Software
Houzz Logo Print
scraplolly

'Layered' planting

18 years ago

I'm reading "The Making of a Garden" by Rosemary Verey and she says something about liking to plant in layers. I'm not exactly sure what is meant--can anyone help me?

Thanks.

Comments (34)

  • 18 years ago

    I believe what she meant is that not everything should be one height. For instance, you would choose some trees for height, some shrubs for intermediate height, and some taller-growing plants or flowers and some shorter ones for the lower layers. This gives a more natural feeling than if everything is basically one height. It also means of course that you will have a greater variety of plants. Some people end up with an area of stiff hybrid teas and nothing else, which translates into boring, not to mention that you've created a monoculture that will support all kinds of disease but be of little nterest to birds and other beneficial creatures.

    Ingrid

  • 18 years ago

    I read something recently where the term "layering" was used to describe planting two or more different things at different depths, that would bloom in succession. For example: daffodil bulbs planted below something bushy that would send up foliage just as the daffodils were through blooming, hiding the ripening daff leaves, possibly providing blooms during the summer.

    Of course, they would have to be plants that need to be planted at different depths.

  • 18 years ago

    I think that is more accurately 'underplanting' tl. Ingrid has the layering right although Verey used the same term for 'lasagne' gardening and a propagation method but "planting in layers" is as Ingrid describes it. In my experience this requires a lot of knowledge, (no problem for Rosemary Verey) or the will to experiment. With enough experience layering and under planting can be combined.
    Anecdote alert: I once had a client who wanted me to dig up and move plants to the back of her border once they had finished flowering. Of course the other part was to move those in flower to the front.

  • 18 years ago

    I can almost sympathise with your client, Ink, at this point in my planning! I'm working on colour and shape right now--factoring in bloom time (especially as, in my zone, mid-spring to mid summer could likely be no more than two weeks!)--well, it's complicated, isn't it! (and pictures of foliage--unless it is strictly a foliage plant--are difficult to find.)

    So, the basic idea is tall at the back, medium in the middle, lower stuff in front and then groundcovers. Makes sense for a full on frontal view.

    I can't find the exact quote (and I wish I could) but she also says something about having planted taller plants in front with a view to the back to the smaller ones....which throws me for a loop.

    She really does layer in the sense of underplanting bulbs and so on...I have yet to wrap my head around that!

  • 18 years ago

    If you do tall at the back, short at the front everywhere you also get monotony. If you look at here layouts (and elaborate mixed borders designed by others) there are sometimes tall plants at the front, mulleins (Verbascum) for instance have large basal leaves that need to be at the front. And where spring bulbs might be planted under a spring-blooming magnolia or cherry tree there is an example of quite short plants not just at the front of the planting.

    Grant, Garden Design Illustrated (last of many printings last done by Timber Press, I believe - try used book dealers or libraries) is a good one for how different categories of garden plants are best used in borders and how to arrange them.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for the book suggestion. I may be a while tracking it down as my library doesn't have a copy.

    Verey also lets some things self-seed which definitely helps break up any perceived monotony. I don't think I have the same sort of room, however!

  • 18 years ago

    You really are going for the Phd scrap. bboy is right, if you arrange your plants like theatre seating you will achieve more regularity than you probably want. With flower borders 8 to 12 feet wide there is enough space to look over the shoulder or through the legs of the tall plant in the front row and the tall plant breaks up the ranks. If you can sort out a large perennial border on paper that is guaranteed to perform exactly how you want it in the ground perhaps you should go for the Phd as it will be the first in history.

  • 18 years ago

    Ink--I know! I'm counting my squares on my scale plan and thinking--what's the point? The plants will do what they like, anyway!

    Still, I have to start somewhere--and for me, that's with graph paper.

    As for seeing through the legs or over the shoulder--that's interesting! I don't think I'll try to "plan" that--not this year, anyway, though it's definitely something to keep in mind. (Though it may happen by accident).

    As soon as I pull something together, I'll ask for input.

  • 18 years ago

    Many gardens are designed to be viewed from different directions - not only the full frontal attack. If one has the luxury of space, tall plants can go in the middle with graduated sizes down to the borders throughout. I have one I've managed to get the E/W views sort of right to my eye, but N/S not quite. I've stared at it for two seasons now and am ready to make a remedial attempt as summer wanes.

    With perimeter beds backing to a fence or structure or a mixed shrub plan for a lot line, etc., graduating from tall to low coming foreward would naturally be the most satisfactory. And it does take some planning and study - and the willingness to eventually get from A (mulling & researching) to B (getting out the shovel). I see so many yards with their front and side yard gardens designed like perimeter beds to look good from the street - the homeowner is left to look out the windows at the tall back ends of things.

    I guess leaving gaps in the planting sequence would afford a keyhole view to shorter plants tucked in among the taller. Does one have to be skilled in vignettes to get that right? I think so, otherwise it could simply be the overlooked Veronica tangled up in the phlox stalks. Or, if something failed to perform as expected, a gap where a gap was not intended.

    Underplanting isn't so complicated as it reads - spring bulbs like Puschkinia, Squill, daffodils are hardy to zone 3. Tulips are deer candy and, thus, don't warrant taking up space (for me, anyway). And by the time the bulb foliage gets ratty, other things are springing up to hide it. And we've all sliced a bulb or two in overplanting our underplantings. It comes with the territory.

  • 18 years ago

    Just mix it up and cross your fingers! :-) I don't like to use stair-steps. My bulb foliage get covered over by the perennials that come up over them in the summer. I use perennials with pretty foliage when they are done blooming (like Japanese irises and amsonia hubrechtii), I mix in some evergreen shrubs and flowering shrubs and trees. Drought plants are up the slope, rain garden at the bottom...all are deer resistant.

    Not everyone's cup of tea, but I like the impressionist look.

    {{gwi:22175}}

  • 18 years ago

    Actually, for the most part scheme shown has shorter plants in front and taller plants at the back. Otherwise you wouldn't be able to see back that far.

    But you certainly don't need to start offering tickets.

  • 18 years ago

    Oh, I don't know about that--I just might buy a ticket! This is so pretty.

  • 18 years ago

    When I said "or the will to experiment"this is what I meant. Wonbyherwits has put a lot of time and effort into this border and no doubt moved things around had some success and some failure. I bet she is in her garden as I write.

  • 18 years ago

    Bboy...not implying that this is the right way, it's just my way. That's why I said that it's not everyone's cup of tea. I don't have the kind of ego that thinks it's all that special to anyone but me. I garden for myself and share my deer resistant experience through my garden blog. I'm not trying to come across as competitive or expert, so my apologies if it sounded that way. I'm just trying to share.

    Inkognito...you've got that right! I'm always in my garden. I'm retired, so this is my fun. That view is only 1 year old. I created the bed (soil prep and a few shrubs in fall 2006 and planted 98% of those perennials in spring 2007...then had a drought). I move plants around all the time. I'm taking notes of what I want to fix this fall and next spring that doesn't quite work for me. I shovel-prune when I really hate something.

    Actually, this is a sideways look through the front garden. The bottom of the slope is on the right and the top of the slope is on the left. I was standing mid-way up the slope so that you can see there aren't stair steps of height up the slope from right to left.

    Sorry that I didn't make that clear about the photo orientation.

    To the left is our open meadow of almost 2 acres, so these plantings can't be too structured. On the right is the house. My garden can be viewed from the top of the slope or the bottom, so I have a mix of short/tall just about everywhere.

  • 18 years ago

    My point is that your basic arrangement is still tall plants at the back, with shorter in front. It just doesn't have them all grading down evenly, in rows. That's why you won't have to offer tickets, it's not quite the theater seating look.

  • 18 years ago

    You can plan for short to tall in general, but you're not likely to end up with anything as rigid as the theater-seat look after shearing back the spent early-bloomers, dead-heading, and allowing for the variations in height caused by flopping, growing conditions, and just plain old variations in size of plants considered short, medium, and tall. Many of my perennials don't do what is expected of them anyway, bad plants.

    Even so, I've seen it suggested that you break up the plan with an occasional medium or tall pulled forward for variety, especially those that are wispy and easy to look through.

  • 18 years ago

    Those herbaceous plants with basal clumps need to be at the front, or their leaves will be obscured. The exception is evergreen ground-covering types beneath deciduous trees or shrubs, where they will be visible in winter.

  • 18 years ago

    I had to look up "basal clump" and after looking at a few examples, it seems clear that the foliage height should be taken for its placement, not the flower height. As to what to place behind it? As saypoint says, the density of the flower in front can be taken into account. I imagine it's a very neat effect to have a "see-through" flower in front of something more dense and a different sort of shape behind it.

  • 18 years ago

    Layered planting has always meant to me, plants in front of other plants regardless of what heights or form they are. The rest just points out that no matter what you are dealing with, whether it is layering, or color, or form,...., it alone does not control the outcome, but is at the mercy or benefit of every other variable that you or the conditions thrust upon it.

    It is a good idea to study these things as individual subjects to get a greater understanding of how they affect things. It is a whole other story to apply these things individually because none of them is powerful enough to completely rule the composition unless you weaken the affects of everything else in order to make it the single most powerful thing.

    If you have gone through the excercise of weakening other things to strengthen something like layering, you have then used those other things making my point that the first element is not strong enough to work on its own.

    I think that a lot of writers convey too much strength in in parts of design which they feel others have ignored or more people should consider either without realizing that these things are not powerful enough to work on their own, or just assuming that every reader already has a deep understanding of many other design concepts and the ability to apply them in concert with concept at hand. One thing that I have really picked up on by reading these messageboards is that many people cling too strongly to concepts that they have read about and have a great deal of trouble combining not seeing them as concrete roadmaps to success - until they build their landscapes.

  • 18 years ago

    Layered to me is a reference to vertical stacking of plants. Trees on top, tall shrubs beneath and so on. In the Mediterranean planting ground crops beneath fruiting shrubs and those beneath orchard trees has been called Greek Hill Farming. Don't remember what we call this same maximizing of land use agricultural method when seen in China, but there's another example.

    Different levels of vegetation in forests are also called layers. Parts of a cake, too. In all cases there is vertical stacking, as opposed to a single layer.

  • 18 years ago

    re basal clump etc.... it may seem clear enough, but it may not be in practice. In the first place, some of those basal leaves simply aren't attractive; it's fine to have them buried in the back of the border. In the second place, in a layered planting (!) the tall stalks of flowers can lean for the light - this is the bane of my gardening existence as I have a narrow yard. If there is shadow behind them like a fence, or shrubbery above them, they may lean out of your border well over the edges of the bed. If they are in the middle or back, they may lean to just the right place.

    KarinL

  • 18 years ago

    It does appear that most garden writers use the term "layers" as Bboy explained - like layers in a cake rather than foreground, middleground, ... as I have used the term. I learn something new everyday here.

  • 18 years ago

    What do they say about a picture being worth a thousand words?

    Here is a link that might be useful: a thousand word picture

  • 18 years ago

    Herbaceous plants lacking large ornamental basal leaves are of course not planted at the front. But if you put these where this feature will be obscured by other plants, you have lost much of the value of these kinds. With something like a hosta it will be most of the value.

    What are we looking for at "a thousand word picture"?

  • 18 years ago

    Hidden amongst the layered planting from Rosemary Verey's book 'Garden Plans' you will find the title of the book she found so much inspiration in. Granted it is a tad obscured but it is there for the observant.

  • 18 years ago

    I'd sworn off garden books, having 'enough.' Now here's one more I really need, hidden in barely discernable print.

    Thanks.

  • 18 years ago

    And it's not even on that page.
    Ink--Do you plant corn mazes, too?

    :)

  • 18 years ago

    It means 2 different things to me, since haven't read her book don't know what she meant.
    #1 is layering successive bloom times so that as each plant fades past its time the next one comes into its season.
    #2 is layering plants by size to create an effect of depth and 'mystery'. This relies more on foliage since you would want contrasting foliage when there are no flowers.

  • 18 years ago

    Actually unless you want it to look busy you want mostly harmony, with some contrast for interest. Depends on if you want quiet or loud to be dominant.

  • 18 years ago

    Contrast doesn't have to be in color, it can be in plant shape, leaf shape, evergreen, bark, etc. I have 13 cotoneaster in a large planting that have tiny dark green shiny leaves. Next to them are a large - maybe 9 ft square planting of Japanese Bloodgrass, 6 chamaecyparis nana aurea and then a large planting of peonies. I don't think it looks busy at all. The cotoneaster has its season of leaf appearance, bloom, leaf interest, red berries. The chams are there yr round. The Bloodgrass adds reds as summer and fall go on. The peonies draw all the attention in the spring. You can either look right past this planting like most people do with landscapes or spend time focusing on it to appreciate the various plant and leaf forms and colors. Putting one of everything is what can create the busy look - like what I did for years till I finally got it that collecting more was making a hodge podge and not pleasing to look at unless you're a horticulturalist.

    Fine Gardening did a special interest publication on landscaping with texture and leaf color and there I saw the idea of putting nothing but Hosta Patriots among green and white variegated Euonymous - I added hellebores, white Bleeding Heart, Carex Evergold, white astilbe aand European Ginger for a completely green and white yr round bed that I rather like. To me the hellebores are the mainstay and I've started putting them all over my place. They are kind of 'self-layering' since they have the late winter/early spring flowers and attractive foliage the rest of the yr.

  • 18 years ago

    From what I've seen of hellebores, I love them. Not hardy here, though, unfortunately. The closest I can get is alchemilla mollis, which isn't close, really, at all.

    I'm drawn to contrasting architectural shapes more than anything...I love your green and white idea! I'll have to look up those plants to get a better idea of what it would look like--unless you want to post a picture for me?

    I'm now reading the other side of the story, "Planting Design" by Piet Oudolf and Noel Kingbury.

    Still working on that Ph.D.

  • 18 years ago

    I don't know if these are good examples of layering since this is a very young garden (it its second year)and layering was not specifically in my mind when I planted it except to have the tallest plants in the back (they'll eventually grow to 7 to 10 feet). The rest was just what pleased me in terms of color, shape and height

    {{gwi:39565}}


    {{gwi:39566}}

    Ingrid

  • 18 years ago

    Ingrid, not to be rude but it's better if you start your own thread if you want specific feedback. And ask for it directly. Folks here do love to help--there's just no way they would know it's wanted with such an old thread.