I vote for white. The siding is traditional so I think the white looks better and is more grand.

Another vote for white, for the reasons stated above.

White.

As long as the posts and the railing are the same, white is fine.

It does not need much:

Thank you for that idea! That looks much better !!

White with the current siding color.

I'm so pleased. Notice I painted the front door/screen door blue and side door yellow?

We installed a roller screen on our front door that slides open to one side to show off the door when not in use.

Oh! I didnt notice that, but now i do! I like that, i will paint those also. I will think on the sliding screen door, although i Like the sound of the ole' farmhouse screen door when she closes.... something about it :)

White will go better. Your house is attractive, you don't need to worry much about curb appeal. Great landscaping always adds to curb appeal, but the house itself is very nice.

White because it unites all the house that seems united and bigger. Cedar brakes the unity, and seems scattered, far less elegant.

For the screen door, you could do a traditional wood screen door, with a little lacework on the edges, painted white or the blue.

White. I like your comment re the sound of the old screen door slamming …. sounds very appealing to me. Love your porches, in addition to landscaping I would take advantage of doing something great on them, especially the lower.

Yes, the screen door sound, the smell of fresh cut lawn, and lightning bugs.