Software
Houzz Logo Print
moneymm

Helping friend with layout ideas.

2 years ago

So currently my friends house has walls and doors everywhere. every room on the first floor is closed in. I am thinking best option is to knock down the 2 walls running parallel to the front of the house. the only walls remaining would be the stairs in the center of the house.


The one downside to this, is that the architect said, they would have to put a post about 18" past where the stairs end now, so it would make the hallway about 40" wide and a bit ackward. I know 40" should be plenty to pass thru, but something about doing it this way just feels weird.


what do you think, is this the best way to open up the space?


instead of extending the wall where the stairs are, 18" and hiding the post in the wall, should i just put a post in the kitchen and build it into an island?


only one post is needed, but do you think i should extend both stair walls to make it even?


house now






house after knocking down walls and extending the stairs back 18" towards the back of the house..






Comments (15)

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    Have your friend listen to their architect and invite their friend over after the construction is completed.

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    Your friend's best bet is to rob a bank, or do a teardown. That much room scrambling and alterations is likely to cost more than building new.

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    You, the architect and your friend should take your plans down to the building department and see what they have to say about moving the stairs. You can't do a thing without a permit, anyway.

  • 2 years ago

    No way that those ideas ever happen. Not without spending more money than building new, plus hiring an actual architect, and not ”a friend”. Really, unskilled drafters are now trolling online forums instead of using the ridiculousness of AI?

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    Are those drawings by the "architect" ?

  • 2 years ago

    You can't turn a house into a loft apartment. But you can take the current layout, and without knocking down any walls, make it feel more open and fluid.


    Check out the pink lines below. Widen doorway between kitchen and dining room as much as possible to make it feel like one space. Add a regular sized doorway between the mudroom and dining area. And add as wide a doorway as you can between the living room and the back room to make that area feel as much like one large space as possible.


    Brainstorm these ideas in the space with a structural engineer and architect.




  • 2 years ago

    sorry i should i said, this is what the architect came up with, but he didnt seem that great. but he was already paid for a previous job for this one, so he is the one he is using. anyway, i have gotten great feedback in the past on here. hoping for some more of the same.


    instead of extending the wall where the stairs are, 18" and hiding the post in the wall, should i just put a post in the kitchen and build it into an island?

    only one post is needed, but do you think i should extend both stair walls to make it even?

  • 2 years ago

    Sorry, but…this appears to be an engineering issue. One lesson I have learned as a “friend” of those interested in my “ideas” for their space is to recognize my own limitations: What I don’t know. What I love about this forum is how much I am learning about what I don’t know!!! And the Pros on here are very insightful. I would back away from this project, but offer support to your friend.

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    "this is what the architect came up with, but he didn't seem that great. but he was already paid for a previous job for this one, so he is the one he is using. anyway"

    Your friend will save money by walking away and starting new with another architect. The current one is really more of a butcher.

  • 2 years ago

    It would help if the rooms were labeled: some are obvious, but not all.


    What do you mean by "extending the stairs 18 inches"? Is that the architect's idea, and has it been costed out? Stairs are very code dependent, which codes change over time. Old stairs are grandfathered in, but touch them and you have to comply with current code.

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    Sometimes if I wait long enough other people will say what I am thinking.

  • 2 years ago

    ARG -- but I thought there had to be cookies. All the best brainstorming involves cookies. Unless they involve wine. One or the other.


  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    ^^^^ Yes, definitely cookies. But no donuts. Whenever we have those I can't get the bumwad (tracing paper) unstuck from my fingers!

    And it's looking like we may another drive by poster.

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    I ahve no clue the drawings are uselss no mwasurements no names of spaces and your friend should get an architect and an interior designer since you do not know what can and can't be done . You do not knock down walls with no undertsnading of the resulting work .IMO the architect ? you have needs to be doing more than 18" post if those walls are removed .

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert