I like the first one which cylinder lights looks unique not the same round or box style. Works with the arches of your windows and the arch window above the door.

I do not think either are modern and the front is very busy so IMO a really simple rectangualr fixture a bit longer than what you have and in black fo sure.

for me, scale is the problem, and if you went oversized it would look better.

Patricia Colwell Consulting, do you think it needs to have any arches on the fixture, or is the rectangular shape alone ok? Thank you!

RL Relocation LLC, I agree that the light needs to be larger. Thank you!

Who makes that first one, the round one?

I used a similar fixture from Savoy House on the house we built in 2021 and it is a pain to replace bulbs due to the way the light is designed. There is a huge risk of the glass cylinder falling out. So make sure you understand how a fixture has to be disassembled to replace the bulbs.