Software
Houzz Logo Print
karinl_gw

I'm walkin' on bluestone...

18 years ago

So I thought walking on bluestone would be like walking on sunshine, but we just put one test stone in, and compared to the rest of the old concrete sidewalk that is still in place the stone feels like... THUNK when you walk on it. Your bones are definitely coming into contact with the full presence of a 2'x3' by two inch slab of solid rock. The old sidewalk feels like a flipping trampoline in comparison.

We have all manner of flagstone and pavers around the back yard and I don't think this sensation has ever struck me on any other surface, perhaps because one moves more meanderingly in the back yard while gardening or carrying a cup of coffee around. Also the only natural stone surfaces we used in back, some random cut flagstone and some granite bricks, are either thinner or smaller pieces.

Now I'm a bit torn whether to do the whole front walkway like this or not. It looks great, but it just feels very hard and unyielding. We have it bedded on sand over dirt, not needing much more for frost resistance in our area. Is the slab size at fault, or the thickness, or the base, or is there just something about bluestone that I didn't know?

KarinL

Comments (6)

  • 18 years ago

    Karin, I think something else must be bothering you about the bluestone. Solid concrete can't possibly be 'softer' than a slab of rock. Color? Texture? Price? Is the sample set higher than the surface you're used to walking on? Something else is making you uncomfortable with this decision. Sleep on it, then re-evaluate. (That almost sounds like "take two aspirin and call me in the morning.")

  • 18 years ago

    Take two aspirins and call me in the morning.

  • 18 years ago

    Catkim, that's what I thought at first but it's been a few days, and even more unnervingly, my husband - Mr. Objectivity himself - agreed that it felt different. Price is a good one! More likely is not wanting to be burdened by having the broken up old concrete lying around. And if anything the sample is set slightly lower... but not by much.

    We'll leave it for a while and get some feedback from friends and family. Most of the work around here is half done; the whole house is half-renovated, so it doesn't look out of place as it is :-).

    KarinL

  • 18 years ago

    Bluestone pavers are denser/heavier than concrete which has more air and voids in it, so your perception is not necessarily off. I don't think any solid paving is going to give you the feeling of walking on air, they certainly don't have any give to them. If the density/weight is bothering you, I'd suggest that you compare this Bluestone with other paving stones that are less dense/heavy for the same thickness. I would ask myself whether it is really of any importance that an entry walk feel "soft" to walk on barefoot? It is not like a kitchen floor that you will be standing in one place, but simply a means of entry and exit, and needs to hold up to your climate, have durability and look good. If you want a paving stone/tile that has a softer feel, I'd suggest that you look into limestone or travertine, as the irregular voids on the surface of travertine do tend to give it a softer "feel" when walking barefoot.

    As to the expense and effort of getting rid of old concrete, it is certainly possible to break the old walk out in larger pieces and recycle/repurpose it as low stacked walls for raised beds, or even to have it saw-cut and used as edging or for decorative walks elsewhere in the garden. This is a classic re-use of old concrete walks/driveways here in California, and I have also occasionally used larger sections of old concrete as vertical sculptural pieces in the garden. You can also stain old concrete with ferrous sulfate to make it look more earth toned.

  • 18 years ago

    Funny, I had a similar sensation but I was happy with it! We had a bluestone patio put in our backyard. It was supposed to be irregular bluestones, though what the stoneyard delivered was larger and more uniform pieces than we'd expected. There was a fair amount left over so we replaced some small slate stepping stones in our side yard with these much heftier bluestone slabs. It makes for a much denser feeling, flatter, even walkway. I find it very pleasant because it gives a much more secure feeling to my steps. It's not as rustic and informal looking, so there's a tradeoff, but I'm glad we did it.

  • 18 years ago

    I think "dense" is the word I was looking for, so it isn't the sensation in bare feet but simply the impact of landing on the stone that is different from concrete. Also I think the span of the average concrete walk is longer and thus the fact that it has some springiness where a bluestone slab does not - maybe a concrete slab has less too than a concrete walkway. A friend was here today and again, spontaneously, noted the different feeling between the remaining walkway and the section that has been replaced by slab.

    Whether the feeling is a good thing or a bad thing is what I am torn about. I normally like the absolute mass of solid rock, but I am feeling my joints already, especially my hips, and given that I travel this walkway often, and often in a rush that will probably send shockwaves to my jawbone, am not sure that enjoying the feeling won't backfire on me in that department sometime. So I'm thinking.... and I wanted to mention it here as it is an aspect of the walkway decision that I haven't heard discussed before.

    Thanks, Bahia, I will be putting the chunks on craigslist, but the last time I did so I didn't have any takers. So there is probably a run to the recycling facility in my future if I can't find other uses, but either way, in the meantime it has to be put somewhere.

    Thanks for the reassurance that we're not crazy to sense a difference, LoveSummer!

    KarinL