for the handheld shower right next to it, since it would be near a bench at the far end of the shower from the fixed showerhead. But most setups I see have even the separate volume controls all grouped underneath the main fixed showerhead.


Thoughts?

Comments (12)

  • 3 years ago

    We have a single volume control knob with the diverter on the handheld itself. No noticeable difference in the water flow, and I can't imagine why there would be one since it's just rerouting the water. I will say that our shower heads are all on the same wall in a relatively small shower. I can see that a volume knob for the handheld might be helpful if it's in another area of the shower, but you'd do it for convenience in that case, I think.

  • 3 years ago

    They told you a lie to upgrade your expenditure.

  • 3 years ago

    Look up the specification sheet of the valves in question, those will list the flow rates. I don't see any reason you'd get limited flow rate.

  • 3 years ago

    We have completely separate temp and volume controls for the main shower head and for the handheld, because it was allowed by code in our current state. If 2 people shower they can set their own temp and volume. My DH likes the water full blast and too cold for me.


    When we lived in CA we were only allowed one set of controls, with a diverter, for the two fixtures.


    What are you allowed to do by code?

    How do you want it to function?

  • 3 years ago

    Yes, this information appears to be a real fairy tale from a salesperson who, by the way, works at Ferguson. She reported it as if it was boilerplate, too, which makes me think it's how they're instructing their salespeople to describe these things. I will not be buying stuff there.


    @chispa I would use the fixed showerhead most of the time, but the handheld would be in case anyone is incapacitated (I've been on crutches before, so I know what it's like to try and shower while injured...). The shower itself will be zero entry, approx 7ft long and 3.5 feet wide, and there's a fixed bench at one end. I plan to put the handheld near the bench, probably ~5ft away from the main shower controls. I wondered if I would want to be able to control the volume from the bench rather than 5ft away. It's not imperative, though. Other than that, if someone needs help bathing, the handheld is useful for that, and for cleaning the shower. Other than if I were to need help, no one would be using this shower but me. I'd like to keep it simple and maybe it's not such a huge space that I really need the second set of controls?


    @stm25rs When I looked at max gpm on different systems, the difference was more from brand to brand and seemed to have no relation to whether there was one volume control with a diverter, or separate volume controls. For example, a Calif Faucet system showed 7.4 gpm at 60psi, with a single volume control with a diverter--but with 2 separate controls it's 6.8gpm. Hansgrohe, meanwhile, seem to be 6-7gpm, depending on the fixture, and all those I looked at are single controls with diverters. Meanwhile all of these are water-saver faucets, so I doubt you're actually getting 7gpm in normal use.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Each fixture is limited in output to 2.5 in most of the US and much less in CA. You cannot ask a water heater to run 3 2.5 fixtures simultaneously unless you want to run the whole home out of hot water in less than 10 minutes. You have to understand water delivery systems as a whole to plan this. You can't just go buy valves that "can" work with 6.8, because you will never actually get 6.8 out of any fixture hooked up to them.


    What size water heater are you planning? 2 100 gallon? 2 tankless? You will have to upsize the drains to deal with multiple fixtures being used as well. Those systems requirements are what take any of this up to the luxury level. It isn't just the fixtures themselves. It's all the upgrades required to run it.

    2rickies thanked User
  • 3 years ago

    @User thank you for pointing that out. I meant to add that these fixtures are pretty much all restricted to 1.75, so i'm even less sure what it was that the salesperson thought she was telling me. I got those higher gpm numbers from the capacity listed in specs, but obviously that's a maximum ability, not a desirable use situation or one that the fixtures would even allow. I was only trying to see if there was any evidence that what the salesperson told me had any basis in something she might have misunderstood (but, no). As for our hot water heater, it's not going to be oversized. I can't remember exactly; it's maybe 80 gallons. It's connected with a geothermal system.

  • 3 years ago


    Build is a good vendor for shower systems where you can specify the Valve Type and other parameters (I installed the Hansgrohe Croma Thermostatic Showerpipe 220 which has a shower head-off-handshower control and temperature control. It doesn't have a volume control because "full blast" isn't the "full blast" of yore).

    2rickies thanked wdccruise
  • 3 years ago

    Thank you for the links, @wdccruise, that's helpful!


    @chispa I definitely plan to get a thermostatic system with separate volume control. This is the one I'm leaning toward: https://www.build.com/hansgrohe-15714/s1523526?uid=3584050&searchId=INUxSuxmso

  • 3 years ago

    @2rickies, I used a couple of different fixture brands in my previous house and had no issues with them. In the new house we used all Brizo plumbing fixtures and no issues in 15 months. The Hansgrohe looks nice and should work well.

  • 3 years ago

    Note that Brizo is Delta's fancy-pants brand and similar -- and in some cases identical -- products can be bought under both brands but at higher prices from Brizo. For example, the Delta R10000-UNBX rough-in valve is $42 while the identical Brizo R60000-UNBX is $63.