Software
Houzz Logo Print
petalique

Has anyone made good bagels? Difficult?

10 days ago

It is challenging to find good bagels. NY deli style, not ”bready bagels.”


I have to limit my intake of carbs and fats, but I long for a decent bagel.


A magazine I bought a few months ago has a recipe for smallish, but nice looking bagels, but the dough is made with a potato. Isn’t that unusual? A cofee roaster on the other side of town has okat bagels, but the bagels are on the medium side and cost about $2 each. I guess that is to keep people like me from eating them daily. ;(

Comments (7)

  • 10 days ago
    last modified: 10 days ago

    I have always just bought the Thomas Bagels from the grocery.

    petalique thanked Sherry8aNorthAL
  • 10 days ago

    I hear you on the bready bagels. Ew. Traditional bagels were half the size of modern ones. The change happened when they were touted for diets because they were plain and small, but then people wanted them with all kinds of flavors and big... A "real" bagel was a ring with a discernable open center, like a doughnut, though made from a rope of dough, not made with a cutter. The crosssection was about an inch and a third.


    I've made bagels a couple of times. Not really worth it for me because there's an excellent bagel store around the corner. So, if you're going to do it, clear down your whole kitchen first. You need space and you can't just juggle your way through. Also, work through the logistics.


    OR This recipe is for only half a dozen bagels. Much more manageable, and I think you're mostly cooking for two, right? Bagels stale fast though freeze well. Small batch means also you don't need to hide the blender to make this. It's also the best recipe I've seen (but haven't made) for real bagels at home. The malt is important. Malt powder would work, but the syrup would be easier. Reeject any recipe that calls for sugar instead of malt. It won't taste right, and it's pretty much heresy.


    https://thepracticalkitchen.com/hand-rolled-new-york-style-bagels-overnight-recipe/

    petalique thanked plllog
  • 9 days ago

    I've made reasonably decent bagels back in the day when the only purchasable ones were a store brand which was NOT a bagel, just ring shaped (baked, not boiled) bread :-P. It was a lot of work and made a lot of bagels, so now that good bought ones are available, I get those when I have the urge for a bagel.

    It's been years since I made bialys, which are not available anywhere; maybe now I have more time I should make a batch of those...

    petalique thanked colleenoz
  • 9 days ago

    I cannot get NY bagels here, but I'm amazed that Dave's Bagels are actually very acceptable bagels, especially for a mass produced grocery store brand.

    petalique thanked laceyvail 6A, WV
  • 8 days ago
    last modified: 8 days ago

    I have made bagels for years.I use sourdough and hand roll them then they go in the fridge overnight and get boiled in lye water the next day then baked. I make 2 doz at a time because they freeze beautifully. Slice , freeze toast. These are the chewy not big bready kind.

    Everyone makes a big deal about

    lye for bagels but it’s weak enough that there is 0 danger. The outcome is so worth it. It is the only way to get the right flavor and color and texture.









    Some pics from my blog on The Fresh Loaf

    ” trailrunner ” there too.

    petalique thanked Still trailing
  • 2 days ago

    I make bagels regularly and use the recipe from King Arthur Flour. I made three "flavors" and gave them to the neighbors at Christmas a couple of year ago. That's when I found out that one of the three owners was gluten sensitive but the other two were happy, LOL.


    I've also used AnnT's recipe, available on her blog: Thibeault's Table The Recipe Collection: Pictorial - How to Make Bagels


    The benefit of making your own is that you can make any size that suits you, top them with various toppings for variety and they freeze well. Bonuses all!


    Annie

    petalique thanked annie1992