Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_1416529

Kitchen cabinets

12 years ago
I have really light oak wood cabinets. I have hired someone to paint/stain them ebony black. My question, is it better to stain or paint. My guys telling me to paint since the wood has been sealed. He thinks painting them would look nicer. What do the experts here think? Please help!

Comments (15)

  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I agree, I think painting would be more consistent and even. You may still see some of the wood grain pattern through the finish.
    Aditi Shah-Gandhi thanked Carie Gentry
  • 12 years ago
    Paint for sure. Staining may give you too much or a Rorschach look!
  • 12 years ago
    I'm not an expert, but I stained my kitchen cabinets w/General Finishes gel stain, and did NOT need to completely remove the current finish and sand down to bare wood. On the contrary, I washed with strong cleaning solution (TSP w/o the P) and lightly sanded them.

    Then, three coats of GF "Java", two of GF poly sealer, and they look lovely and, so far, are standing up to the large amounts of surface cooking I do, with the accompanying necessary scrubbing. Gently, of course, but I'd do that to any cabinets in my kitchen. Attached are before and after.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    @mickisue - I'm glad that your cabinets turned out OK. But... stain is just that, stain. It needs to soak into the wood, and any finish already on a piece of wood will prevent this from happening. It's purpose is to color the wood but still let the variations in the wood grain show. You can add a lot of stain so that it looks even, let it dry (if it will) and add a top coat. Basically what you have done is add so much pigment using three coats of stain, that it has worked like paint. Which would have been a lot easier.
  • 12 years ago
    Thanks. So my concern (if it even should be a real concern) is, will the paint chip over time? I really want the dark gray almost black look for the kitchen with my Metallic silver wall color by BMthe cabinet color I've picked is ebony king By BM. My painter also said he is going to use shellac paint. Does that sound right? Sorry I'm completely new to this.

    Q2: I'm thinking of doing the powder room Kendall Charcoal by BM and the vanity paint it ebony king. Add silver accents in mirrors and paintings. Thoughts?
    Coloring the LR, hallway, staircase walls thundercloud gray by BM.
    Should I keep the bedroom color thundercloud gray as well or should I do something darker/lighter? Also two full baths upstairs but completely lost on the color. Thinking about doing a lighter gray like the metallic silver and paint the vanity ebony black.
    I'm planning on adding modern paintings, shadow boxes and colorful curtains throughout to add color.

    Does this sound good. The reason I want to have the same color all throughout is so that everything flows really well. Thoughts?

    TIA for all your suggestions and help.
  • 12 years ago
    So it looks like painting is the way to go. Is their a specific black/ebony color you have used in your design scheme already by BM that you would recommend? I'm asking for BM because that's the paint my painter uses :). Thanks again and sorry for so many questions. This small project is exciting and nerve racking all at the same time.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    The paint will not chip if the cabinets are prepared correctly. I'm sorry that I'm not a house painter and don't use regular house paints in my shop. You will have to be comfortable with your painter and that he is preparing the cabinets correctly. I'm also not familiar with shellac paint, but I do know alcohol is a solvent for shellac and spilling it on a regular shellac finish will dissolve the finish. He may be using a shellac based primer. If that is the case it's OK. Maybe some of the painters can add their $.02.
  • 12 years ago
    I think he is using the shellac primer. Thanks for your input and I'm going to go with painting the cabinets.
  • 12 years ago
    @mickisue I am thinking about doing the same thing with my cabinets. Do you have an overall photo of your kitchen? The photo you posted looks great! And as you probably know, gel stain is different from regular stain. It is designed to sit more on the surface rather than penetrate the layers, which is why you don't have to sand all the way down to bare wood.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Paint is the way to go. As for chipping. First, do not keep your coffee maker, toaster oven or microwave on the counter under your wall cabinets. Bring them out to the front of the counter when they are in use so that the moisture with dissipate. Make sure the room is above 55 degrees when the cabinets are being painted. Once the painting is complete, crank up the heat a bit to help them sure faster. If possible, use a fan to circulate the air in the room but not while the paint is overly tacky so that not sticks to the paint. You a good quality paint such as Benjamin Moor Advance and you should have good results.
  • 12 years ago
    Thank you so much everyone.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    @wasalo - you are right about gel stain not penetrating as much as regular stains. It was formulated to help people stain difficult woods more easily and not get as much blotching on some woods that tend to blotch with thin stains (maple and cherry for example). No stain is made to sit on top of an existing finish. That's why you are supposed to wipe them off or put them on with a rag not leaving a lot of stain on the wood. Wood will never absorb as much stain on the second and following applications as it did on the first. If you want to color an existing cured finish you could use the pre-colored finishes, but in my opinion they leave a cloudy finish. Whenever you have to use multiple coats of stain you are essentially painting the surface. Some stains will never cure if left on too thick. They may feel dry to the touch, but aren't really cured.

    I have had cabinets and furniture come into my shop using processes similar to yours for repair. You could peel the new layers of finish off the original with your finger nails. They required complete strip because the second finish will always peel no matter what is put over it.

    There is test that is used to test finish adhesion (although destructive). Make a cross hatch pattern with an exacto knife in your finish cutting through the finish. Sort of like a 1" square tic-tac-toe square. Put a piece of masking tape (good masking tape, not the cheap stuff) over it and rub it down. Quickly pull it off. If no finish comes with it, you have good adhesion.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    You have to use shellac so the stain will not react with the mineral spirits. after the shellac you will need a protective topcoat because shellac is not durable enough for a kitchen.
  • 12 years ago
    wasalo--I would love to post my whole kitchen-but right now it looks like a bomb went off in it. I just finished painting the walls, and am in the process of finishing the staining/painting/painting the trim/changing out the vanity top in the powder room. All in three days less than I thought I had, because my son and his g/f are arriving tomorrow, not Sunday!

    Also, the kitchen isn't finished. The cabinets are, and, now, the walls. But we're saving up for the new cooktop, sink and granite counter, so we still have the old stuff, and the 1999 laminate with an oak edge. Which, BTW, has some stain on it, but as it's going to be pitched, I didn't so much care.

    @Al F--I used the method from the blog monica wants it--a disposable glove with a man's sock over it. Cheap, easy to get, and makes for a really smooth finish, because you can feel if you have unevenness in the finish.

    And the length of the sock means that your wrists and arms are covered, too!