Software
Houzz Logo Print
djn123

SWC lime question for Justaguy

17 years ago

Hi

Just a clarification requested about the quantity of dolomitic lime to add to 1 cubic ft of homemade potting mix (peat. perlite, vermiculite). In a previous thread( (2nd last post http://forums2.gardenweb.com/forums/load/contain/msg0405253423105.html?8) you recommended 1/4 cup, yet according to the earthbox site 1-2 cups is suitable. Given that my SWCs all contain chillis and the water in my area is hard, can u confirm the quantity required? I should add I am trying to source "white" (LIGHT BROWN) sphagnum peat moss which tends to have a low ph of around 3-4. Thanks again!

Comments (4)

  • 17 years ago

    With respect to the EB folks who I think made a terrific product, they are very confused on the lime issue. A few years back I discussed this with a couple of their folks and they seem to change their liming advice frequently. I don't know if they are still repeating the myth that tomatos prefer alkaline conditions or not, but they used to so they recommended a heavy lime application for tomatos. Then they expanded it to all plants, but at half the rate. They have also, in the past, perhaps still, given advice that blossom end rot was due to a calcium deficiency in the soil rather than an environmentally induced calcium deficiency in the plant so they advised to add hydrated lime to the reservoir if plants got BER in spite of all the lime already added.

    In any event their liming recommendations, while not harmful, are excessive. 1 cup of lime per cubic foot on top of a store bought mix that is limed for pH by the maker is a waste.

    You could use 1/4th-1/2 cup dolomitic lime and be just fine with a peat or bark based mix that is not prelimed (such as when making one's own mix). I tend to use the lower of the two amounts as my tap water would be solid if it contained much more limestone ;) It's around 440 TDS with much of that calcium. I also use a fertilizer that contains 2% calcium.

    If you are at all in doubt then by all means use 1/2 cup per cubic foot, it won't harm a thing. You could even use the 1 cup per cubic foot as EB recommends, but I promise you it isn't at all necessary.

    I have grown tomatos and peppers for years. They were in the very first garden I ever grew. I have never had a BER problem that was anything more than minor and quickly self correcting. It's likely due more to my climate than anything else.

    Your call. ;)

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks very much for the explanation! Good to hear that less is more...

  • 17 years ago

    Hello I am new to this forum and I would like to know what SWC and BER stand for. I am growing both tomatoes and peppers in 5 gallon pots.

  • 17 years ago

    SWC= Self Watering Container such as the EarthBox
    BER= Blossom End Rot which is a common problem with tomatos and peppers where the bottom of the developing fruit rots. It is caused by a calcium deficiency in the developing fruit. It can occur due to not enough calcium available in the growing medium, but more commonly it is an environmentally induced calcium mobility problem in the plant. Too hot, too humid, growth too fast etc. In most cases, for most people, BER is a short lived problem that self corrects, but some varieties are more predisposed to it than others and some climates/weather conditions make it more likely than others.

0