DH changed our counter tops and back splash. "Difficulty" no doubt depends on the material you are choosing to put in/take out. Our old popped out as they were laminate on plywood attached to the base cupboards. In our scenario no damage at all was done to walls or base cupboard boxes. They are most likely nailed in--so no screws to remove first... They ought to come out in one large piece for each run.

I see this dilemma all the time on Houzz. Homeowners do it either themselves (depending on their skill level) or have a professional do it. Not a huge deal. Just get a good tile setter and counter top fabricator. Make sure you vet them--get resources, and don't go with the least expensive.

The first thing you do is post a picture of the kitchen you are asking about. All the angles in Jpegs, with the lights on in full daylight. Start there. : )

Yes, people change tops all the time., but lets SEE it.

Add the jpegs in a comment below

Yes, the counters can be taken off without damage to the cabinets. Vet the person you hire to make sure they are able to do so.

I don't have answers, just as curious as your are: What materials do you have on your countertops now, and how is it fastened to your cabinets? I would presume how well the last guy did the install will dictate how easily it can be removed and whether there is any chance of damage.

You mention your counter is dated. Do you like it? Or are you just trying to chase trends?

Yes it is done all the time I agree pics of your space are a great help. I hope next time you do not do fake plastic and choose a nice real stone . I might start by looking for what counter you will choose then the palce where you choose the counter will have access to the guys who do the work for removal and install

You’ll find lots of on line info regarding countertops as well. The more research, the better to help you decide to do yourself or hire.

Its all about the professionals you hire. Some are cruddy and their work damaging while others are sublime. I would start by asking around as to who in your area are the best. If done correctly we have even been able to replace the counters without replacing the backsplash.

My brother had his removed and even reused some of the countertop pieces that had been removed to get better tops on some old cabinets he had in the basement.

I had granite countertops replaced and tile backsplash changed. Cabinets stayed in place and were absolutely fine.

Is this an AI conversation starter question from a bot? People change their counters all the time. They pay expert stone fabricators to do it, rather than breaking 700 lb hunks and dropping it on their feet.

Oh ….. that word ”dated” again. I sure would like to see a picture of what you consider ”dated”. Just curious.