Software
Houzz Logo Print
richdelmo

Earthbox Disapointment

19 years ago

Disappointment

After experiencing an abnormal number amount of BER many of the leaves on the two tomato plants in my earthbox are rapidly turning yellow and dying. This just started over the past week to a point that at least 25% of both plants are infected and with whatever. A second earthbox is experiencing the same problem but not quite as bad. Ironically my tomatoes in ground just next to the earthboxes are still doing just fine, just a hint of yellowing.. I followed all instructions for growing in the eartboxes and at one time was tempted to add lime, but was convinced not by Justaguy (I think it was he), watered daily only missing a few days but never more than one consecutively. The only extra thing I did was to water the foliage with neptunes harvest.

Was two indeterminate plants too much for one box?

Any thoughtsÂanyone have a similar experience?

BTW few good fruit developed without ber, the overall foliage was huge.

Comments (9)

  • 19 years ago

    The first thing I'd do is move the EB's away from the healthy plants.

  • 19 years ago

    If you check into the tomato forum's FAQ pages, you'll find out that no one knows exactly why BER even hits. Some guesses, but no definitive answer. Doesn't help any, when it does hit. (I'm 80% BER this year with 4 outta 5 tomato plants. The one that hasn't been hit is the only cherry tomato, which is touching one that is being hit, so I don't know if it's contagious. Never heard that one before, but then again, I'm not a great gardener yet.) Since those, who do think they know what causes it (minor minerals missing in the soil, especially calcium)I've added a couple dozen egg shells into the five container, and have seen no difference.

    I do know container plants are harder to keep healthy, since we wash out the nutrition in the soil every time we water them. Then again, that's why we need to constantly fertilze them -- first by adding time-released fertilizer in the soil at planting time, and then adding water-soluable fertilizer at least weekly. Still, have done that too, and well...that didn't help.

    Rumor has it, the BER usually only hits the first crop of tomatoes, but, it's the end of August, and we're still on the first crop! With that, the only thing I can really offer is that it probably isn't you. You can always try contacting the company that you bought the box from and ask them. Doubly sad to hear about your problems, since I was considering Earthbox for mine next year. If that company does tell what went wrong, I'd love to find out!

    Lynn

  • 19 years ago

    You didn't add (hydrated) lime to the Earthbox soil before planting the tomatoes? I mix 2 cups of the lime into the top 3-4 inches of soil before planting; I've been growing tomatoes in Earthboxes for about 5 years now, and don't have the yellowing problem you describe - and I always put two plants per box, determinate and/or indeterminate. This year I had 'patio' tomatoes (determ), which got about 5' tall and 'kosovo' (indeterm), which is about 7' and still growing.

    The yellowing leaves can be caused by any number of things; the simplest and least tragic could just be a nutritional deficiency, probably from a lack of nitrogen, iron, zinc, potassium, or calcium. Since your in-ground tomatoes nearby are doing fine, that might be the problem, rather than some dread tomato disease. Check out ways to provide any or all of those nutrients to your EB plants and see what happens. Or just give them a good feed of fish emulsion.

    With the first set of 'kosovo', I did get some BER (on three toms, to be exact), but I mixed 1/4 cup of the hydrated lime into a gallon of water and added it to the reservoir. No BER since.

    I don't have ground to grow toms in, so can't make any comparisons. Re: whether two indeterminates were too much for one box - I'm sure that one would be better, just to allow more elbow room for the plant, but I can't truly say that I've had any great problems with two in one box.

    I'm no expert on tomato-growing, so I only offer what I've done personally to get good crops. But don't give up on the boxes yet ......

    PV

  • 19 years ago

    PV thanks for the feedback, I added the package of dolomite supplied with the purchse of the Earthbox but no lime. I also soaked the foliage with a mix of Neptunes Harvest several times over the summer. As far as adding nutrients now would you suggest adding directly to the soil, the instructions advise not to.

  • 19 years ago

    If you added the dolomite, then that would "basically* be the same as my adding the hydrated lime - the EB people suggest either/or. Dolomite (agricultural lime) is almost pure calcium carbonate, with sometimes varying amounts of magnesium carbonate, and is more widely used. Hydrated lime (calcium hydroxide) can be caustic and not such fun to use, but that's what I found when I went looking.

    I'm not familiar with Neptune's Harvest(?).

    Yes, the instructions say not to add any fertilizer other than the strip at planting, but at this point with your plants, how could it hurt? I'd add it directly to the soil.

    PV

  • 19 years ago

    Adding the hydrated lime, if the dolomitic was added to the mix is simply not necessary. If BER occurs, it isn't due to lack of calcium in the mix.

    My experience this year has been the opposite of yours, Rich.

    My tomatos in raised beds have all been hit with fungal problems (we had 2 weeks of rain). Additionally many of the ripening fruit have split due to the excess water. Those that have ripened have been watery tasting, again due to excess water. Very disappointing tomato year for me.

    The plants in self watering containers have done much better, but they are located about 100' away from the raised bed tomatos. They are also showing signs of disease, but very minor and it's progression thus far is very slow.

    I don't think you did anything wrong, Rich, I think you just had a bad tomato year and sometimes it just happens. Blame the weather, not yourself. Make sure to dump the mix and wash the containers with 10% bleach before reuse to avoid fungal spores surviving.

    Better luck next year.

    Also, there is nothing inherently superior about container growing as far as avoiding disease.

  • 19 years ago

    Pvick, just what is Neptune's Harvest, and what is it supposed to do for a plant. Is it a solid or a liquid and where does one get it. What is it supposed to do for the plant?

  • 19 years ago

    Neptune's Harvest is a fish emulsion and or seaweed fertilizer, last I saw they offer three products, fish emulsion, seaweed, and mixed fish and seaweed, awesome stuff.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for that information, lucky me I have a large supply of fish emulsion and love to use it, good stuff.

0