I would change them out for square or round chrome framed mirrors.

Are they seen together I see a wall so how obvious is the different mirror . I dislike J&J batrhooms and by the looks of the size of the vanities you could have done 2 actual batrhooms . IMO the only people using these 2 spaces are kids I hope and they don't care.IMO just get another frameless plate glass mirror to replace the one that broke

The framed mirrors took the spot light in the 90s. I am all for practical. A small child using that sink needs the mirror to reach the back splash. Some day you might have two teen girls wanting to stand side by side and do their hair. I don't know why more mirror ever when out of style. Fill the space!!!

I appreciate a nice framed mirror, a large rectangular or square mirror, not circular.

I'd go with large, fill-the-space mirrors -- but frame them. Large mirrors are so much more practical in that they allow you to see more of yourself /your outfit. They also make the space look larger, and they don't go in-and-out of style; they are the standard.

@Patricia Colwell Consulting

I dislike J&J baths, too. House is 25 years old, and I can think of many things I would do differently. The next owners might have kids, but we typically have adult guests using them for a few weeks out of the year. I want our guests to be comfortable and enjoy coming for a visit. So, we removed the outdated wallpaper and tile, updated the light fixtures, countertops, commode, cabinet hardware. Thankfully the bedrooms are comfortably sized. I appreciate your feedback and that of all the others who have responded.

I guess I am the odd man out I like a big mirror no frame to fill the space above the vanity why have a mirror framed if it is not needed to be framed .