Software
Houzz Logo Print
pattigaff

Bull nose hardwood pieces on stairs, raised or flush?

12 years ago
We just had hardwood floors installed on the first floor and stairs. The bull nose pieces used on the stairs are raised about 1/4". I assumed they would be flush? Is this the correct way?

Comments (53)

  • 12 years ago
    I have never seen anything like this before. I would definitely insist that the bullnose be installed flush.
    pattigaff thanked mcbriec
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    They should be flush, and the installer should have known.
    pattigaff thanked PPF.
  • 12 years ago
    Floor guys aren't expert finish carpenters. That's who you need for a stairs project.
    pattigaff thanked User
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Definitely a hazard, not to mention a cleaning issue. Lots of dirt and gunk are going to build up on that lip.
    pattigaff thanked Bryce Engstrom: Architect
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    @mcbriec...
    I wish I could say I'd "never seen anything like this before"... but unfortunately I have... too often!
    Really tests the limits of suppressing my gag reflex!
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Full disclosure...
    While I'm busy criticizing the approach taken on the esteemed Poster's project...
    I have to state that I'm NEVER a fan of using the flooring material as a stair tread... even if it can be done correctly with matching FLUSH style bullnosed trim.

    Just seems a bit "amateurish" to me when a full tread isn't utilized.
    We typically recommend following that approach even when it's OUR flooring that could be used...
    Guess it's personal preference, but usually, by the time you figure in the misc. parts, labor, etc., it may not be too much more to consider the more refined approach.
    But once again, we don't work in the "boxed goods" end of the biz...
    pattigaff thanked Select Hardwood Floor Co.
  • 12 years ago
    It is the cheapest way not the best way. A good woodworker or Carpenter would have cut a grove to insert the bullnose into FLUSH. I would have never paid for a job like this.
    pattigaff thanked fredm51
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Flush. Watch the tripping hazard
    pattigaff thanked LineBox Studio
  • 12 years ago
    Select, just because you are a craftsman and an exception to the rule doesn't mean others like you are easily found. Most ''floor guys'' aren't ''flooring contractors'', first of all. It's generally an unlicensed specialty that falls within the cracks. And that is full of hacks.

    Second, not to tell you a thing, brcause you know this already, but stairs are a specialty skill. They are regulated by building code for safety reasons. Redoing them, and not taking into account the levelness of a tread, or the required uniformity of rise and run requirements is typical of someone who doesn't undertstand the complexity the project. On a building site, only the most experienced finish carpenters build the stairs. For good reason. That should translate into redoing those stairs as well.

    If that skilled individual happens to be an actual flooring guru, like Select, then you've found a fortunate combo. You will have a better chance of success with the project though in searching outside that trade specialty. And buying better quality materials.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    @Sophie...
    I understand your point... and the requirements re: licensing vary from state to state (in the USA, of course)... however that being said... I know PLENTY of people who are "licensed" that I wouldn't allow to work on my dog house, which is where I spend MOST of my time.
    This is another detail often "falls within the cracks".

    We can't be sure... but the originator of this discussion, obviously worked with someone "posing" as an expert... licensed or not, however the point remains that a license... and for that matter, high pricing, doesn't insure HIGH quality or standards... but at least there's a better likelihood than going the low end route.
    pattigaff thanked Select Hardwood Floor Co.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Yikes! Definitely not right but certainly not a unique solution unfortunately. One of the most awkward installations I have seen recently was encountered on a historic homes tour. The owners had prefinished hardwood installed on top of existing flooring in the upper level of a two story house with an open stairway. Because they didn't want to disturb the staircase and the upper level railing, they stopped short of the edge by about 3 inches. Then, to avoid the abrupt transition, they cut the front corner off the flooring to create an angled strip from original height up to the new floor level. So, you couldn't even put your foot flat on the floor at the top of the stairs. Silly looking, awkward to walk on and very dangerous. Sometimes the best approach is to bite the bullet and do the project correctly from the start or just leave well enough alone.

    I did a complete gut job on an older house a few years ago...almost everything was redone, except for the stairs. I wouldn't even consider messing with a reasonably decent staircase. We had a lot of labor into refinishing the stairs and replacing missing stair returns but they finished product was probably the best feature of the house.

    Except for prefinished parts, building or redoing wood stairs requires both a finish carpenter AND a floor guy. Many finish carpenters are not going to have the expertise in finish selection, surface prep and surface finishes that you would expect in a flooring guy.

    In my experience, the people who know the most are often the ones who don't consider themselves an expert. The deeper you get into any subject, the more you realize what you don't know. The best guy to find is the one that considers himself "talented" or "competent" but others describe as an expert.
    pattigaff thanked Linda
  • 12 years ago
    looked like those stairs were expecting an inlaid carpet! I would have thought dangerous, too easy to trip and fall. Can't they be planed down?
    pattigaff thanked janbhan
  • 12 years ago
    Dangerous. I would get the redone ASAP. Hope you haven't paid this person. If he has a supervisor, I would be calling them.
    pattigaff thanked grobby
  • 12 years ago
    Our contractor says he has installed them this way before with no issue; however, since we are uncomfortable with the raised lip being a hazard, he is looking diligently for a solution.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    @pattigaff...
    your "contractor" has an interesting take on the subject... I'm sure he's "picked his nose" in public, and gotten away with it... but that doesn't mean it's a good idea.

    Perhaps I take my job too seriously, but WHENEVER I suspect there may be conditions which might cause bodily harm... I act in favor of leaning toward a safe approach.
    Stairs are a necessary facet of any home that involves more than one level... and 99 times out of a hundred, there's not an issue.

    But all it would take is that ONE misstep... and the result could be anything from a twisted ankle to something MUCH more catastrophic.
    I know that I personally, would NEVER want to feel responsible for an injury to a customer... (which isn't to imply that your contractor is inept or an inconsiderate person... however he's a bit cavalier on the subject for my taste).

    I'd hang tough... if he's worth his salt, his "diligence" will pay off... there are several approaches to accomplishing the objective... he just wanted to take the easy way out, which isn't always the best.
    Good Luck!
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    No need to look for a solution. Tell him to do it right, his solution will be to put one cobble on top of another. This guy is an idiot. (Sorry for my description, but this kind of s___ is what gives the trades a bad name.)
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    @Al F.
    Can we have an...Amen!?
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Amen, Amen, Amen
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Flush on the stair treads...bull nose on the landing - so it is written for BC's building codes.
  • 12 years ago
    NO NO NO! You could be sued if someone trips because that is knowledgeable negligence.
    Get that fixed right now!
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Ah-ha... someone finally "dared" to touch on the subject of "liability"... I've been waiting for that.
  • 12 years ago
    I think your contractor was making up excuses for a duff job.
  • 12 years ago
    Sue him. before you have that accident.
  • 12 years ago
    nope! wrong! get that taken care of pronto..bad workmanship
  • 12 years ago
    I'd be ripping those nosings off and planing them down flush.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    Thats horrible and should be flush. That is one reason I do not recommend using flooring products on stairs, you never know what your getting. True, the installer should have padded the treads to compensate or planned bottom of nosing , but I strongly recommend using pre-finished (1-piece) stair treads.
  • PRO
    12 years ago
    last modified: 12 years ago
    @panamabound...
    No you wouldn't... doesn't work that way.
    The "trim" offered for these purposes is an "L" shaped piece... sometimes wood, sometimes wrapped in vinyl... regardless, if you "plane" the top off, there's nothing left but a flat front...
    These "approaches" are sold as an alternative to knowing how to do it right.
    It's bad enough that a DIY'er would take that route... but someone who proclaims themselves a professional... uh-uh!
  • 11 years ago

    I'm dealing this this issue right now. I was pissed off because the installer turned a 3 day project into a 6 day project. However, because he dawdled, he only installed 5 steps wrong, rather than 12. A blessing in disguise, I guess. 5 is too many of course. If it weren't a staircase, it would look cute, kinda like a kitchen cabinet. It feels like you're walking on a cabinet face, thus the danger. I'm hoping to get this fixed and redone shortly. . . .by someone else.

    I wasn't certain if this was installed incorrectly though it didn't feel right - literally. I had never seen a staircase with a lip until mine was installed. I'm not an expert on installing hardwood floors on stairs, but I'm an expert on walking on stairs. I searched "should a bullnose be flush with the tread?" I was hoping there would be some disagreement because getting it fixed is going to be a pain, but the verdict was overwhelmingly "guilty."

    I'm so glad I found this site.

  • 11 years ago
    August 8/14 post
  • 11 years ago

    August 8/14 post . . . .and?

  • 10 years ago
    I'm glad I found this. My installer just did this to two stairs. I knew something was wrong as soon as I saw it, but I'm glad this thread confirmed my suspicions.
  • 10 years ago

    Same situation here. He actually recommended he install it this way. I honestly have no experience with this sort of stuff, which is why I hired a "professional" for the job. Now I just feel stupid for allowing him to finish this

  • 10 years ago

    While all of the comments are about the personnel, the issue may be the product. Some products by some manufacturers (such as the Shaw laminate option we otherwise loved yesterday) only come with overlay bullnose. They don't *make* a flush bullnose.

  • 10 years ago

    The stairs of our new house are covered with laminate and the particular product only comes with an "overlay" type stair nosing. The result is uncomfortable and unattractive raised lips on each stair. Wonder if there are any fixes for this short of ripping up the product?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I posted last year about this situation. I wish I had posted again regarding the resolution on this. The product that I used was Schon engineered hardwood. Per the installer, they ONLY have overlapping bullnose, which was a sadly bad idea for them. I checked my local building codes which didn't indicate that overlapping bullnose would be in violation of the codes. Remember though that codes don't cove every potential safety issue and that you are the customer paying for the product. I insisted that the 5 previously installed steps have the bullnose replaced so that they were flush. It took over month to have it corrected and it appeared they were waiting me out in case I changed my mind. The installer had to trim the bottom of the product a little over an 1/8 of an inch to do this. They complained & hemmed and hawed, but I said better that than hearing from my lawyer if someone got injured falling down the steps. They acted as though they were doing me a favor when really I was doing THEM a favor by avoiding a lawsuit.

    So, yes, stupid manufacturers actually produce overlapping bullnose which is a tripping hazard. SMH. The only way to avoid this situation is to insist in the beginning that the bullnose is flush. Do not let them try to argue you out of it because building codes might not cover this issue. It's unsafe.

  • 10 years ago

    Thankyou, whirly, for your feedback.

    TWO YEAR OLD THREAD.

  • 10 years ago

    So, yes, just found this two year old thread. It is timely for me because I have taken the carpet out of master b/r, basement and off stairs in a house we just bought and I am looking into options for finishing the stairs and the rest of the bare subfloors with something other than carpet. I have been deeply unimpressed to find manufactured stair nosing pieces (for, I think, cork planks and vinyl planks) that wrap around the top of the riser and onto the tread above and that are MEANT to sit 1/4" above the level of the stair tread. Furthermore, because the material is prefinished, there's no planing it down to make it into a workable flush stair nosing. I walked up and down a staircase finished with such moulding in bare feet and it was a painful experience. It's a terrible design for stair nosings, but in my research I have found example after example of this sort of stair nosing. WHY? So now I find that all my flooring choices are being driven and severely limited by the fact that I am insisting on a flush stair nosing (that's not utilitarian rubber). I've walked into a number of flooring stores and they don't seem to get what I'm being so picky about. It's turning into a pretty frustrating experience. I would be interested to know, pattigaff, if you see this post, what solution your installer came up with for you.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I feel bad complaining about this, since only the top step is an issue as I carpeted the stairs in berber, but my second floor laminate stair nose is overlapping and I HATE IT. It's a deep and visceral hate full of disappointment that my newly installed floors are ruined the moment you get to the top of the stairs.

    To make it worse, the flooring (a fairly expensive Kronotech laminate) doesn't seem to come with matching transitions. I specifically asked before the installation if the colour would match and was assured it would, but it's not even close.

    I have been been told they will attempt to find a better colour match in either vinyl (not loving that idea) or custom stained wood. But no matter what they say I'm stuck with the overlapping bullnose because you can't install flush once the rest of the stairs are installed. Is this really true or am I getting a lazy answer?

    I found a YouTube tutorial on how to make a custom flush stair nose out of the laminate you're using, and it's hugely disappointing to be told this isn't an option at this point. Knowing that I wanted the laminate to appear as close to the real thing as possible, why on earth would they have thought I'd be happy with an overlapping nosing?!

  • 9 years ago

    I know someone who has this installed. I have problems going up and down their stairs. It feels unsteady and definitely a trip hazard. The company should make a flush system. I recommend carpeting the staircase rather than doing this.

  • 8 years ago
    Unfortunatly this is installed correctly. We just got this exact style of bullnose because it came with the flooring we bought. We returned it when we found out this is how it was supposed to look and thankfully found a flush bullnose in a similar color flooring to match what we had already installed. Im glad we went to the trouble because this style really does not look professional.
  • 8 years ago
    No it is NOT CORRECT. It should be flush. It is a trip hazard
  • 8 years ago
    I’ve seen that so many times, it helped make the decision to keep carpet on my tract home staircase. I could not see spending the necessary money for a quality job.
  • 8 years ago

    We have new LVP floors and wood stairs - happy with both of those individually but the bullnose 1/4” tripping hazard on top & landing! I couldn’t find a definitive solution in above comments??

  • 8 years ago

    The installation is correct. There are two types of stair noses - flush and overlap. Engineered and LVP have overlap noses; solid hardwood are generally one solid piece for the tread. T&G solid has flush noses.

  • 6 years ago

    This is not the right way to install the no bowl.

    But because those stairs we made and are avalibe in market for cheap price the installer use them because it is chape, will tell you that is today popular fashion in the market.

  • 6 years ago

    Could we glue a piece of laminate to the tread to mske it even?

  • 6 years ago

    Try laying a piece of Luan on the tread base and then putting your tread material over it. That might make up the difference in thickness and bring your tread up level with that stupid bullnose.

  • 4 years ago

    I had a similar installation recently. Luckily, the company I went with is going to replace it all. I'm going to be honest, I grew up with hardwood stairing but it was already in the home when we bought it (i knew a lot about home projects and very little about wood stairs). The comments that flooring should never be used on stairs, I 100% agree. It should be solid oak. I honestly can't think of why an overlap stairnose would be used. Seems like a horrible idea, even if the manufacturer recommended it. Anybody know of anyone who got the bullnose aka overlap nose and actually liked it? I've definitely learned my lesson the hard way. Now I have to make sure whatever we replace it with is correct and start over.

  • 11 months ago

    When my stair treads were installed with the raised bullnose, I called the manufacturer of the flooring who said it was, indeed, supposed to be raised. It is simply a different style of tread. Since it is painful to walk on, I’m installing carpet treads to go behind the bullnose so it will be an even surface.