You have to test on your house. You are looking for off-whites.

One of my neighbors had what looked like a perfect creamy off-white. When I tested it on my house it looked like highlighter yellow!

SW Natural Choice

Austin Transitional Remodel Elevation · More Info

BM Classic Gray

Bridle Path · More Info

SW Alabaster

Girona at Mediterra · More Info

BM White Dove

Cottage Addition - Exterior · More Info

Another BM White Dove. This one looks more white.

Our Portfolio · More Info

SW Greek Villa

Lanier Project · More Info

BM Olympic Mountain

Front Exterior · More Info

BM Seapearl

Front Elevation · More Info

Same house in BM Seapearl, but look how more yellow it looks from the back.

You have to test on your house, sunexposure, surroundings, etc.

Rear Elevation · More Info

BM Simply White

Custom Brookhaven Home · More Info

Here's an old thread from this Forum (2013) that has some pictures of Dutty's house. To my eye, it's a very pretty soft white; it's Sherman Williams Westhighland White. On the SW website it looks darker than how the pictures in the thread look. (I also love the red barn garage.)

I agree with @chispa that you'll need to test on your own house.

My house faces east but I used SW Alpaca at 75% for my trim and it reads as a true off-white, including on the west side. You might even try it at 50% to see if it works for you.

I am having a hard time getting past, "wondering if these may still be too white?"

Maybe you should pick a color?

Thank you everyone. I am testing the above. I love the white but not wanting stark. A designer suggested Swiss Coffee by Benjamin Moore as well. Will try all and see. Thanks for the help!

BM Swiss Coffee has yellow undertones.

I would sample BM Fossil, yes, a darker white, but in the natural light will be much brighter than the chip sample.

How about a photo of your home so we can see the natural foliage, and other architectural accents that will play a role in the selection and final look.

We‘ve used BM Swiss Coffee for exterior trim. It did lighten/brighten up with exterior lighting. No yellow undertone at all but you have to test it.