The plaid is a different vibe than the rest of your space. I would recover the cushion in a solid - blue-grey-green shade. You have a lovely home and fantastic decorating instinct!

Thank you! I figured it was the plaid. Seems more obvious now!

I got some sample fabric. I know pictures don't always look the same as in real life, but I tried to get several shots. All in the same order. Any advise welcome! I'm leaning towards the 3 middle ones, and specifically the darker one.

I would choose the lightest one.

I'm still undecided. I have 2 family members telling me the dark one, I don't know why it's so hard to make choices! Just thought I'd throw it out there to see if I get any more feedback!

Just thought I'd post a photo of my update. I think it's an improvement. I can always change the material again if I have to as it's a DIY job!

I would do them in a solid not a print fabric… I think it takes away from all the lovely pillows…I like the medium gray..second in from the right.