Software
Houzz Logo Print
pdxman

Retainng Wall Help

18 years ago

I recently had my general contractors build a series of dry stack mortarless retaining walls for me out of basalt rocks. I think most of the rocks weigh between 100-150 lbs. The wall that I am most concerned with is about 3' feet high (maybe slightly higher in some spots) and about 40' long. The potential problem is that they did not backfill the wall with gravel but only used soil. Also, the wall has very little batter if any. They dug a trench, I think at least 6" deep, but again no gravel, drain pipe or landscape fabric. I am concerned about drainage especially since I live in Portland OR and we get lots of rain!! Also, maybe freeze although I'm not sure how we are affected here. Most everything I read suggests that gravel backfill is integral to good drainage. But I have also read that mortarless rock walls have good built-in drainage because of all of the joints and can withstand some movement. So my questions are:

1. Will my wall fail due to hydrostatic pressure or the freeze thaw heave? If so, any ideas when and how? In another words, will I still be able to get some good years out of this wall before major problems?

2. Will soil erosion also be a problem?

3. How can this wall be fixed without tearing down the whole wall and starting over? Is it possible or fesaible to dig behind the wall and backfill with gravel?

I am basically trying to find out if I have a big problem on my hands that need to be fixed now or maybe I will just experience some small movements in the wall over time that can be addressed as needed. Thanks for any input.

Comments (4)

  • 18 years ago

    It depends on the situation and exactly how this wall is built. Dry stacked walls have lasted centuries without gravel behind them or footings under them in areas of ground frost. Others have fallen down very shortly after being built.

    Tf your wall builders have a long track record of successful dry stack walls, it is likely that it is OK. If a bunch of laborers stacked up stones in front of a cut and are hoping for the best, it might not be so good.

    Some situations where there is a retaining wall has water movement toward it. Some do not.

    My recollection of Portland soils are that they are heavy silt for the most part and hold lots of water. Silt is small particles, so it goes into solution and migrates in water. That means that it can put a lot of pressure on a wall when wet and that it erodes easily.

    Silt/clay soils hold water much more than larger particle soils and don't give water up to gravel or sand unless it becomes completely saturated, so drain rock behind the wall would be move effecive for allowing surface water a place to go than fo relieving hydrostatic pressure. It also would be important if you have perched water moving between soil layers and toward your wall.

    If the face of the wall is getting dirty, it is a sign that the soil is bleading through with water.

  • 18 years ago

    Portland? Freezing? I didn't think so, at least not to a serious extent. But I may just be projecting down the coast.

    I agree with Laag that this is one of those dreaded "it depends" situations, though his understanding of the factors is more learned than my lay perspective. On the other hand, I know the climate fairly well, and we've done a fair bit of rock placement on just dirt up here in BC, without gravel backfill, and as long as the base layer is well-compacted, we don't have problems with shifting, sinking, heave, etc. And those are good big rocks you've used.

    This is a really important sentence in Laag's post: "drain rock behind the wall would be more effective for allowing surface water a place to go than for relieving hydrostatic pressure." I've taken the liberty of correcting typos (3, Laag!), but the point is that having gravel behind the wall is not a problematic omission unless you have a big surface flow issue. If you don't have that, you may well be OK.

    What you have read about the importance of gravel may come from different climates, or from industry sources which have other reasons for wanting to make the construction of a wall seem more complicated than it has to be. Rock work in areas without frost heave is different, and I don't think you need to obsess about gravel behind the wall or about a different base just on principle. There might be something about the site or the actual job performance to worry about, but we can't see that.

    Erosion? Possibly. But I doubt it would be significant or ongoing. What is on top of the wall - a lawn, a tree, a house?

    If you are even contemplating tearing down the whole wall and starting over, perhaps you should address the other classic question of "so what?" What will happen if the wall fails? What will it hurt? If you park a Lexus right beside it, maybe rebuilding out of anxiety is rational, but if not, perhaps you can just wait and see what happens, and repair only if necessary.

    KarinL

  • 18 years ago

    Is the wall at the front of a flat area, 3 feet high or does the ground continue to rise behind the wall? I thinks a dry stacked wall has minimal durability as a retaining wall and should have a batter. I have never seen one or built one with such big stones as although not durable a dry wall is easy to rebuild if parts collapse, not so easy with 100lb stones. I agree with laag's skepticism about the way the wall was built as there is a bit more to it than piling up stones. Any chance of a photo?

  • 18 years ago

    Is the 6 inch trench a swale for diversion of surface water?

    The other question, is this a wall or just rip-rap?

Sponsored
Landscape Management Group
Average rating: 4.9 out of 5 stars33 Reviews
High Quality Landscaping Services in Columbus