Software
Houzz Logo Print
britt_domke

Two toilets better than one?

12 years ago
We're looking at re-doing our retro glorious main bathroom this summer, and DH is making ominous noises about knocking through the wall to our powder room ensuite to make one big (ish) bathroom on the main floor. I'm horrified at the idea of losing my own sink and toilet, but is he right? Is it better to have one big bathroom than one small full, and a powder room?
We have another full bath in the basement.

Comments (14)

  • 12 years ago
    Do you entertain often? Do you want guests running to the basement or using your bathroom?
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    It is better to keep them separate from a resale point of view, even if you are staying in the house long term. Changing two bathrooms into one bath really hurts resale value especially if you only have one bath. Did you husband say why he thinks it would be better to combine the full bath and half bath?
  • 12 years ago
    We have the inlaws over to dinner a few times a month, but generally that is the extent of our entertaining. Our previous home had only one full bath so I could probably get used to it again (having people in my bathroom) but I do like keeping my stuff seperate.
    In terms of resale down the road, do people much care for having a powder room as an ensuite? Or is it really molehills and nobody cares one way or another. I guess, would someone choose a house with one large full on the main over one with a small full and a powder room if they were in all other ways similar?
  • 12 years ago
    Denita we must have posted at the same time!

    There is a window in the ensuite. He likes having a window in the bathroom. *shrug*
  • 12 years ago
    Lol...maybe you can change the light bulbs in the main bath so it looks more like daylight :)
    I hear you with the half bath issue for the ensuite. It really depends upon the market in your area - some markets a half bath in the ensuite is not acceptable (full bath only). Some markets having the expanded full bath and no private bath for the ensuite would be okay. Call your Realtor and ask about the market impact if you make that change to your home. It is worth checking out before you make the final decision.
  • 12 years ago
    I might be strange [well, I know I am! :)], but I just don't get this need for en suites the size of a small living room. What besides go to the bathroom, bathe, shower and get ready do you do in the bathroom that requires that much space?

    I would much rather have an extra powder room in case my main toilet plugged up, and I wasn't able to unclog it right away.
  • 12 years ago
    Could you add a skylight to the windowless bathroom?
  • 12 years ago
    Good idea Rachel H, or even a solar tube.
  • 12 years ago
    Solar tube is a great idea, but it rains a lot here, I'm not sure I want to mess with the roof. I'll definitely mention it to him though.

    Probably cheaper than that fancy tub he promised me if I let him take down the wall. ;)

    I'd like to put a shower in the ensuite but I don't think there is enough room.

    I will ask the realtor next time I bump into him. We're not looking to sell for at least a few years, but I'm more interested in adding value/interest than destructing it. The main is admittedly small, but it is functional.
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    You can do a lot with a small bath without touching the roof :) I don't know what style you are looking to do so I posted several inspiration pics that show how a small bath can be beautiful and function well. It really is the design that counts. Post a floor plan (in jpeg) of the space you have with dimensions and there are professionals on this site that can help you with a design.
    Hover over each photo to expand and click on the photo name to see details.
    DC Master Bathroom · More Info

    Oceanfront · More Info

    Presido Heights San Francisco Bathroom · More Info

    Cheyne Walk Project · More Info

    b-w Bathroom · More Info

    A Modern Miami Home · More Info
  • 12 years ago
    Wow, most of those are bigger than ours, but I LOVE the shallow cabinets and popped out sinks! We've been wondering how we would get a vanity to replace the custom one we'll be pulling out (it's angled, shallow by the door for necessary purposes) and I've always thought deep vanities are a waste of space regardless. Thank you!!

    I will create a floor plan with measurements for both bathrooms this weekend. Our budget will be smallish, but we've done a bathroom before and my dad has worked as a contractor before so we'll be able to do most of the labor ourselves. I'm very partial to black and white floors, with white amenities and white tile on the walls halfway up. :)
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    Have fun! Here is a black and white bath with a little pop of color
    Family Fun · More Info

    Another one that is closer in size to your bath
    Denville, NJ Main Bath Renovation · More Info
  • 12 years ago
    Here is my old bathroom, right before we moved out. This one will be a bit more fancy I think.