Software
Houzz Logo Print
coldinmn

Staining a pine door dark- help!

12 years ago
last modified: 12 years ago
We purchased a custum solid wood front door with side lights and in effort to save $ we chose to finish it ourselves. Now the door has arrived and I'm terrified to start in on this door. As I research how I go about this I have read that pine doors are difficult to stain without them coming out splotchy and I would like a dark stain. I wish I had just had them finish it or ordered a fiberglass door- but it's already here and there's no turning back. Can anyone PLEASE guide me to the look I am trying to achieve? Or is this something i shouldn't attempt? The attached pic are images that came up when I googled "dark stained pine" and that have the color I'm shooting for. Thanks in advance!

Comments (12)

  • PRO
    12 years ago
    A custom door with sidelights is very expensive. I personally would start to find and interview people to finish it for you. Ask them to do several test samples first before touching your door.
  • 12 years ago
    As far doors go, are you absolute that it's pine ? Pine is a soft wood. I would think that doors should be made of hardwood.
  • 12 years ago
    Per experience i liked and agreed with Al Fortunato Furnituremaker, apply stain using a rag instead of a brush. With a brush, you'll be wasting a lot of stain.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Curt reminded me of something that you should also be aware of. Many wood doors are made from glued up pieces of wood vs. wide boards, then veneered with the desired wood. When sanding make sure you don't sand through the veneer.

    Curt, yes it is entirely possible this door is pine. Less expensive and paint grade doors are made from pine or hemlock. It is somewhat unusual to find a door completely made from a solid hardwood unless it is very high end or custom made.
  • 12 years ago
    Thank you all for your input. Curt, yes I'm sure it is pine. I think my best bet is to find someone with more experience than I. :) any tips on finding said person? Is their a name for this? I've searched 'wood finishing' and came up with painters that also do this. I hesitate though because I just had a local painting business do a major mud and tape job on my ceiling and it looks terrible. I'm sure there are great painters who can do it all- I'd love to find one. Thanks again!
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Look for woodworkers or cabinet shops (not retail shops, custom shops) in your area. If they don't do it, they may know of a finisher.
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    A front door is SO visible....you and every visitor will see it every time you go through. An expensive, highly visible purchase like this, which needs a UV and water-resistant finish that can last for years, is not something I'd tackle myself and I have finished MANY pieces of furniture successfully (including compliments from professional appraisers and decorators).

    Al gave some good tips but did not mention anything about special requirements for outdoor exposure. Sun, rain, abrasion from daily use, temperature and humidity swings, are all far harsher on exterior finishes than furniture used indoor. You MUST use stains and 3+ layers of a topcoat, all intended for harsh outdoor use.

    How about asking the supplier if you can send it back and have them do the finish? It may be less expensive than someone local and factory/manufacturer finish is best 99.4% of the time. If not, then yes, find a pro. They know all the gotchas, tips and tricks to do this right. You won't save money having to buy and test all the materials and equipment yourself...or getting a blotchy result...or watching it peel and split and having to redo it in 2 years.

    BTW, here in the San Francisco Bay area, I recently got my 52-year-old front door (36" x 84"; 0.9 x 2.1 m) refinished by a pro. It cost $875. He sanded that thing, repaired cracks, and used a UV-resistant yacht varnish which I believe he may have oven cured. The finisher says I can expect 8-10 years before refinishing. (Yes, the wrong clear finish will result in severe dissatisfaction and early failure.) Some of the best money I ever spent....looks terrific. I found this pro by reading Yelp reviews. Others in the trade may also be good reference sources.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    There is difference between a painter and an artisan finisher. If you work with an interior designer they may be able to help you locate a person to do the work for you. I will give you one tip. If they start with anything other than sandpaper you have the wrong person.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Soberg, keep us posted on how you front door wears I am very interested in the product used because in direct sun I have yet to find a finish that does not require yearly maintence.
  • 12 years ago
    Quoting my finisher: "Isocyanate is a catalyzed industrial urethane that was designed to protect Oil Platforms in the North Sea. This is not a Home Depot finish or anything that your local painter would have any idea about.. The U.V. stabilizer is Cobra Giegie 150. It is a U.V. Absorber. We have over 1000 high end exterior doors to our credit over the past 35 years."
  • 10 years ago

    Just updating the post to say that my front door is wearing beautifully.....looks the same now as when it came back from the refinisher. 2.5 years of service so far.