Software
Houzz Logo Print
zaphod42_gw

Best medium for starting seeds

12 years ago

In a previous thread I was advised to use a seed starting medium that wasn't primarily composed of peat. Since then I've been casually looking at the seed starting mixes at Home Depot, Steins, etc. Everything I've run across so far is 60-90% peat. Any recommendations for brands that aren't primarily peat? I'm not starting a whole ton so don't want to blend my own or have to buy a gigantic bag. Thanks!

Comments (6)

  • 11 years ago

    I just caught your post, so I'm not sure what the other advice was about but as long as it's not pure peat it sounds fine to me for seed starting.... but I'm far from an expert and often just use bagged potting soil for my seeds (as long as it's a soilless mix). Only for a few special seeds do I mix in perlite or grit or something else to make it a looser mix.

  • 11 years ago

    back in the day ... i went to the high end garden store.. and asked them to order some for me ... i highly doubt you will find it in bigboxstore ...

    media is all about water management ... as you should know ...

    many potting media are very course .. leaving big open spaces for water to move thru.. as well as air ... for root development ....

    a seedling media.. is much finer ground... so that the seeds will stay in contact with it .. while developing a root mass ...

    you repot and move out of the seedling media.. rather quickly ...

    its just one of many variables.. TO THINK ABOUT ... i would NOT get all tied up in thinking it is imperative in success .. so on that logic.. what was the reason or problem you previously had.. that led to the suggestions of a seedling media????

    ken


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi zaphod,

    " Everything I've run across so far is 60-90% peat. Any recommendations for brands that aren't primarily peat? "

    I wouldn't call 60% peat primarily peat. I would call 90% peat primarily peat. Is your objection to peat that it is too water retentive ? You can always reduce the water retentiveness of a mix by adding extra Horticultural Perlite. (Hoffman's or Miracle-Gro are good brands of it.) Don't use a non-horticultural grade of Perlite, because it could have a lot of fines and present a dust hazard. Perlite chunks retain air and don't become waterlogged. Vermiculite, on the other hand, does retain water, so, in that regard, Vermiculite functions the same as Peat. Also be sure to use a horticultural grade Vermiculite for safety. Some industrial grades could be hazardous to handle.

    I use Premier Pro-Mix BX, which already has added some Perlite and Limestone (for calcium nutrition and pH adjustment). I usually add some extra Perlite to my Pro-Mix. I frequently cover my seeds with Country Cottage Horticultural Vermiculite because it is fine-grained, retains water well, and yet the seedlings have no difficulty pushing up through it.

    If you wanted to exclude Peat altogether (some people object to depleting the natural supply of a resource beyond its renewable rate), you could formulate your own mix using just horticultural Perlite and horticultural Vermiculite. I would start off at about 2/3 Vermiculite and 1/3 Perlite. If you are really concerned about good drainage, you could go 50-50 on the formula.

    Small seeds (for example, non-pelleted petunia seeds), could fall down too deep in a coarse mix. To prevent that, I would include a thin layer of non-additive toilet tissue below the seeds, to keep them in place without interfering with their root growth.

    There are some people who favor tree bark as an ingredient in growing mixes, and some commercial mixes contain a significant amount of it.

    ZM (not associated with any product or vendor mentioned)

  • 11 years ago

    The Pro-Mix ZM mentions is very good. I haven't found any lately (but I haven't looked real hard, either). Another good choice would be Fafard Seed Starter available at Stein's. I usually blend ingredients as ZM mentioned, but these products are good as is for starting the seeds. You could wait to mix the other things in as you pot up.
    tj


  • 11 years ago

    Hi tsugajunkie,

    " I haven't found any lately (but I haven't looked real hard, either) "

    Home Depot has recently started carrying Pro-Mix BX. Their packaging is a bit different, in that they carry half-size 2-cubic-foot compressed bales instead of the usual large 4-cubic-foot compressed bales. And the Home Depot bales are orange and white, instead of the usual black and gray tones that we are used to. Their price is competitive, too, $13 and change for the half size bale. And the smaller bales are easier to handle. If you have a Home Depot handy, check them out to see if your local store has it.

    ZM (not associated with any product or vendor mentioned)

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks ZM.

    tj


Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals