Software
Houzz Logo Print
sheeisback

What do you use for a doormat?

last month
last modified: last month

For years I had a black half-circle mat at our front door, but since we got a dog, his hair sticks to it, it’s hard to clean, and I’m over it.

I recently bought a plain coir mat and love the warm color, but when I had my fern by the door, some water got underneath and left a mark on the concrete. The fern was in a grow pot that I removed to water, but apparently I put it back before it was completely finished draining, so that is something I could prevent.

The porch is covered. We do get snow though, so a WaterHog probably makes more sense. I’m considering the Frontgate WaterHog Parquet mat in camel, but the camel color is anemic-looking. I love a warm camel/cognac, and the coir looks so good with my mums and pumpkins. Frontgate recommends using an outdoor rug pad underneath the WaterHog for drainage and to prevent slipping. I’ve honestly never heard of putting a rug pad under an outdoor doormat. Is that something people actually do?

Parquet mat link

But do I really care if the concrete gets marked under the coir mat? I’ll always have some type of mat there anyway.

Would you stick with coir or go with the WaterHog? I know this isn’t exactly an earth-shattering decision in the grand scheme of life.

Comments (19)

  • last month

    We have the Waterhog mats from LLBean. They come in a few colors. They have lasted forever and have been best for us.

    sheeisback thanked sas95
  • last month
    last modified: last month

    I never even knew there were outdoor rug pads! I've been using coir half rounds for a while. I bought a waterhog type from Costco and found it holds onto everything like Velcro. It's impossible to keep it clean. Maybe a different brand would work better, but it seems like the very fibers that help hold the water do the same for all the other stuff like dog hair, sand, debris, etc.

    ETA: I wonder if one of those stone type of bathmats would work. It wouldn't be good for scraping off mud or snow, but would work for water and since it's slick, shouldn't hold other schmutz. Hmmm....I might have to experiment.

    sheeisback thanked Fun2BHere
  • last month

    i only like pure coir, and no backing of any kind. We replace them maybe every other year

    sheeisback thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • last month
    last modified: last month

    Sas - I was looking at the LLBean ones too. Good to know they’ve held up so well! Do you happen to have pets? I’m curious how they do with the hair.

    Fun - Yeah, my old mat was like a WaterHog type, but the hair was so bad that even vacuuming didn’t fully take care of it. I saw a reviewer of the WaterHog mats say that pet hair didn’t stick to them, so I was wondering if the material was a little different.

    Mtn - Where do you get your mats?

    Jilly - FrontGate was the only place I’ve even seen mention using a pad under a WaterHog. I wondered if it was just marketing and trying to sell more products.

  • last month

    Shee, we have 2 cats but they're indoor. But we also have Waterhog mats inside, at the garage entrance and in the kitchen leading outdoors. We have had no trouble with cat hair, and though they seem to be a favorite place to cough up hairballs, they clean easily. Stubborn issues are taken care of with a hose outside.

    sheeisback thanked sas95
  • last month

    We get them at the local hardware store. They are 100% coir and not inexpensive but I frankly don't get how a doormat with a backing ever drains?

    sheeisback thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • last month
    last modified: last month

    Ours with backing rarely gets wet. It was under a snowdrift for a few days, but no issues occured from that. I prefer it for our front door because it’s heavier, doesn’t move with traffic or wind, and I like the more formal look of it. It’s woven tighter, so doesn’t shed like my others.

    This is what ours looks like (sunburst pattern), but for a single door:



    sheeisback thanked Jilly
  • last month

    Coir and i change them out seasonally. For spring/summer i found the prettiest floral one that works great with our door color. i found it at Target of all places!

    sheeisback thanked Tina Marie
  • last month

    I had a coir mat a long time ago and never wanted another because the coir fibers broke down underneath it. Maybe it was of a cheap quality. (?) For the last five or more years I've been using a half-round rubbery mat that looks like a wrought iron design, likely made from old tires. It's effective and still looks new.

  • last month

    We have the waterhog mats. The black one on the front porch is very large—maybe the size large or extra large. We spend a lot of time out there with our two hairy australian shepherds, so it collects hair. The cleaner vacuums it on their every-other-week visit. i usually vacuum it on at least one of the off weeks. I like understated mats, and i found the coir mats too messy.

    sheeisback thanked deeinohio
  • last month

    I have a wrought iron? cast iron? rectangular and a a rubber half moon that looks like whatever type of iron the other is.

    sheeisback thanked porkandham
  • last month
    last modified: last month


    In my Florida home.

    I tried a coir and it did not look right. Entry is well protected. Hard to find something this suze. I'm happy with this choice.

    sheeisback thanked eld61
  • last month

    I usually have a coir one with no liner - however, my grandson (= my daughter) gave this to me as a funny part of my last bday present = I have left it out this summer:



    It's a low polypropylene loop (it looks like faux coir) + embroidered. The rug underneath it isn't needed - she just thought it would look "cute." It actually works well at catching things on the bottom of people's shoes before they come into the foyer + it is easy to shake out (or vacuum if you want it to be perfectly black). I'm sure that there are options without embroidery (or with other sayings).


    I do have a portico over my porch = it's protected a bit, However, it's been a bit wet at times (the top one dries fast - the bottom one is cotton) - I have containers with plants on either side of the door in front of my sidelights.

    sheeisback thanked dani_m08
  • last month

    Fell in love with the ubiquitous look in London(see below) This was easiest copy.



    sheeisback thanked martinca_gw sunset zone 24
  • last month

    At my front door I have a coir mat with our last names initial on it. It's made to sit in a black rubber holder that frames it. I've had it eight years! From Bed Bath & Beyond. The base is sold separately from the mat.


    sheeisback thanked NiCOZ5
  • last month

    I use Waterhogs. Occasionally I get a coir one and then it starts looking awful, even though it is on a porch (narrow one though).

    sheeisback thanked cyn427 (z. 7, N. VA)
  • last month
    last modified: last month

    We just have plain rectangular coir mats with a rubber backing. I typically keep one or two fresh ones on hand and swap them out when they start looking too gnarly. The one at the front door is covered but gets the most wear and needs vacuuming/shaking the most. The two at the back doors are exposed fully to the elements but don't get much use so they last a bit longer.

    Our mats sit on flagstone and does mark it a bit, but I always have a mat so the marking doesn't really matter?

    sheeisback thanked jakabedy
  • last month

    We have New England Trading Co lobster rope mats. One at the front porch door and two on the back porch, bith covered. I replace a neutral black and beigh one on the front porch with a coir mat for fall and Christmas (no backing). In the hot south, the backing just melts no matter how expensive the rug.

    We had one at the condo on the lake that was fairly exposed.Adter the fire I just knew it would have to be trashed. We watched firemen walk over it many times and dirty water pour out the door as they fought the fire. As an experiment I later took it home, scrubbed it with dawn soap and water and a stiff brush. It looked like new ao we put it by the steps in the garage leading into the house.


    sheeisback thanked OutsidePlaying