Software
Houzz Logo Print
brenda_ernst

Need help picking siding material and color

12 years ago
last modified: 12 years ago
I am purchasing this chalet style cabin that is going to need immediate repairs and upgrades. The work is going to be done just after closing and before I move in. I am going to have to make decisions on the roof and siding before I even get to spend time there, so I am hoping some more experienced people have some good "budget" suggestions. I am thinking I will go with black shingles for the roof, but I am open to suggestions. The gable/window wall is going to be rebuilt with the same style and windows that it currently has (loose, shaky wall, not built to code), but it will need new siding. The front (short side) of the cabin is going to be getting a floating gable porch roof with 10 foot wide steps going straight up to the door, too. Additionally, the decorative rafter tails are rotten, so those will be sawed-off and I will be having gutters installed. Some siding on the house has water damage and rot, so it needs to be replaced. Since some of it has to be replaced I am wondering if I should go for a whole new look. Part of me wants to keep a similar look to what it has now, but part of me wants to see what some other options are. I don't have much vision or experience with this, so I would love to hear what others have to say. By the way, the "glamor shot" angle from the bottom of the property looking up at the gable, window wall is not really an angle anyone will ever see. You drive up and park at the short side, where the new gable porch cover will be. I do want to make sure the roof and siding don't clash with the two decks, too.

Comments (10)

  • 12 years ago
    It looks like you are buying a project! You have some very good ideas so far. It will be worth it in the end as it's such a beautiful setting.
    For the roof do you want to consider a metal roof? I don't know about cost compared to shingles, but I think they hold up better.
    I think greys go well with the orangey tones of wood.
    Brenda Ernst thanked MarleneM
  • 12 years ago
    Beautiful place. I suggest charcoal mixed with browns for a roof shingle color. Solid black will look like tarpaper!

    For major changes and major investments, hiring an architect is worth the money.
    Brenda Ernst thanked apple_pie_order
  • 12 years ago
    I definitely think slate grey for the roof, I agree, black will look like tar paper. I tend to prefer neutral-taupe (gray-brown, or brown-gray, possibly with a hint of green) colors for siding for this type of dwelling, based on where it is.
    Brenda Ernst thanked Kathryn Nichols
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    I know that this siding is expensive but I thought the color combination was nice for your setting. I agree with the comments that a black roof is too harsh and I would go with a more neutral color.
    Brenda Ernst thanked Louise Hane Interior Design
  • 12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    This is a super cute house! I love the idea of the cedar shingles, but if you don't want to reface your house, a grey or grey/brown roof with greyblue siding, white trim, and a rich woodtone deck area and door will look great.

    Capturing the beauty of its location. · More Info

    Guadalupe remodel · More Info
    Brenda Ernst thanked kellyography
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    The cabin has a great setting with a nice form and prow gable. If you are losing the rafter tails do to rot, consider a new, heavy rake trim (or barge board) with a decorative profile or tail. It will give back some character to the architecture. I hope this helps.
    Brenda Ernst thanked Agape Designs
  • 12 years ago
    Thank you all for your ideas and input! I'm curious why you all think black shingles would look like tar paper. I look at black shingled roofs everyday and think they look new and solid and definitely not like tar paper. I think a lot of the lighter shades look like faded blacks which make them look worn to me. Being there are so many repairs that need to be made (I didn't mention them all!) I can't put any more money into the roof than I already am, so going metal is not an option. It's definitely going to start out as a project!
  • 12 years ago
    I think black can look very dramatic with cedar. Do you know what siding you are putting on? Today's shingles are made with subtle colour variations in them, the only thing I am wondering is if it will look too top heavy from the front where you see just the one story. Something bold like cedar would balance that.
    Lake Country Builders · More Info
    Brenda Ernst thanked MarleneM
  • 12 years ago
    I may just leave the siding as-is for now, although I am not sure I can re-use the siding that is on the gable window wall. I played around with some software online to try out some different roofing colors and siding options now I see what y'all mean about the black. I'm just going to not think about this for a couple of days and then maybe I'll have an epiphany :) Thank you all!