Software
Houzz Logo Print
wellspring_gw

Getting The Grade Right

19 years ago

I think we are going to get some landscape work because of an occasional seepage issue into the family room (lower level) of our raised ranch.

We have completed stage one of renovations on this level of the house and have decided to tackle this issue. Reading the house, it seems that previous owners have had this recurring problem but never rectified it. I suspect that it is so occasional that those owners didn't want to go beyond the minimum.

I've had 2 design / build guys come out. Their solutions are not the same. A third design / build person, recommended by an LA, will come next week.

Here's the deal. Raised ranch. Finished living space on lower level. Family room has walk out to small patio, about 3.5 feet below grade. This pit has 5 steps up to a side walk which borders a planting bed on one side and the back lawn on the other. This planting bed is sandwiched between sidewalk and house on its long sides and the "pit" and larger patio off the garage on its short sides. The planting bed is 9' x 20'. The exterior faucet is midway along the house wall of the bed. There is brick veneer to the soil line. Cinder block below. The roof overhang is about 1', gutters are clear, there is no downspout in this area.

First guy's suggestion: The Plastic, Sand, Gravel Method

He identified the problem as primarily occurring when water from the faucet "pools" and then drains back toward the house. The grade "looks" o.k. except around faucet.

1. Remove the nasty old wood border edge.

2. Remove all plants.

3. Re-grade area.

4. Create a drainage way for water--dig down, line with landscape plastic, sand, top with gravel.

5. Re-plant.

"Hmmm," I said, "would I really want this gravel line just sitting there in the middle of my bed? Isn't what you're saying pretty close to how you put in a path?" I then pointed out my particular need for pathways that give good footing, as I can't see where I'm stepping.

Modification of first plan: Using solution as described, but creating 2' wide stone or paver path.

No written estimate. Verbal ballpark approx. $1500 - $2000.

I'll post again to tell you about the second guyÂmy favorite so far. I really don't have a question. Any comments, guidance, good questions to ask or anything else you can think of would be appreciated.

Wellspring

Comments (11)

  • 19 years ago

    If I am reading this aright: the faucet is the problem? If so surely it would be less expensive to move the faucet away from the house.

  • 19 years ago

    I would suggest having a closer look at one or both of the patios being the source of the problem.

    Even if the sunken patio pitches away from the house, the base material under it is most likely gravel. If there is no other path for that water, the path of least resistence may be back toward the foundation through that gravel base.

    The same can be true for the upper patio. That can be compounded by the fact that the original cut for the foundation tapers back toward the foundation with more porous material as the backfill - the path of least resistence again.

    It may not be the case, but if it is, the plastic and gravel won't help. ... just something to think about.

    When does the problem occur? After rain events or randomly?

  • 19 years ago

    Laag, I hadn't thought about the lower patio. It has a drain, so maybe water flows to the main sewer line? HmmmÂ

    The water in our family room has occurred 3 times in 6 years. The first was due to exceedingly heavy rainfall. Four homes immediately aroundus were bailing water out of basements. . We thought we were high and dry and then noticed the soaked carpet along the wall.

    Now I get to confess my stupidity. The second time involved a soaker hoseÂThat was several years ago. Then about 4 weeks ago it happened again. It was because the hose was leaking right at the faucet. In an attempt to get my husband interested in the problem, I tried to make it happen one day by leaving the soaker hose on. No go. After my feeble attempts to correct the grade, the bed now actually does drain pretty well except right at the faucet. But I want to knowÂhow can I make this dang problem as near to impossible to happen again?

    So, Ink's thought may be the simplest and the best. Move the faucet. But then, in the back of my mind I know that the drenching rains in 2002 that went on for weeks did eventually saturate the soil so thoroughly that the problem happened at that timeÂ

    The second guy's main approach involves getting rid of the planting bed, the main concrete patio, and the sidewalk that borders this planting bed. He'd replace the planting bed with a patio, using 4 inch "mud base?" cement with tile, brick paver, or stone.

    I know you guys could use pictures. I'm trying to think how to accomplish thatÂ

    Wellspring

  • 19 years ago

    It does not sound like the proposed work is going to change a whole lot other than your bank account and tearing up the property for a while.

  • 19 years ago

    Dang, Laag. That's clear, and therefore helpful.

    Can you explain further? I know you're answering from a distance, so are only giving me general ideas to consider.

    Is there something in what I've described that leads you to believe that my desire to keep the water entirely out is just fruitless? If that's where I end up in my decision-making, it will probably change certain decisions about renovations in the family room.

    Or is it like the old joke. The patient says to the doctor, "Doc, my arm hurts when I hold it like this." And the doc says, "Well, then, don't do that anymore." Don't, in other words, forget to turn the water off or let the faucet drip.

    When Nature provided the water in 2002, we had Be-Dry and Greenlawn, two basement water-proofing outfits, come out to check the situation. Both said, "Basically, this is a dry basement. Fix the negative grade outside the house."

    I used to think that was good news. Now it just seems like occasional water will visit my downstairs whenever someone is forgetful about turning off water or excessive rain falls on our flat Illinois town.

    Would any of the possible solutions, alone or in combination, create any change in this problem?
    ï Move faucet.
    ï Re-grade planting area.
    ï Dig down to footing and apply tar sealant along house wall.
    ï Remove planting bed and replace with properly installed hard surface.
    ï Never, ever water planting bed again and pray for drought.
    ï Move.

    Wellspring

  • 19 years ago

    Wellspring, I am by no means an expert in this situation, but it sounds like the occurrence of seepage is so seldom and directly tied to an identifiable event that I'm not sure you really have a problem. Obviously very heavy rains and saturated soils could continue to have an impact - I guess it is just a matter of weighing the likelihood of these occurring with regularity and addressing such. FWIW, my basement has flooded only once in the 20 odd years I've lived here as the result of just such a heavy rainfall/snow melt/saturated soil situation, as did most neighboring properties. And I have planting areas totally surrounding all faces of the structure.

    I think I'd be inclined to apply an exterior waterproofing to the foundation and when replacing the backfill, altering the grade as necessary as well. And remembering to turn off the faucet fully and check periodically for leaky hose fittings :-)

  • 19 years ago

    Another quick and easy possible solution is to get one of those plastic drainpipe splashguards and place it under the faucet. That would at least get the drips a few feet away from the house, and with a reasonabl grade right at that point might be enough.

  • 19 years ago

    Is it possible that the problem is splashing water, hence your difficulty in reproducing it with a soaker hose? Could it be that hard rain or a dripping faucet has the water bouncing up under the veneer? The first step is to accurately identify the problem before you can fix it, you will probably need to borrow some eyes though. Once upon a time my bike had a flat tyre so I took out the inner tube found a hole and mended it but when I put it all back together the tyre went down as soon as I blew it up. I took it all apart and found another hole that I fixed but when I put it all back together the same thing happened. After I fixed the third puncture I ran my hand around inside the tyre and found the nail that had made the holes and removed it. This is known as The Sermon on Correctly Identifying the Problem.

  • 19 years ago

    Ink, that's enough to turn anyone off bike riding!

    I agree with good problem identification, and I speak as someone who is very handy with a shop vac in a wet basement. Does the place where moisture first appears in the basement give you any hints? It might actually be well away from that faucet, maybe close to one patio or the other. Maybe at the hole where your water main comes into the house. Can you test the issue simply by letting the faucet run directly onto the ground?

    In terms of bang for buck, you'll get the most out of the smallest solutions, especially since it happens so infrequently.

    KarinL

  • 19 years ago

    Ink- I think fixing the problem relative to the faucet would resolve 95% of the issue. The other 5% goes with acts of God and with the fact that we don't really know where the water comes into the house. Karin talks about that. I suppose that means we could redo the planting bed or construct a new patio and the drainage issue would then be determined by the construction practices used at the time of installationÂright?

    SoÂis there any trick to relocating a faucet?

    I keep hoping that I'll turn up The Water Pro. You know, that amazing designer who just loves dealing with water problems This town is famous for its high water table and wet basements. Ours is by no means the only home in town with this issue. The LA I talked with on the phone told me about the $2 million homes where he's had to try to "fix" poor construction practices that led to water seepage.

    I may need to be satisfied with less-than-perfect answers, but since we are doing extended renovations it makes sense to do our best to figure out what's going on and try to make it better.

    Wellspring

  • 19 years ago

    I haven't seen any discussion of checking on where the water is coming from on the inside of the house. As with roof leaks, the stain on the ceiling can be twenty feet from the hole in the roof. Perhaps it would be cost effective to remove some of the wall board and follow the water stains to their source before spending a lot of money relocating spickets, regrading and repaving. It would tell you exactly where the leak originates, thus narrowing your search for answers on how to fix it.

Sponsored
Haus Studio
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars28 Reviews
Franklin County's Preferred Custom Cabinetry & Design Studio