Software
Houzz Logo Print
harkdh1

When is a kitchen sink to big?

7 days ago
last modified: 7 days ago

Hi, I'm looking to upgrade my 25 year old sink to a workstation sink without changing the counter tops. The existing cutout is 33" x 19.5", whereby excluding any possibility of an under-mount (front to back is way to wide). So I will be getting a drop in... but because the side to side dimension is already 33", I must go up to the next larger which is 36" x 22". Wondering if such a large sink might look a bit ridiculous? The counter top is 11.5' long and the cabinets are 36". Thanks for your thoughts.



Comments (26)

  • 7 days ago

    I do not think it will look ridiculous at all on an 11.5 foot run, a 36 inch sink fills a 36 inch cabinet the way it is meant to. I went bigger on my own kitchen sink and the single large bowl is what I reach for every time I wash a baking tray, the workstation ledge just makes it look deliberate rather than oversized.

    harkdh1 thanked bibleblessings
  • 7 days ago

    Try using tape to mark out the size , it might help with your decision to be able to see the dimensions.

    harkdh1 thanked kazzh
  • PRO
    7 days ago
    last modified: 7 days ago

    It could be the only issue is the divide in the sink. A single bowl might be enough. JMO that "workstation" is just an expensive route to stuff you already own and unnecessary gadgets, bells and whistles.

    A good knife, a cutting board and garlic , onions whatever ? Easy peasy.

    harkdh1 thanked JAN MOYER
  • PRO
    7 days ago

    First that curved sink you have is in a space that was fabricated for that sink , the width is not the big issue. Workstation sinks are IMO ridiculous since the minute you use any of the addons you now have only 1/2 the sink. IMO there is no way to upgrade to a new sink in that space without changing the counter . That counter will need to be cut on site and I honestly do not think it will survive. Get some assurance from whoever is going to cut the coulnter then see what is possible for a new sink

    harkdh1 thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • PRO
    7 days ago

    The first thing to consider is freeing yourself from the riser height/bar stool issue.

    Show the entire kitchen?

    Sometimes.,... pecking at small areas, is a juice not worth the squeeze.

    Stand back, get all angles and add pictures of the whole: )

    harkdh1 thanked JAN MOYER
  • 7 days ago

    @Joseph Corlett, LLC had a business that specialized in sink replacements. I believe he has a sink he recommends with a stainless faucet deck to account for the depth of the old sink.

    Photos on his website: https://www.ihatemysink.com/before-after

    harkdh1 thanked chispa
  • PRO
    7 days ago

    honestly 36 on an 11.5' run with a 36" base won't look silly at all, it's proportional. the real catch is the 22" depth. measure from the cutout edge to your backsplash and faucet holes, and check the sink base interior width since drop-in rims and clips need room. tape the new outline on the counter first, then have the fabricator confirm the stone can be enlarged on site without cracking.

    harkdh1 thanked Boss Design Center
  • 7 days ago

    Thanks everyone for your comments. I've already spoken to a professional granite cutter and have an idea what's involved there. As to the undermount option, note my sink has the faucet inset, whereby there is no room to move it back to accommodate an undermount. Plus undermounts are typically 19" front to back, the existing hole is 19.5" inches. But looking at @Joseph Corlett, LLC response, seems there might be an undermount option with a built-in faucet deck, I will investigate that further, starting with the link @chispa provided. Yes, the bar-height counter does have the issue that the faucet cannot go back any further than it already is (not much room anyway). I've looked at dozens of sinks, and this one seems to fit the bill the best... is Sarlai considered a decent sink?


    https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0D2NBNZ1Q?smid=A1OW1F8GNYOGLZ&th=1


    Heck, with a little ingenuity, I wonder if I can undermount it instead?



  • 7 days ago

    I have this sink as a top mount, but it can be an undermount as well. I think it would work with your dimensions since it has the built in facuet deck.

    https://www.kraususa.com/kwt310-33-workstation-33-drop-in-undermount-16-gauge-stainless-steel-single-bowl-kitchen-sink.html

  • 7 days ago

    @kiniyagirl, I saw that one... I wanted an offset drain but sadly the existing plumbing and electrical under the cabinet will not allow the garbage disposal to be located in that one particular space. I looked at Kraus and they do not make a 36" sink with a center drain.

  • 7 days ago

    Just realized that under-mounting a 36" sink will not work with 36" cabinets. All roads lead to Rome :-) So to keep it simple, drop-in 36" sink, center drain, I think I can live with that assuming it does not overwhelm the counter space, which it seems most feel it'd be OK.

  • 7 days ago

    @harkdh1- I am pretty sure you can undermouth a 36" sink in a 36" cabinet. On the advice of @Joseph Corlett, LLC I was able to undermount a 30" sink in a 30" cabinet, using the sinkit sink straps. I have done this multiple times in rental properties. The sinkit straps are very easy to use for a DIYer.

  • PRO
    7 days ago

    A 36" sink is standard. Nothing ridiculous about it.

    harkdh1 thanked CAGE Design Build
  • 7 days ago
    last modified: 7 days ago

    @harkdh1- one last thought, if you can't do an off set drain- I initally considered this Ruvati sink with a center drain, but toward the rear of the sink. I am not sure if it can be undermounted, but the top looks pretty flat, I think undermounting it with the sinkit sink straps would be worth a try..

    https://www.ruvati.com/products/rvh8003-33-x-22-inch-workstation-ledge-drop-in-16-gauge-stainless-steel-kitchen/

    harkdh1 thanked kiniyagirl
  • 7 days ago

    @kiniyagirl, yes I see that now, missed it before. That kit does not require cutting the cabinet walls at all, thanks for the tip! Will mull it over for a few days... seems the only change for the quote I already have is to install the straps and buff the granite edges. Thanks everyone for your helpful comments.

  • PRO
    6 days ago

    "Just realized that under-mounting a 36" sink will not work with 36" cabinets."


    harkdh1:


    You are mistaken. I have literally done this hundreds of times in my sink replacement business. If your sink base cabinet is 36", a 36" sink will undermount.


    If you want a top mount, go for it. It's faster and easier, but not fitting has been removed from your excuse list.

  • 6 days ago

    If Joe says it'll work as an undermount using straps check with more contractors until you find one who also sees no problem.

  • 5 days ago

    Go for split one maybe, large main sink that fits your oven trays and second smaller one to have handy for stuff when you have suds in the main one

  • 4 days ago

    Call Creategoodsinks! The best!

  • 4 days ago
    last modified: 4 days ago

    Right away I see the biggest problem with this kitchen is the ugly black counters - what a crazy fad and thankfully it has come and gone and many people need to get rid of them.

    Sinks are too large when you have to bend your back to clean the bottom, and if you have to bend to reach the handles.

    And - note that sinks with two bowls are difficult to use and wash a larger pan - best to have one bowl. And in an area with water being used and splashed - try to find one with drainboards on the sides - they are available.


    And avoid the new stupid fad of square corners in sinks - difficult to keep clean and looks stupid.

  • 4 days ago

    I tune in to Houzz “working on” just to read terrib comments. 😮😳😂

  • 4 days ago

    Random thoughts:

    - A kitchen sink is too big when it cuts into much-needed storage. And I don't hear you saying that's an issue.

    - 36" is probably the most common size we see mentioned here, but 33" is barely any smaller, and 30" will do in a small kitchen. Larger than 36" really is pointless.

    - Workstation sinks are absolutely wonderful! Since you have to cut out what you have now, Joseph's image above is the right choice. (Note: He's always right.)

    - One-bowl -- yes, yes, yes!

    - Drain in one corner -- eh, nice but not necessary.

    - Connect it to a quiet disposal, and you have a great set-up.

  • 4 days ago

    @Mrs Pete, good point, my garbage disposal is obnoxiously loud, can you recommend a brand and horsepower for a small household?

  • PRO
    3 days ago

    Insinkerator Pro 3/4 horsepower. Quieter than most.


    harkdh1 thanked JAN MOYER
  • 2 days ago

    I have a large kitchen with a 30" sink! Plenty big. I did get a model with an integrated 18" drainboard, because it looks nicer/sleeker than a dish rack sitting on the counter.

    48" x 18' opening. The DW sits under the drainboard, so the sink cabinet is 33".



Sponsored
The Creative Kitchen Company
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars52 Reviews
Columbus Area Kitchen Remodeling and Refacing Professional