First dith those silly shutters the house is modern the shutters are not. Why did you not get a factory finish on the garage door and front door.And of now they are being painted IMO you can still change that. As for siding color I like the white with the style of house but not so sure about the front door and garage door style .

I completely agree, however we are limited to leaving the shutters at this point. It has been approved by our HOA and changes to those items cannot be made. I just need advice for colors. Please help!

between windows the same color as you choose for window trim.

Black for trim and shutters.

I would petition the HOA to remove the shutters. Black between the double windows. A natural or light stain (not paint) on the wood at the peaks, above the windows and around the front door. White as shown for the main body of the house -- it looks good with the current black accents.