Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_318001981

Walnut and Alder Stains

We found a 50/50 mix stain on Clear Alder and a Pecan stain on Walnut shown in the picture and we like both colors. Could these go well together in a kitchen or is intermingling the two stains not recommended because the grains are different?

Comments (2)

  • last year

    As FRH above has already commented, you need to use the different wood species + stains very thoughtfully in order for it to work in your kitchen. I've seen a few kitchens that have used two wood species (typically, one stain is lighter and one is medium to darker) - it seems like they were larger kitchens that leaned a bit more modern than simply transitional.


    I wouldn't ever try to mix wood species/stains in a kitchen without advice from an actual kitchen designer (not someone who works for the cabinet manufacturer).


    What are your plans for flooring and countertop material? Those two decisions will impact whether two wood species/stains will work in your kitchen. If you are using another wood stain on the floor + bold countertop slabs (or one type of slab for your island and a different countertop slab for your perimeter cabinets), it seems like it could become very busy.


    Obviously, your backsplash selection will also need to be considered in the design of your kitchen - but that should be selected last (unless you are running your countertop up the wall as your backsplash - you'll need to have those slabs held at the time you order your countertops - you can't just decide later to use slabs for your backsplash also - whether natural stone or man made material - because you need the lot #s to be the same for the countertop slabs + the backsplash slabs).


    I have some examples saved from when my neighbor was thinking about using two different wood species + stains in her upcoming kitchen renovation. In the end, she decided not to do it (her CKD put together an attractive design - she used a flat panel door style + solid white quartz countertop) - however, my neighbor's husband was VERY vocal about how he didn't like the mixed wood species/stains for the cabinets (even though they had made an agreement that she had final approval re: materials/design for their kitchen renovation while he he had final approval over the new patio/outdoor kitchen).





    The dark cabinets below are stained (Onxy) - not painted black.


    I can't remember if the kitchen below is a mix of wood veneers and solid wood doors - or if the lighter color doors are laminate (made to resemble wood):



    This next example is a traditional kitchen that incorporates two wood species/stains.


    Here is another photo of the above kitchen - it's pretty large.


    The next kitchen also has painted cabinets added into the mix of different wood stained cabinets on the island vs. the stained wood used for the perimeter cabinets (however, since the painted cabinetry appears to be the same white that was also used on the rest of the walls/vent hood/ceiling - it doesn't make the kitchen look busy):


    Repeating the second wood stain color that was used on the island for the stacked glass cabinets in the next kitchen seems a bit odd to me - but I am not a huge risk taker:


  • last year

    I wouldn't do it. It would look like you either couldn't make up your mind or ran out of one material and had to substitute another. It's different with furniture (non-fixed elements), those don't have to be matchy-matchy, but with cabinets? No. I'd stick with all the same. Frankly, the inspo photos Dani posted look awful, very disjointed. Except that last one with the dark island, light perimeter. Now there's where it might work - doing only an island in a different stain, but even then it'd have to be just right, like in Dani's last photo above.


    FWIW: I very much like the sample with the dark stain, it's a beautiful color, has so much more depth to it than the light sample.