Software
Houzz Logo Print
brandon7_gw

Apple Questions from a Beginner - About Rootstocks

18 years ago

Please just don't respond to this post if you are going to say something like "You need to do your own research before you bother us here" or "You just have to try it for yourself". I have spent weeks reading and studying about growing apples and have more questions than when I started. I'm really hoping that someone here has the knowledge and patients to give me some guidance. I have tried searching through older posts, but find that Gardenweb has deleted a vast amount of the older posts that seem like they might have related to my questions.

I am in East Tennessee and have plenty of room to grow any size tree. I think I want to grow apple trees on a standard size or near standard size rootstock. My goal in choosing a larger rootstock is to have a tree that will be around for a long time and be as low maintenance/disease resistant as is reasonably possible. It is my understanding that standard rootstocks are more likely to provide these characteristics.

From what I have seen, the most common standard size rootstock is Antonovka 313. I have noticed that it is prone to fireblight problems, may produce more suckers than some rootstocks, and has a tendency to produce a tree that leans. All these problems concern me. Is there a better full size rootstock that would be available commercially?

Another question regarding Antonovka's problems relates to rootstock/scion combinations. If the rootstock is prone to a problem but the scion is resistant, what happens? For instance, Antonovka is prone to fireblight but Freedom and Liberty are fireblight resistant. If one of these varieties were grafted onto Antonovka, is the tree prone to fireblight or resistant?

I've also considered EMLA 111. The issues I see with this rootstock are slightly shorter lifespan, powdery mildew issues, and burrknots. How much shorter would the lifespan of a tree grafted onto this rootstock be, on average, compared to a full standard size rootstock? If the scion was powdery mildew resistant but the rootstock was susceptible, would the resulting grafted tree be resistant, susceptible, or somewhere in between?

I read that the burrknot problem might be overcome by planting the graft union below ground level, but have not been able to confirm that through other sources or find out why that was true. I've not even been able to find out how much of a problem that burrknots where likely to be. If I use EMLA 111, am I highly likely to experience this problem? Will planting deeper eliminate or reduce this problem? Will the trees I get through commercial growers be grafted low enough to ensure that I would be able to plant the graft union below soil level without planting the tree too deeply for it's own health?

Finally, the ultimate "beginner like" questions....If lifespan and disease resistance is important, size is not an issue, commercial availability is important, and early production is not critical, what's the best rootstock?

Comments (12)

  • 18 years ago

    brandon,
    See the linked article below.

    I'm in agreement with the author that you really need to select rootstocks(at least so far as apple & pear are concerned - stonefruits are a different critter) based on anchorage, disease resistance etc., rather than on 'size control'. Ultimately, YOU are in charge of how large(or not) your apple tree becomes; Prune, Prune, Prune.

    That said, I've planted, over the past 15 years, 60 or more apples, on various semi-dwarfing rootstocks - M7, M111, M111/M9, M106, and some unknown to me. Of all these, M7 has been the best, most reliable performer. All sucker fairly profusely, but M7 perhaps a bit less than M111. M111 and the combo M111/M9 have failed to anchor in my good clay soil, exposed windy site - many of those trees would be lying flat on the ground, except for my having propped them up. Trees on M106 have been exceedingly slow to come into bearing.

    Personally, I wouldn't want an apple on a standard rootstock - the average person would have immense difficulty pruning/spraying/harvesting fruit from them. A semi-dwarf or even some of the better-anchoring dwarfing rootstocks are probably a better choice.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Dwarf Tree? But it's so BIG!

  • 18 years ago

    111 is long-lived and adaptable. The burr-knots are just clusters of root primordia and have never been an issue on trees in my region. M7 used to be my choice but poor anchoring tendoncies are a nuisance and 111 is generally more conducive to survival under relative neglect. The root-stock will not affect mildew susceptibility.

    I'm curious if anyone else out there has found burr-knots to be a meaningful liability. What works here may not work so well elsewhere but I have often heard and read experienced southern growers extolling the virtues of 111.

  • 18 years ago

    You forgot to mention domestic apple seedling with the vigorous rootstocks. The reason seedling and other vigorous rootstocks (Northern Spy used to be the benchmark) are so long-lived is that they basically outgrow whatever's trying to attack them. The roots are vigorous and thus extract nutrients and water from a larger area, and the roots have a tough, rope-like strength to them (as opposed to thin brittle roots of dwarfing rootstocks). The canopy is capable of growing new limbs if snow or bears break off one.

    It is not uncommon for a seedling tree to take 7-10 years to really start bearing. But even semi-dwarf trees from M7 upward have a chance of outliving you. On the other hand, I'm thankful for the pioneers that planted our local mountains with seedling rootstock trees 100 years ago so we can still go pick a bunch of apples. I say plant both; maybe a Geneva dwarfing rootstock resistant to fireblight and a seedling tree that will outgrow the fireblight...

  • 18 years ago

    Brandon, Gardenweb hasn't deleted the older posts, yet. There's a glitch in the upgrade they just did that for some reason won't display the older posts using a simple forum "Search". It's very frustrating, because there's a lot of valuable information there
    However, if you do a Google search on "gardenweb.com/forums/fruit/"; and then the title of the post that had the "Whoops-" message, the page with the message comes right up. You can click on it and read it.
    I sure hope they can fix this without deleting the older posts.

  • 18 years ago

    I manage plenty of apple trees on size reducing rootstock that are well over half a century old with no signs of decline. They haven't dropped off in the production of high quality apples either.

  • 18 years ago

    Some home orchardists sanitize their pruning tool between every cut, or every job or whatever they consider appropriate.

    How do you know if the owner practices some form of hygeine that your unapproved pruning will violate? What if they are trying to train the tree in a particular manner? How would you know any of this?

    What if he's grafted the last stick of his great grandfather's dying tree onto the tree in question and you harvest it off, or inadvertantly damage it during your gathering?

    What if a homeowner has several newspapers piled up on the doorstep. They appear to be unwanted, is it OK for you to take them? How many need to be piled up before its OK and how many can you take? What if the owner is saving them for mulch or paper mache and just hasn't bothered to collect them up yet?

    I've been tempted to "prune" the trees from the local big box hardware store, but it was so obviously wrong that I didn't do it. If I did so it wouldn't because I thought it was moral or ethical, it would be because I'd succumbed to temptation.

  • 18 years ago

    Yo Murky,

    You got the wrong thread man!

    ------------------------------------------------------------

    Everyone Else,

    It's interesting how M 7 and M 111 have produced opposite results for different growers. Can this really be simply from different environments/soil types?

    I've seen the technical difference in M 111, MM 111, and EMLA 111 written out, but is there really much of a difference in actual practice?

    Anyone else have opinions about burr knots? I have read that they are frequently an entry point for various insects and borers, which in turn leads to all kinds of problems. I also read today that burying the graft union was not only a disadvantage because, in many cases, the advantages of the rootstock would be voided, but also because collar rot was much more likely.

    I now see that tomato ringspot virus is also a problem with 111. Tomato ringspot virus can lead to apple union necrosis and decline. Is this problem widespread? Is there a solution?

  • 18 years ago

    BTW, I really appreciate you guys taking the time to answer my questions! It is very helpful to get feedback from actual growers.

  • 18 years ago

    Oops, sorry. I wonder what happened to my post.

    Sometimes I have several gardenweb windows open at once. They load slowly so I'll "open in new window" each thread with an interesting title.

    This is the first time I've posted in the wrong thread. Hopefully I'm not slipping.

    You may now return to your regularly scheduled programming.

  • 18 years ago

    Aren't there any commercial or serious amateur growers in your area you can ask? I know that nurseries all over the country sell trees on emla 111 (virus free). You can certainly plant the trees right to the graft union, 111 won't rot from contact with soil. You can also contact your cooperative extension for suggestions.

  • 18 years ago

    There are orchards in Tennessee, but no large ones near where I live. I have seen small plantings (10-15) trees around some of the local farms, but would be surprised to find that those growers were "experts". In any event, I don't know any experienced individual fruit growers locally.

    It seems to me that feedback from multiple sources, such as here on Gardenweb, is one of the best ways to get info. Another good thing is the "peer review" that goes on here. I have talked to the local extension people, but have found that the amount of helpful information from them is definitely limited. I think the combined years of experience here are probably highly useful compared to any single source with which I am familiar.

    As for planting the graft union right at ground level, from what I read about burying the graft unions to reduce/eliminate burr knots, I'm not sure that planting the graft unions at or just above ground level would work. I think the idea was to plant the trees so that the scion would form its own root system and eventually bypass the 111 rootstock. Has anyone else had good or bad experiences with 111 concerning burr knots?

    Anyone have any information about how much difference the EMLA (virus free) rootstock makes?

    How about the tomato ringspot virus issues?

  • 18 years ago

    EMLA is usually all that's available from repuatable nurseries these days, at least the commercial suppliers. Virus free may or may not make a noticable difference, I have even heard of a variety being better on a dirty rootstock but I don't really take that seriously. I would go for EMLA but don't assume that a nursery is selling something else because they don't label it as such.