Software
Houzz Logo Print
melosgirl

Raised Garden Bed - How Big?

16 years ago

I am planning to build a raised garden bed. The purpose of the bed is to grow vegetables for my family of five. Ideally I'd like to grow tomatoes, peppers, zucchini, green beans and brussel sprouts, or just about anything that will taste great grilled. Perhaps also a section for cilantro. I am not sure how long to make the bed. I am planning for it to be 4' wide and about 28' long. Will this size garden give me an adequate yield of vegetables throughout our short growing season (zone 7 NJ), or should I build a longer garden bed? All advice appreciated. Thanks.

Comments (22)

  • 16 years ago

    112 sqft is a respectable place to start off. If you find you need more, what about building additional beds instead of elongating that one.

  • 16 years ago

    melosgirl, this is just my humble opinion, more is better, if you have the space , materials and strength, once you start growing seems like you always need more space because you will want to try say, watermelon or some crop that takes a fair amount of room, last year was my first to plant. I built a 4x8 bed just for tomatos and peppers, it just wasn`t big enough for any real harvest for two people, now I am busy trying to build more raised beds and get the soil conditioned for spring. And I wish I had a better plan when I started, Also go to the soil forum to get an idea of what you need to fill your raised beds with, the people are so helpful, there is a wealth of knowledge here on this website. I hope that it doesn`t sound like I am talking down to you, your post reads like you haven`t had any experience with veggies and I personally find veggie gardening to be more intense than planting flowers, more of a loss so to speak. I hope your veggie garden is a success. :o)Deanna

  • 16 years ago

    I agree with Deanna - more is better. ;) Multiple beds have advantages over 1 giant bed but it all depends on the space you have - don't waste space on paths unless you have ample room to work with.

    Also consider whether you will be tilling these beds or not? If so, one huge bed is easier to till than several small ones.

    Dave

  • 16 years ago

    I would do two beds, rather than one 28' long bed, because it will get annoying soon enough having to travel all the way around to get to the other side.

    I have 4x12' beds now, and like them. For our new place, I'm planning on 4x16' beds for the main garden, and 4x4' boxes closest to the kitchen for things like lettuce and herbs that I want close at hand.

    If you're not a seasoned gardener, I'd recommend starting with two 16' long beds, and leaving room to expand later. The best thing to do is start small and not get overwhelmed by trying to do everything at once.

    Another thing to consider is who will be tending the garden. I'm 5'10" so I can reach into the 4' wide beds, but if you're shorter, or want to have your kids help out, 3' beds might be easier to weed and plant without stepping in them.

  • 16 years ago

    I agree with ribbit. She also juggles garden and family.

    Curt~

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks, Curt. Melosgirl, I agree that more is always better, but if it's your first garden, there is so much to get frustrated with -bugs, soil, pollination issues, etc- that it's easy to get discouraged. If you're not pressed to do it all at once, grow your garden as your knowledge grows. Do one bed, say 4x16 or 4x12, easy sizes to find lumber already cut in, now in the spring. Learn. Do another bed or two if you want for the summer. Learn. Then do another in the fall if you think it necessary. Make sure you also learn as you go how to preserve everyting your family doesn't consume.

    However, as everyone else has said, it's always necessary to have more beds, or you'll find some excuse for it to be. ;)Fall 2008 I started with 18 sqft, learned as I went and I'm now up to 204 and looking to put in another 32 sqft in for the summer. It's not a lot by other's standards, but it gives me enough to do without overwhelming me.

  • 16 years ago

    The first rule of gardening is that the garden is never big enough. Now I suppose it's better to have a smaller garden to which you can pay adequate attention than to have a large garden that gets out of hand because you don't have the time to maintain it. But still, I'll wager that you won't find too many gardeners on this site who would say "Yep, the garden is big enough, I'm good."

    4'X28' is certainly a good start. Many people start gardening with smaller spaces than this and quickly get frustrated because they run out of room by the end of May. With a single bed this size, you'll be able to raise some of everything that you mentioned, but not a lot of each.

    You've got the width right - 4' wide beds offer you the ability to comfortably reach half way across the bed from either size. If it were me, I'd probably make a second bed of the same size and parallel to the first, with a 3' permanent path between.

    Anyway, it's a great thing you're doing for yourself and your family, so do whatever feels right and have fun out there. Congratulations on a wise decision!

    -Diggity

    Here is a link that might be useful: Garden Imperative

  • 16 years ago

    for us that is app' 1meter wide and 6meters long no more than 10 meters long. easy to mange no need to trample garden ever.

    len

    Here is a link that might be useful: lens garden page

  • 16 years ago

    I would make the beds as long as you like but keep the width to about 4 feet at most. That way you have access from other side and don't need to reach too far or step into the bed compacting the soil. I grow all my veggies in either raised beds or containers. If you are interested, a link to my blog on the subject is below. I will post about raised beds in the future.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Vegetables and Fruit Container Gardening

  • 16 years ago

    I find that a 12 foot bed is as long as I want to walk around and 8' is better yet "LBE".(Lloyd)

    Curt :-)

  • 16 years ago

    The width is a matter of ergonomics. That means you have to be able to reach from both side to weed, pick and plant, comfortably.
    But the length depends on the land one has. But, even then there is some ergonomics and visual factors involved.
    I would not have a bed longer than 15FT. If I have a 30ft run, I will make two or three beds instead of one. It is just like a house design. I do not like a shot gun house.

  • 16 years ago

    1) It is her first garden, and the OP seems interested only in summer vegetables. 112 sqft will feed a family of five through the summer, no problem, especially if there are green beans and tomatoes. So, two major points in favor of it being big enough. In Zone 7, the beans will kick in in late June, and the tomatoes in mid-July. There will be no eating after first frost or before. Plenty big.

    2) Put up a trellis for the pole beans, and place them on the North end of the bed

    3) You have picked good vegetables for BBQing, but the best BBQ vegetable IMHO is eggplant.

    4) 4ft is the maximum width really. As I get older, I am leaning more and more towards 3 ft. But in the old days, everything was 4 ft wide.

  • 16 years ago

    Normally I try not to chat it up on these forums, but diggity ma, I swear I haven't laughed out loud like that in a LONG time reading this:
    ... I'll wager that you won't find too many gardeners on this site who would say "Yep, the garden is big enough, I'm good."

    My husband thinks I have some kind of mental illness, he sees the evidence in all the seed packets I acquire that I have no more room to plant (I'll squeeze that ornamental pepper in somewhere darnit...or that every surface in my house is covered in seedlings in one stage of growth or another...

    Thanks for the smile :)

  • 16 years ago

    Lots of great advice here. Now, once you have figured out how to arrange those 112 square feet, you are going to have to figure out how to get the best soil into those square feet.

    There's always something more to learn for sure...

    Michael

  • 16 years ago

    I agree that most gardeners will say they never have enough space for everything. However, being fairly new to gardening, on many forums, I've been told "start small".

    There is the danger of being overwhelmed by a big garden. It's also important to break a long bed into two or three sections, so you don't have to walk around such a long bed to reach the other side.

    These two points have been mentioned already, but I think they're worth repeating. While gardening is fun, it's important to start with a reasonable size bed, so it will continue to be fun. After this year, you'll have more of an idea how much you may want to expand and what you'll want to grow more of next year.

    Do try the pole beans. They're a lot of fun and in your zone, should do very well. My favorite is Emerite and Purple Pole beans mixed together. Emerite has lavender flowers with green beans and purple pole has purple flowers with purple beans...that turn dark green when you cook them. Great if you have kids helping in the garden. Both beans have a really good flavor, too :)

  • 16 years ago

    How deep are you going to make it? The soil will push against the sides of the bed with quite a bit of force. Our school made 2' tall beds that were 4x8' with the screws going through the ends of the 8' sides into the 4' sides - the screws all pulled out in 1 season. It works better to screw from the short side into the long side because there is less outward pressure on the short side. But when you make the sides REALLY long, like 28', you'll probably find that your garden is 5' wide in the middle in a couple years.

    Make sure that all your paths easily accommodate your wheelbarrow.

  • 16 years ago

    I have two 4'6" x 35'. I know that is long but I wanted growing space not walk space. So, I plant herbs in the middle and if I have to step thru them-they don't care.

    Tips for growing LOTS:
    1. Incredible soil w/ lots of organic matter. Soil tested and ammended to be in balance (or close to it). With that kind of soil, your plants will be big and prolific and one bed will be enough for a short time.
    2. Two beds are much better so you can plan overlap between seasons, rotate around to grow organically, try experimental plants.
    3. Use trellis and poles to grow as much as you can upright. You can get a lot that way.
    4. Grow Suyo Long cukes. 4 plants on a 3'x 7'trellis will feed my family, everyone in the office and some for the compost pile.
    5. More space allows for continuous harvest. I know you said your season was short, but it would probably still apply. I plant pole beans, for instance, March 1. By May, they are spent (disease and age). But, if I have another set of poles (away from these), then I can plant April 15 to extend my harvest further.
    6. Try a bed for corn. Minimum 3'x 3' or double that for 2 crops. Corn is GOOD eating!! Corn does not need to be rotated so it is the same every year. I grown fall crops like lettuce, beets, carrots there.

  • 16 years ago

    Thank you all for the terrific advice. Diggity has the right idea for me. I am on an acre of land but it's in a newer community, not farm land. I have trees around my property line which we planted four years ago and plenty of butterfly bushes and ornamental grasses for interest. I have always been an avid gardener and started container (vegetable) gardening on my patio when we moved to this house with mostly good success. My cukes were doing beautifully until the cucumber beetles found them. It was just was not big enough. Two beds 4 feet by 24 feet long, with a 3 foot path in between just may be the ticket. My wonderful husband is happy to build it for me (lucky me!). I will have to enclose the entire vegetable garden area with chicken wire to keep the deer out. Now I have to figure out what kind of soil to put in, but that's another topic. Again, thank you all so much!

  • 16 years ago

    The best advice I ever received and therefore the best I can give is get a hold of the book 'All New Square Foot Gardening' by Mel Barthelemew. He tells you everything (and I mean everything) you need to know about building a raised bed (sqaure foot) garden, the soil mix that works best, how to plant, what to plant. It's absolutely genius.

  • 16 years ago

    This will be my first year trying to grow in a raised bed and if I have enough concrete blocks, it will be 4' x 80'. That's not really all that big - my back yard garden is 900 square feet and I never have enough room.

    Mike

  • 16 years ago

    melosgirl - Gee - I looked through all of the posts, and couldn't find anything to offer - great stuff!

    However, one small item - if you are going to raise pole beans or sugar snap peas, along with shorter plants in front of them - broccoli, cabbage, etc., then it would be nice to run those long beds east and west. Then the beans and peas could go north side, and you could plant lots more, without shading other things. The smaller stuff could go southerly - onions, garlic in front.

    If doing raised beds in boxes - a board spread across the middle - could become a convenient bridge if needed later.

    Let us know how it turns out. Nice to have such a sweet husband too.

    Just my 2 c's.

    Bejay

  • 16 years ago

    I don't think that raised beds are practical for vining vegetables like peas beans, cucumber, squash. Because they either lot more room to run or climb.