Software
Houzz Logo Print
startingsomethingnew

Should we add more honey oak trim to the 2nd floor addition or not?

We are in the final stages of adding 1900 sf of space below our existing home. A project we started a few years back and put on hold when the housing market was wavering. We didn't want to overbuild for our area. We originally built our home in 93 when honey oak, polished brass and shades of green were popular. Everything has been painted to a neutral Sherwin Williams color called Brown Sugar which matches well with the tone of the honey oak. All our existing windows and doors, mantle and hearth, bathroom vanities, window seats and built in's are all honey oak. The house design leans towards a transitional style. We are having trouble deciding whether to install the same oak trim in the lower addition for continuity or use a darker oak trim, or just install painted trim which would keep the cost down but give the new floor a different look which I'm not too crazy about. We have 3 solid oak french doors leading to the exterior decks that I stained a darker shade than the honey oak. I think that the honey oak is nice but it seems out of style and I like the clean look of painted trim. Before making the investment in more oak to wrap all the window casings, trims and baseboards for the addition as well as the stair case I was looking for ideas that may be helpful.

Comments (10)

  • 11 years ago
    I would get a large piece of trim and do all 3 colors on it you can cut the trim up in 3 sections or leave it then place it on the floor so you can visualize what all 3 options would look like. Personally I wouldn't go with the same as upstairs. You have updated to 2014 stay with that it doesn't have to be the same. Look at it like paint every room doesn't have to match but it should go together. If you don't love it don't do it. It's better to wait and find something you love then doing it because it needs to get finished. It's just trim do the sample and find what you love not what is just ok.
    Starting Something New thanked Janel Stroud
  • PRO
    11 years ago
    Go with what you like with the addition especially if there are plans to renovate the existing parts of the house.
    Starting Something New thanked Dytecture
  • 11 years ago
    I'd say go with the painted trim, save the money and stay in style.
    Starting Something New thanked Craig CraigMDesigns
  • 11 years ago
    The stairway leading down to the addition will be in the living room area of the home. The railing style, choice of material and color for the stairway will be the initial visual introduction to the new living area. The ceilings in the addition are 9' with coffered ceilings in the master bedroom and bare wood exposed beams with black brackets in the family room. There will also be a stacked stone wall around the gas fireplace. The family room and game room are all open around the stair way.
    We live in the mountains near Lake Tahoe and we like the wood, stone and metal elements in the house.
    I like the idea of going with a wider base board trim in a darker stain but the sticky part is how to wrap the windows? They are all encased with oak in the original area of the home. Then the baseboard trim runs right up to the trim around each of the painted doors. It was all custom wood work.
    When the addition is done, it would be nice to have the house feel like one original build. That was our goal in the beginning, it's just tying in the finish design elements that is where we're getting hung up on.
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    I would consider painting over all the honey oak to a color like "taupe" that would immediately give you a much more transitional feel and cohesion to the entire house. Also gives you the flexibility of any color rather than trying to continue with the 1990's honey oak theme.

  • PRO
    11 years ago


    Example of the taupe and the two wood types used together for a more sophisticated look.

  • 11 years ago
    What color wall should I paint ?
    In kitchen
    In living room
    In dining room
    In master bedroom

    Thank you !!
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    old post...Faye you might want to start your own topic. It will get more responses. You will want to show more than 1 photo at a bad angle...that will also help.


  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Your oak color is very much a neutral and won't have a big impact on color selection. Try to find something in the palette of furnishings or general personal preferences. Please send me some more comprehensive photos that include some of your furnishings in each room and I can give a better answer.