Software
Houzz Logo Print
juancastillo

Radiant heating vs. Electric baseboard heating for Basement

12 years ago
We were told by friends that they wish they had used electric baseboard heaters for the basement instead of radiant floor heating. They think that because the proximity to the ground the radiant heat takes more energy to heat up. Any one with some advice on both options will be appreciated...

Comments (7)

  • 12 years ago
    What about cost of electricity vs water heated radiant floor?
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Hydronic (water heated) radiant heating works well if you already have a hydronic boiler, pumps, and valves and other related hydronic plumbing, however, the cost to install hydronic heating along with all of its necessary components tends to be very costly. Warming a floor will be much faster, easier, and wallet-friendly using electric floor heating, because extensive construction may be required in order to install a hydronic radiant heating system. Hydronic systems are not maintenance-free and there are moving parts that can wear out and fail. In the future, a professional will need to be called in to make any repairs, big or small. In comparison, electric systems are virtually maintenance-free without the risk of leaking or eroding hydronic pumps.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I have gas powered boiler and wall mounted , just above floor radiators and I love the kind of heat we get, very even and not very expensive inWestern Canada. I guess infloor heating would have been esthetically a little nicer looking ,these are worry free and if we need maintenance down the road it is all easy to get to.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Electric baseboard heaters are the worst way to heat that space. Besides losing all your heat to the ceiling, you lose a ton of wall space. You are supposed to keep everything at least 6" away from those heaters. Very few people do that and it is a big fire hazard. Nothing is worse than a couch pushed up against a baseboard, trapping all that heat. Electric Radiant Floor Heat would be a great solution. We have an insulation board that we recommend people use when installing onto concrete sub floors. True it raises the floor 1/4", but that is a very small price to pay for all the additional benefits. If you need help feel free to call me at 862-666-2413. Good luck with the project, Barry
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    There is almost no comparison in regards to the difference in heating, radiant floor heating is by far the most efficient. The problem is that you have to lay the Pex in before you pour the concrete. The difference is that a concrete-radiant setup produces a huge heat mass, meaning after a couple days of it being on, it heats up the concrete faster than the heat can dissipate, using less power. If your power goes out, that radiant floor will be warm for days after.

    Baseboard heat immediately travels upward while you have a constant cold floor from the cold mass, and collects in the corners of the room. If its not boiler heated, and is a 220V baseboard heater instead, its kind of difficult finding out the difference in power consumption between the two (depending on if its an gas or oil or electric furnace).

    You'd have to leave the baseboard heat on constantly to match the heat output retention that an insulated concrete floor provides.

    In your situation- because you're heating a basement, you can frame in a floor, (most commonly with "sleepers" or 2x4's laying flat on the floor) and fill in the spaces in the framing with 2 "Rigid Foam, put a reflective membrane (or Celotex that already has it on both sides) or reflective sheeting above or below the new floor, or both, and get the spacers for the tubing and your problem is solved. You'll need to seal the concrete first. Some concrete forms are done with rigid foam board underneath to keep in heat. You might lose a couple of inches in height for the ceiling but it doesn't compare to walking barefoot on a warm floor.

    Check to see if you have a vapor barrier under your concrete, without it, you'll have moisture or humidity between the concrete and its barrier above it. Whether or not the radiant tubing is close in proximity to the ground, if its insulated properly- again theres no comparison between the two. You need something reflective in there, or its a no-win situation. Even though its in your house, you're still heating the outside without it.


    I hope this might help you with your situation, good luck with it !

    Rich

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Is it possible that your friends did not insulate below the concrete before they poured it? If they did not I could easily see how they would feel that way. Without insulation that is a poorly installed radiant setup and certainly would not be very efficient.