Hello, I would like feedback on whether I should use a courtside style or a vestibule style entrance.

The photos below are renderings which depict my homes very accurately with a few exceptions. For example, the outdoor dining table is part of my driveway so you can ignore it. I can’t seem to make up my mind between both styles because they both have pros and cons. For example, the courtyard approach takes away the seating arrangement I can otherwise include if I go with the security gate(portico gate) approach. Yet, the courtyard style entrance gives more of a resort style approach and creates more privacy. Oh yea, keep in mind my house faces the street. There is lots of road traffic. It goes without saying that the renderings are concepts and I am opened to changing materials to wood or other materials and other suggestions. Many thanks!

Courtyard Style:

--

Portico Gate:

The driveway in the photo below is true. Although, none of the fence panels are true. I do have a small garden island in front the window left of the garage.

Actual photo: