Software
Houzz Logo Print
lantanascape

Styrofoam insulation in a raised bed?

16 years ago

I was wondering if this would be safe. I would like to build a couple of 4x4' raised redwood beds that would be right outside the back door. I want them to be chair height, with about a 6" overhang so that they could be sat on. Being in an arid area, watering could be an issue with a smaller, very raised bed, and I was thinking that with the overhang, it might not be a bad idea to line the boxes with rigid styrofoam insulation - this would moderate temperature swings, protect the wood, and I think it would also help with moisture retention and water wouldn't be seeping out and evaporating at the board joints. These would also be used as cold frames in the winter, so the insulation would have definite advantages for that application. Are there drawbacks to this that I'm not thinking about? Not sure about the safety of it, but styrofoam drink cups are common so... ?

Comments (6)

  • 16 years ago

    I have not quite wrapped my head around the benefits, but I would say that the top edges of the insulation exposed at soil level would degrade quite quickly, especially if you are using tools for cultivation.

    Michael

  • 16 years ago

    lantanascape

    I can visualize what you have in mind, I believe, and agree that there might be the benefits you are suggesting, like water retention, at least on the sides of the bed, and temperature stabilization in the bed.

    My concern would be aeration in the lower levels of soil, something I pay attention to. I'm not sure if the impermeability of rigid styrofoam (on the inside walls of the bed?) would eventually cause plant root suffocation or not, without some "breathing" mechanism in the soil. Maybe there would be no difference between such a bed and a huge pot with plenty of drainage. Your best source of information about your question might be Al (tapla), who hangs out in the Container and Soil forums.

    Unless someone has some other reasons why that might not work, you can certainly try it and see what happens.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I was thinking of doing that exact kind of garden bed this coming spring ( 2017) I can't see any aeration issues with doing this. But I think using a mix of potting soil wouldn't hurt. If you build a bed using composite plastic walls it would be the same situation. I'm going to give it a go. It will help stop decay of the wood frame. I checked and styrophome doesn't decompose till 25 years or more.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Several of us have tested several types of insulated beds and now have a fairly simple designed that allow us to raise cold hardy veggies all winter with an insulated bed. Zone 5

    The insulation must must go down into the ground. If it just stops at the dirt it does little to no good as the frozen cold dirt below the bed that is in contact with the raised bed soil and easily cools the raised bed soil to the same temp as the dirt.

    The he next raised bed I build will have below grade tolerant 4" insulation 2 foot buried I down into the dirt and will stick 2 feet above the dirt. Then the raised bed will be built around it.

    This allows the soil below the bed to be separated from the soil all around the bed. And the soil below the bed acts as a large thermal mass that retains heat.

  • 9 years ago

    I'd be afraid of the chemicals in the styrofoam leaching into the soil. A google search will give you tons of research that says when styrofoam gets hot, it leaches many, many cancer causing chemicals. Not in my garden....

Sponsored
Hope Restoration & General Contracting
Average rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars35 Reviews
Columbus Design-Build, Kitchen & Bath Remodeling, Historic Renovations