Software
Houzz Logo Print
lucy_vanandel

Advice please on this fireplace surround?

2 years ago

Our fireplace surround has been primer only for years because we cannot decide what to do. Paint color to match existing white trim or matching the tile. Removing tile is not an option. What about the wall above? Leave it the same as other walls? Thanks for considering my question.

paint in a color similar to the tile
paint to match white trim

Comments (16)

  • 2 years ago

    Paint it white to match the trim or paint it the same color as the walls. You don't need a third paint color going on here. The tiles are gorgeous and the will pop against either the trim or wall color. You have a lovely pallet going on here.

    Lucy Van Andel thanked Kendrah
  • PRO
    2 years ago

    I'm not thrilled with the primer white, so no to more white to match the trim. Painting to match the tile wouldn't be quite right with the warm floor and walls. So I'll offer a third option... a soft sage or mossy green that compliments the tile and floor colors.

    Lucy Van Andel thanked beesneeds
  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    Paint to match trim. I like your art work. Remove all those objects in front of it so it can stand alone, or with just one or two tall objects on the side. Think about leaning it as below or hang it lower so it connects to tiles. All those objects make the mantel look cluttery and detract from the art.

    58th Street · More Info


    Fill your firebox with white birch logs or chunky logs. Remove the plant off the hearth and add a basket of logs instead.

    Mid Century Master Bedroom · More Info



    Striped Wicker Storage Basket, Small · More Info


  • 2 years ago

    in your case, I would find a soft green in the tile and paint the Mantle, surround and the chimney for a great accent to your white walls. Edit the decor on the mantle. looks like a lot of stuff pushed against the perimeter of the room (that small table with the lamp, find a prominent place for it in the room. move the plant to a window area... it's un natural to have a plant in front of the firebox, Faux or real.

    Lucy Van Andel thanked Lyn Nielson
  • 2 years ago

    Inviting pleasant space.

    Paint the mantel piece same as trim or same as wall color.

    The art is very nice,but may look better if same size as the fireplace opening.

    Mantel is too cluttered .

    I find that items placed at the outermost edges of the mantel top tend to look unbalanced ,haphazard and weaken the overall vista.

    Keep items in line with the vertical surround to strenghten the dsplay.

    My opinion only!



    Lucy Van Andel thanked rosiembog
  • 2 years ago

    I’m not really fond of just painted drywall over mantels (funny because I currently have painted drywall over three out of four fireplaces in my house - however, all four fireplaces are being updated shortly). However, if you have a nice/interesting piece of art (that is sized correctly), the drywall just recedes into the background.


    Re: my first thought was to paint it to match your trim color. However, I think that pulling out the soft green from your tile - and using it instead of matching your white trim, might work better. However - I am not a designer - and am having trouble deciding a similar issue right now!



    I agree that you need to change the items on your mantel. Right now, it looks cluttered.


    I think that your art would look better if it was in a larger frame = in order to fill up more of the space above the mantel.


    I wouldn’t place anything directly under the art - only add a small grouping off to the side. There are many examples re: styling your mantel in previous houzz threads.

    Lucy Van Andel thanked dani_m08
  • 2 years ago

    I like the idea of finding a green that matches the green tiles. Paint the mantle and surround.

    Your wall color is fine.

    I don’t like white with your tiles.Another idea would be a paint in the same family but darker as your wall color.

    Lucy Van Andel thanked eld6161
  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    I’d be tempted to paint the mantle and all the trim work in the room a greenish color that works with the tile and then paint the walls a lighter shade of that color if that is at all possible with your furniture.

    I’d paint the trim that is currently white but not the wood tones.

    Lucy Van Andel thanked lisaam
  • 2 years ago



    here the walls are similar to what you currently have.

    Lucy Van Andel thanked lisaam
  • 2 years ago

    A lot of people seem to be recommending green. While there does look like there is some green in the tile, I wouldn't go too green. More like a taupey beige that leans a little green, dark enough to have some contrast with the tile and set it off, but not really dark.

    Lucy Van Andel thanked kandrewspa
  • 2 years ago

    Here's some photoshop options - the sage and tan are color matched to the tiles, and the dark one is just another option.






    Lucy Van Andel thanked Susan L
  • 2 years ago

    Wow! Thanks Susan- those photoshopped images really help. I like the last one because you cleaned up my clutter! 😁

  • 2 years ago

    I appreciate all the suggestions! This is my first time asking for advice on Houzz. I have a game plan now!

  • 2 years ago

    I agree with all of you that suggested painting to complement tile. Also great ideas to move plant, basket of birch, larger art and remove small items.

  • 2 years ago

    You’re welcome! If you want to see another colors let me know. Paste an image of a swatch here, and I can use it in the photoshop file.

    Lucy Van Andel thanked Susan L