I love the look of the current garage door. I’m assuming that there is something wrong with it that can’t be repaired. Is that true? I don’t think the brown sample is the right shade, and the almond isn’t right either. Do you have a photo of the replacement garage door?

I also like the look of the current garage door. If you're going to replace, go with a mid to dark brown. But, there's too much red in your brown sample chip. Usually there's a few browns to choose from -- what else do they have? You need to get the tone similar to the brown trim you've got.

What about black?

Garage door and trim directly around it should be same color as house especially on a front load garage

I like the garage door you already have too. Is there a reason, it needs to be changed, and I agree with the others, the two colors you are thinking of using, do not go well with your house.