Software
Houzz Logo Print
mischievous_magpie

Best bands from this year

3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago

Almost all of my roses have been purchased as bands. Because of winter here and me being unsure of how hardy a new rose will really be, the first season's growth does not accurately tell me how a rose will do here. I've had roses explode with growth in season 1 only to struggle to recover after the first winter, as well as roses that hardly grew in season 1 that picked up steam each year since. Nevertheless, it's still fun to observe which ones grew well or bloomed well in the first year. So the best new bands out of the batch I bought this year:
- Hera's Song (I think): it has bloomed really well in large clusters a couple of times since planting. Also nice and fragrant already! Still a small thing overall, though.
- Paul Ricault: lots of (very thorny) new growth.
- Isabella Skinner: Loads of growth! And not just one or two canes, but many have gotten 4' already.
Nothing is guaranteed, but I've got my fingers crossed that 2024 will be good for these roses.
So, how about yours? Any standout bands this year?

Comments (24)

  • 3 years ago

    For me Alba Semi-Plena is really taking off, as is Paul’s Lemon Pillar. Blush Noisette has been slow.

    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked oursteelers 8B PNW
  • 3 years ago

    Interesting that you got Paul's Lemon Pillar, I looked at that one a lot the very first year I was online shopping for roses. I never see anyone mention it on here, so I'm looking forward to your photos/assessment!

  • 3 years ago

    Oh nice!


    My Connie’s Sandstorm and Marion Ross have grown great. Never would have known they were tiny things a few months ago.

    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked Liz 9b Sunset 14
  • 3 years ago

    I got a hand full of bands from Roses Unlimited this past spring. They have all done very well.

    Orange Morsdag---It is planted in a 10 Gal. fake wood pot. It has been steadily growing all summer. It has completely filled the pot.

    Summer Snow---Same kind of pot as above. Great growth all summer. Great rose

    Brigadoon---Same kind of pot. This one has been just a little slower to grow and put out blooms. I have had probably 8/10 blooms this summer with only 2 big, strong basil canes. I'll give it all the time it needs.

    Whisky Mac---Same type of pot. This was my runt. I was only charged 1/2 price for it. It just sat there for over a month, then BOOM!! It took off. 2 big basil canes this summer and another pushing it's way up.

    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked Ken Wilkinson
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Hands down, Oh My, a band from High Country Roses, grew beyond expectations. There has been not one single speck of black spot on Oh My. Queen Of Elegance, on the other hand, also a band from High Country Roses, has been so unspectacular that I doubt it will survive winter. It came tiny, maybe three inches tall and when depotted, the soil fell apart. It was planted in a very focal spot in my rose bed, and its 8 inches of spindly scrawniness, with no effort to make even one bloom this season is all I expect right now, cold weather soon approaching when everything comes to an end for the 2023 season.

    So, Oh My has shown great progress, with expectations of greater things in 2024. Queen Of Elegance.... well, time will tell.

    Moses

    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked Moses, Pitt PA, cold W & warm/humid S z6
  • 3 years ago

    Watch your mouth moses, LOL!

  • 3 years ago

    Moses, what a shame about QoE, and the soil fell apart and everything! I would expect a better sized band from HCR. Sadly they never did right by me after I asked (twice) about their sending me the wrong rose. I never did get the Lilian Gibson I paid for. :/ Maybe they're having an off year.


    Ken, I have heard that adding balsamic vinegar to the water and scratching some mozzarella into the soil can really boost basil cane growth. Sorry, I'll see myself out, goodnight folks.

  • 3 years ago

    Good puns!

    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked librarian_gardner_8b_pnw
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Moses, QofE is a slow very very slow grower from band size. I had a better sized band of it from HCR that I planted last year and it is still small this year, in it's second year. It's under 2 ft tall and only 1 ft wide...and in my very moderate easy rose growing climate! For comparison, other bands I planted in 2022 are bigger than grafted bare roots that I planted this spring. I've planted so many bands from HCR and this is the only one that's been like this.

    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked librarian_gardner_8b_pnw
  • 3 years ago

    The grammar police... to serve and correct :-D

  • 3 years ago

    Hi, MM. I buy a lot of roses as bands, too. Those that have done well their very first summer here (in no particular order):

    Ringo/Eye of the Tiger- This one came from Jung Seed who I think might buy odd lots left over from other vendors. I have bought roses from them several times over the years and the packaging is never the same, even for two roses in the same order. Although, everything I got from them lives and does fairly well, including this one. I put it inside a 3' wire cage as protection against deer and it has outgrown it. The deer have very thoughtfully pruned it to be cage-sized again twice. A single rose, it has been the most frequent bloomer of all the bands, with exceptional health and vigor in spite of our odd weather this season. It's an interesting rose although its thorns are concerning.

    Belinda's Blush- From HCR, it is happy, very healthy and has outgrown its cage as well. It has bloomed a little and the bloom is as pretty as you'd expect from a sport of Belinda's Dream. I have hope that next year it will really begin to strut its stuff. So far I'm pleased.

    The next two are mini's (sort of):

    Whimsy- Also from HCR. I had Whimsy once before but lost it. It got larger than most of my other mini's but it was an example of excellent health and always in bloom. I think this one took a few weeks to settle in but it started growing and blooming the way the old one did. It has just finished a flush and has new basal growth.

    Petite Peach- Also from HCR. I really had no expectations for this one, I just needed a soft orange or apricot small rose. Like a cross between a mini and a ground cover rose, it's growing wider than tall. The flowers are peach pink little pompons that lighten to a soft apricot as they age. There are usually a few roses blooming at a time so the color variation is interesting. It is healthy and happy, not even suffering much when it was swamped by salvia and poppies.


    Some things worth noting- I have only own-root roses. I am nearly out of room so I don't even order most of my roses till late April/early May when I have an idea what might not have survived. I grow them in pots after receiving them for at least a month.


    Oh, MM, don't give up hope on getting the correct rose from HCR. I ordered Distant Drums last year and got something else instead. I let them know but never heard anything more about it and thought that was the end of it. Several weeks ago, surprise! - I received a package from them containing DD.



    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked Karen Service
  • 3 years ago

    re Paul's Lemon Pillar -- it is hardy here in my central Michigan garden. I give it no protection, no spray, it is planted in the open, and it has maintained a reasonable 7' height with three sturdy canes.

    Beautiful clear yellow flowers; heavy spring and fall flush with steady floral presence all summer. No fragrance, or slight at best. I have had it for about 20 years.

    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked rosesmi5a
  • 3 years ago

    umbra from rogue valley - grew a new cane about 4' high, very vigorous - think this is going to be a great rose in a couple years

    savannah from high country - bloomed all summer and made a tidy little bush about 2'

    high country banshee from high country - grew a new cane about 3' high in a really tough spot, can't imagine what it would do in my main bed that gets 10+ hours of sun


    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked Josg Maggsib
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    @Josg Maggsib I also have High Country Banshee, nice to see someone else growing it! In year 3 it's finally grown a new basal and started picking up some steam, but not a crazy fast grower yet. However I favor this rose quite a bit so I have lots of patience for slower growth on it :)


  • 3 years ago

    I’m gonna be so bummed if Paul’s Lemon Pillar doesn’t have fragrance! I got it because it is advertised as having a strong scent!!

    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked oursteelers 8B PNW
  • 3 years ago

    @oursteelers 8B PNW I used to grow PLP (lost to RRV). It's a gorgeous rose, more white with a blush of pastel yellow. For me, it did have a nice scent, but far from "wafting". You had to be near the plant in full flush, or actually sniff individual blooms. But yes, it smells of lemons. And J&J baby powder, lol. The scent was strongest, like most roses, on humid days, of which there is no shortage here! I think you'll be pleased once it matures and gives you enough blooms to scent the immediate vicinity.

    Back on topic, my most robust band this year has been Paul Barden's Oshun. The thing was planted into a gallon pot a month ago, and needs to be up-potted already. I might even go ahead and plant it in the ground, which I don't normally do with bands this late in the year. I'm *hoping* for at least one bloom before frost, but it's putting so much effort into growing that it's not a sure thing.

    My next best grower has been Ivor's Rose/Flamenco Rosita. It's quickly going to be a monster, but a beautiful monster indeed. It came with a bud, has already bloomed, and is already producing another. This is my second FR. I spotted RRV on my semi-mature one, cut out the infected cane, and haven't seen a return of symptoms, but I wanted a "clean" plant that I can feel safe in propagating.

    Both of these roses came from Long Ago Roses. Linda has always supplied roses that have been among my best at getting established and taking off. I really hate she's gone to mostly selling on eBay, but she's hoping to retire soon, and eBay has certainly been more profitable for her. I wish her the best.

    Another great grower is Magic Wand. I got this one from Paul Barden, so not a commercial grower. But with Paul, I know I'm getting a good plant, and true to name! Magic Wand is a very rare Moore mini-climber/shrub, and it came with buds, has bloomed three times, and tripled in size. It's going to be a winner. But as far as I know, Paul is the only source besides a nursery in Alaska that doesn't ship to the lower 48. Possibly Burlington carries it, since she has so many Moore roses. I haven't seen her miniature list recently.


    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked fig_insanity Z7b E TN
  • 3 years ago

    Magpie, gorgeous rose, and I love the name High Country Banshee. Does this mean it will grow gigantic and haunt you at night. I can think of worse things than being haunted by a rose. Diane

    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked Diane Brakefield
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Diane, actually I bought it because I was confident that it would indeed grow gigantic (for here), I'll let you know if a haunting begins. I think banshees are known for shrieking so... Let's hope it doesn't do that lol.


    @fig_insanity Z7b E TN How come you usually don't plant this late? For your zone I'm surprised to hear that.

  • 3 years ago

    I see! Thank you for taking the time to explain.

  • 3 years ago

    I never plant anything in autumn because I've lost too many perennials that way. Diane

    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked Diane Brakefield
  • 3 years ago

    BTW... The music lovers in my household were excited to read the title of this thread when they saw it among my email notifications. They were expecting scintillating reviews of what's new on the music scene and were so disappointed to find out what we call "bands".

    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked Karen Service
  • 3 years ago

    🤣🤣🤣

    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked librarian_gardner_8b_pnw
  • 3 years ago

    My two bands of Bill Warriner from Rogue Valley Roses in December were great when delivered, and have grown extremely well. I used to order from them a lot, but have been hesitant with their mis-ID issues. These were perfect and correct. (I already grow it).

    Mischievous Magpie (CO 5b) thanked susan9santabarbara