Software
Houzz Logo Print
chuck60

Grafting buck rub

15 years ago

I just found three of my apple trees have been badly damaged ... probably killed ... by a buck rubbing his trophy rack. It probably occurred in November, but I just found the damage yesterday. One tree is a four year old Jonafree, and it was a poor tree I might well have decided to grub out anyway. It never took off and was just not happy. The other trees are three year old Spitzenberg and Wickson crab. The Spitzenberg is poorly shaped due to my crappy pruning, and also has some kind of growth on the lower trunk. It might be trying to graft root. On the other hand, the Wickson crab was doing just fine until Bambi's father found it. I'm pretty sure it is completely girdled.

I've never done any grafting, but I sure would like to try to keep the three years I have invested in the roots of at least the Wickson crab. Is it possible I could graft to the trunk below the rubbed area using scion wood from above there? The tree should have been dormant when the damage occurred, so is it likely the roots and the potential scion wood would be viable?

Chuck

Comments (9)

  • 15 years ago

    Chuck, I have done what you are proposing. If the scions look green and not shriveled they should be good. The root is definitely still good. I would soak the scion ends in water in the fridge for a day or so before wrapping in a bag to give them a chance to re-hydrate. Then graft to the base in the spring.

    Note that if you have deer problems you may need to guard the grafts in the spring. Deer prefer lower sprouts so they may decide to munch your graft out of existence.

    Scott

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks, Scott.

    I do indeed have deer problems. I have kept all my trees in fence circles for the first 3-4 years or until they reach a height such that I figure the deer can't turn them into shrubs. I took the fence circles from these trees this past fall and intended to use fence material or corrugated drain pipe or something to protect the trunks from exactly what happened. I was somewhat lulled by a much smaller local deer population this past year and just didn't get around to it and paid the price.

    The trunk of the Wickson below the rub is perhaps 3/4 inch in diameter, while any scion wood will be considerably smaller. I'll look up instructions on the web for grafting under those conditions and give it a shot.

    Chuck

  • 15 years ago

    Would bark grafting be a viable option here? I've never tried it, but it might be nice to be able to someday.

    Thanks,

    M

  • 15 years ago

    I would personally do a bark graft in such a case. The other good option is a cleft graft. I get equal takes with the two but with a cleft you have to split the stock which is a pain to do and it takes more years before signs of the graft point have disappeared.

    Scott

  • 15 years ago

    I've been reading and watching U-Tubes. Seems like either bark grafting or cleft grafting would work. The cleft graft seems easier and I'm all into easier.

    Chuck

  • 15 years ago

    First .243 rifle. second motion sensor (jack russel ). third remote light sits on cab of truck and is controled from inside the house. forth give the jack a piece of the heart hot from every deer he spots with praise. fifth do not doubt the jack. went from a 20% loss to 2% loss in 10 years. 100 trees per year. # 5 is the hardest for me to learn.

  • 15 years ago

    Hi Scott- I mispoke about bark grafts. What I meant to address was the possibility of grafting-in strips of bark to repair the damage. Is that doable?

    Thanks yet again,

    M

  • 15 years ago

    I think you mean bridge grafting [link]
    Since your injury accrued now and grafting time is spring, this would
    most likely dry out your top, so you're probably better off to cut off
    and start new.

    Konrad

    Here is a link that might be useful: Bridge Grafing

  • 15 years ago

    I will try to determine if my potential scion wood is viable, but in the event it is not I'll probably try to obtain good scion wood at least for the Wickson crab. That tree was doing very well, so I expect the roots are well developed.

    I'm looking forward to trying some grafts on at least the Wickson and the Spitzenberg, and perhaps the Jonafree. I've ordered another Spitzenberg from Burnt Ridge, where I think I got my Wickson, but they don't list Wickson this year. I mentioned in another thread that I have an aging double grafted tree with what I think might be Grimes Golden on one side. There should be lots of good scion wood available on that tree, which is in decline, so I'm thinking of grafting some of that onto the Jonafree stump and perhaps also the Spitzenberg, though I want to keep the Wickson as Wickson. Reading here and on various grafting sites has roused my interest in the project. It may not be as satisfying as going on a deer killing rampage, but I'm trying to get revenge by being optimistic!

    Chuck