I would choose between the two lightest colors you show.

...paint the vanity one of the other colors.

Choose towels, rugs, art and accessories first, and paint last.

Thank you for your suggestion @ShadyWillowFarm. I love white fluffy towels, not sure about the rugs yet, and here is my print. White spa like shower curtain.

I can’t tell which sample is which, but if you’re not changing the vanity, I would go with one that has more green and less blue.

I can’t tell which one is what. Best way to sample is put paint on a large foam board (or purchase Samplize) and hold it right up to the fixed elements (tile, vanity, etc.) that will be staying. Trying to pick it with the gold background is no help and not necessary because it won’t be part of the final design. If I have to choose from the current samples, I’d say the long one on the bottom.

Here is the bottom color above the trim that we are keeping. Thoughts?

Can you paint the samples on heavy weight art paper so that you can move them around? It’s important to look at them with your fixed elements: vanity, countertop, wall tile, trim etc.

It is difficult to tell because they are painted on your beige wall. It distorts the color. As has been suggested, get some big white foam core boards and paint each color on them. I would be inclined to go light vs. dark. You don’t have a window in the room, correct? That means all colors will read darker….

Thanks. I’ll pickup a white boards and paint them and repost. Thank you so much @texmax13 and ptreckel.