Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_556880378

Renovation ideas

4 days ago

Need help with second floor Reno. Which plan is better and what would you do differently? Thanks.

Comments (10)

  • 4 days ago

    The second one is better: the laundry is accessed from hall; the mater toilet is private and someone can be at vanity when it’s in usen there is a bathtub in the hall bath, good for bathing kids or dog.

  • PRO
    4 days ago

    I would need to know more about who lives there and age of kids . Too much missing info.

  • 4 days ago

    Family of 4 - 12 year old boy and 14 year old girl

  • PRO
    4 days ago

    So one kid gets an ensuite the other not , 2nd floor laundry IMO is a PITA A wasyed space for bedroom entry in the 2nd one I do not find either great and only one bedroom with the ensuite when you have 2 kids seems unfair and for sure for guests who then have to aslo share

  • 4 days ago

    I like the primary bedroom location in the 2nd option as it has windows on two sides and will be brighter. Do you really need that much closet space? I might try to squeeze a small pocket office where the windows are in the biggest closet and shrink the closets a little bit.

  • 3 days ago

    We don’t need more than one walk-in closet. Need options for additional space.

  • 3 days ago

    The second plan puts the laundry in a more accessible spot and I definitely agree that the natural light in the primary bedroom will be much better. It also puts the hall bath much closer to the existing bedrooms. I also agree that there is a lot of wasted space with the 2nd smaller walk-in and large entry into the primary.

  • 3 days ago

    I like #2 better. #1 limits the light in the bedroom and wastes a wall which could have windows in it on a closet.

  • 3 days ago
    last modified: 3 days ago

    With two kids, it is hard to give one of them a bedroom/WIC/private bath suite and not the other.

    Consider reworking the plan so their bedroom suites are comparable. The small bedroom next to the staircase could become a private bath/WIC for the adjacent bedroom.

  • yesterday

    Additions should follow right size, right place - part of that is heirarchy, scale, and proportion based on the existing house. Every design needs to be taken in context with all information, and the front elevation here is an important piece:



    • The first scheme is 1/3 the size of the existing 2nd floor addition, and only dedicated to the Master. Proportions of rooms aren't bad, but the placement has the closet benefiting from the front elevation windows which it doesn't need, and the back Laundry placement does not benefit from windows over a more secluded back yard, which isn't a huge need to begin with. The biggest problem is what it does to the front of house, it makes your garage over-emphasized, almost like a snout garage, and detracts from the rest of house.
    • The second scheme makes the 1/3 size addition seem like 1/2 the size because it has extended the footprint beyond the garage (which brings some detailing problems), which now makes that addition very dominant and out of scale on the front elevation. More work would need to be done so the entry isn't overwhelmed and the left side of the house doesn't appear to be a "tack on." Even though the plan is trying to take advantage of where windows are available by moving the Master Bedroom and where the resulting Master Bath would be, it leaves huge closets (that you didn't ask for or apparently need) and a circuitous circulation. Also a technical note but the existing chimney is not how it would be redone, it does affect layout but moreso it shows that the designer may not be an architect.


    This is a common 1960-70s house design that I see additions over the garage all the time, albeit usually 2 car garages. Like your schemes have, I do see full additions all the way to the front wall, and the result is as I commented. The other route of successful addition placement on these style of houses is smaller and more "subdued" to work with the existing scale and proportions of the existing house, and also seems to fit your programming. That would be something like this:



    I'm not going to generate a front elevation or plan as you have hired help, but if this scheme is developed by a competent designer you will see this has oppportunity for much better scaled, proportioned, and efficient elevations and plan.