Software
Houzz Logo Print
michael357

Cleary's 3336

17 years ago

Anybody out there familiar with Cleary's 3336 labeling? I've encountered what appears to be some conflicting information concerning it's use on apple trees. I'm interested in it's use for controlling Scab, CAR, PM and/or sooty mold. Ok here goes: 1st - the label very specifically states that for home orchards it is not to be used past fruit set. 2nd - several university web sites list it's use for summer diseses (namely post-fruit set). 3rd - I have e-mailed their rep for this area and have not yet received a response.

As a systemic, non-restricted use fungicide it could be a good tool to use with the last few remaining fungicides legally available to the general public. The only other systemic I know of is myclobutanil (Immunox). Immunox appears, from my research to have resistance building problems if not used in rotation and/or combination with other fungicides of different chemistry (3336) and mode of action (protectants like mancozeb and captan).

The best legal fungicide schedule I seem to be able to piece together accounting for resistance, effectiveness and the diseases I have to deal with (CAR, scab, PM and sooty mold, minus FB), generally is: Bordeaux or Kocide pre-budswell followed by Immunox + mancozeb sprays from green tip through petal fall. The cover sprays would drop Immunox to avoid resistance and mancozeb (it has a 77 day pre-harvest interval) and switch to captan + (hopefully) 3336. Another advantage of 3336 is the 12hr PHI though I have seen some conflicting info. on that too.

Hope the above makes some sense. If you're dying to look at the 3336 label check out "Horticultural Applications" section of the link below.

Here is a link that might be useful: Cleary's 3336 F Label

Comments (31)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "The only other systemic I know of is myclobutanil (Immunox)."

    Quarts of Propiconazole called Fungi-Fighter are available from Jungs. It is a systemic fungicide for stone fruit. Every 21 days for 4 applications.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Myclobutinol is known to me as Nova. Are you asking your question in reference to commercial production or home orchard?

    I have managed over a 100 home and estate orchards during the last 2 decades and the only orchards I have failed to control scab completely with only a combination of Nova and at least one application of Captan and Nova mixed is when they are very susceptable varieties like Macintosh and there are nearby unsprayed trees. In such instances I use both a strobe like Flint and Nova plus Captan.

    I often can get this control with only 2 applications- one at petal fall and another 10-14 days later when I also spray Imidan for usual complete control of PC and other insect pests.

    I more often do another application when I'm applying oil during half-inch green to tight cluster when I throw some Nova in the mix.

    The smaller the planting the less likely is resistance development if you are not near large commercial plantings. I haven't heard of resistance problems with Nova as far as CAR and mildew go.

    The strobes are also systemic as I understand it but not affective against CAR.

    I am in southeastern NY where there is plenty of humididty and lots of scab and CAR.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Harvestman: home orchard, and yes Nova 40W and Rally 40 WP are both myclobutanil AI restricted use fungicides, Immunox is the 1.55% AI myclobutanil over the counter version. Topsin-M 70WP is the only restricted use version of thiophanate-methyl (the AI in 3336) I'm aware of. I unfortunately let my applicators license expire several years ago so am stuck with only the homeowner selection.
    The various university commercial recommendations I've been plowing through indicate a slight edge to using a combination of Nova + mancozeb over Nova + captan for scab, rust and PM. Mancozeb itself looks to be pretty effective for scab and rusts but not PM. Also, for what it's worth, every mention I've seen for SI fungicides makes the comment about disease resistance potential. Admittedly at this point, unlike you, I can't speak from experience. Therefore, I appreciate your offered comment.
    Michael

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Don't over value the info you get from universities. They have no mandate to research home orchard production and are often overconfident that their research applies to non-commercial scale. I have had many arguments with Cornell reps who insist that my actual experienc must be myth.

    My low-spray use of Nova was supposed to render is useless years ago if I believed these experts. Their info is useful but only as guideline.

    Nova is not restricted nationally, at least not up until last season, nor are any of the other materials you've mentioned. In NY state, Manzate has been restricted in the timing and frequency of application only.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Harvestman: I agree and don't over value it but have to start somewhere. Listening to sales reps would also be a source of info not to be over valued.

    I do have some confidence in university work having participated in horticultural research in Florida and Colorado for a number of years. Research has it's limitations and those are understood. There's the old adage, "garbage in garbage out", it applies to research also. It is incredible how much effort has to go into going from a theory to proving it with a high degree of confidence. Notice I say, "a high degree of confidence", that is on purpose. Any good scientist would understand that their work is not an everlasting gospel. In the living world nothing is absolute, everything changes including the fungi, weather and apple trees. I'd say those Cornell reps should listen to your experience with open minds, who knows, there might be a good paper in it for them!

    Thanks again, Michael

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Research is usually conducted in areas with much higher levels of innoculum than found in home orchards and even the research orchards themselves have more trees than most home orchards.

    I feel absolutely certain that resistance vulnerability is exagerated when discussed by most experts including sales reps. There is tremendous concern that valuable pesticides will be rendered useless by careless use so they error on the side of caution. Sales reps that supply commercial growers tend to echo the recs of their local land grant college.

    I have much more actual hands on experience than any expert I've ever met in managing home and estate orchards, even though it is without much microscope work. I am in several different orchards most every working day to evaluate results over a wide range of micro-environments, species and varieties so I hope you will recieve my advice on fungicides with a little confidence- I know it's hard to believe someone without actually seeing their work.

    The beauty of Captan in the mix with any systemic is its tendoncy to wash off during rain and redistributing to growing shoots. This is Cornell's observation and I do trust them on this one.

    Most commercial growers spray programs around here include the ample use of Captan in spite of its limitations.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Michael, here are a few disease fighting options for the home grower. Their labels are available online to see what they work on and what the PHI etc is. Google on their name plus LABEL to see the label.

    Sulphur, lime-sulphur, copper (Kocide 3000 is the best IMHO), Surround - organic options with many sources.

    Eagle 20EW -- Myclobutanil 20% (more than Immunox) which is available from several sources, e.g. Cooper Seeds.

    Fungonil -- Chlorothalonil 30% available from several sources e.g. Cooper.

    Monterey Fungi-Fighter -- Propiconazole 1.5% from e.g. Jung as Ace mentions above.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Michael357

    Cleary 3336 has been mentioned by Virginia Cooperative Extension as a systemic fungicide in their pest management guide for the home orchard. I have researched this to death and all in information I could find was that it is only to be used as a landscape fungicide, not in the orchard. I gave up and went to Topsin and Capitan. I would listen to harvestman. In fact , I believe I recall a company rep. stating that Topsin was for the orhcard and Cleary 3336 was for landscape trees. I do not know where the universities got the idea that Cleary 3336 could be used in the orchard.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If you live in a state with a fruit growing industry you probably have a commercial source for agaricultural chemicals. One national chain is CPS or Crop Production Systems which recently bought out United Agricultural Products. If you know what you want, this is often the best place to buy. Sales reps deal with commercial growers and know what works and the prices are often much better than suppliers that service landscapers and on-line sources.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Crop Production Services apparently bought out or merged with Royster Clark as our Royster Clark is now the CPS.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Harvestman,

    This is Mark here. I know you know this, but for the benefit of others, if one intends to spray with commercial products, be prepared to get your wallet out. Most commercial products are sized for several acres of mature trees. As an example, I use a fungicide called Pristine. One gallon container costs $200. I also use an insecticide that costs $300 per gallon. There are lots cheaper pesticides out there, but pretty much all commercial pesticides are going to be pretty expensive. Some of them are also packaged in water soluable packets (WSP). The packets are designed to be tossed into a large tank rig, where the entire packet disolves, not opened and individually metered out. Imidan WSP, is currently packaged this way.

    Addtionanally, for commercial pesticides not in WSP packaging, understand the chemical is much more concentrated than what is typically available to the consumer. When I mix spray to use in a backpack sprayer, I literally use a digital scale that measures to the 5 thousandths of an ounce.

    Lastly, don't forget about personal protective equipment. To spray commercial pesticides you should own a respirator, chemical resistant gloves, and chemical resistant headgear.

    Don't want to discourage anyone, just want to point out it's a pretty big commitment to start spraying commercial pesticides.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Yes, absolutely right on all counts. Of course, older pesticides sometimes cost as little as $35 for a lifetime supply, such as Captan and Imidan. Nova ran me about $70 a bag last year- with enough to make about 1,000 gallons- I'm told it won't be called Nova next year. Some of the new insecticides run as high as $400.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My mistake:
    Sorry Hoseman and others!
    The recommendations I referenced were for thiophanate-methyl, not Cleary's 3336, too much stuff swimming around in my head I guess. However, the 3336f and wp labels I looked up on the web indicate it's use up through petal fall on, "home orchards". Of course, Topsin-M formulations have thio-meth as their AI and the few labels I've looked at are listed for apple (for summer diseases also, I vaguely recall). The rep from Cleary's wrote me back; he reminded me that, of course, the label supercedes all other recommendations including universities. His curious explanation for why no spraying after petal fall was that spray contacting the fruit would get into the fruit and "could not get out". He did not recommend Topsin-M.

    The good university extension people have been in the field alot working for the people who pay them, you and me. There are those who are professors only doing research within extension departments getting little field experience. On the other side, there are those like the one I worked for who are excellent researchers and excellent field people. And as in any endeavour there are good crop managers and those who aren't. I expect you are a good manager Harvestman.

    Respectfully, Michael

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The point I was making about the research and researchers wasn't to question the quality of their work but the validity in the context of a relatively small home orchard. Commercial production is an entirely different animal that requires a different regimen. Professional consultants would be ill-advised to prattle on about their own anecdotal observations- they could be sued. I however can say what I want here without fear.

    Until fruit production is being studied in the scale of small, mixed species production(don't hold your breath) the only choice of small growers is to take all the research with a grain of salt and then to compare notes with other small growers. I am a small grower with the experience of a hundred small growers because I manage so many different orchards and have for decades. I affectively manage the major fungus diseases with Nova as the central agent and at least one tank mix with Captan in a 2 or 3 spray program and have not experienced resistance problems even as commercial growers 30 miles away have. However I live in southeastern NY not your neighborhood. You should consider my advice and make your decision. Good luck.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Harvestman.
    Hopefully you havent already answered this... Have you ever tried going to the lesser strength Immunox instead of the more potent Nova? When you say "My low-spray use of Nova", you mean that you just sprayed it infrequently, (as in twice) correct? (and you didn't mean that you diluted it, correct?)
    I'll be experimenting with Immunox on a few of my trees this year, and Ferbam on the other trees, to deal with my difficult CAR problem. For Scab, I'm hoping the Kocide3000 will mostly do the trick. I believe this plan has much more of a chance at success than my plan for previous years (simple all-in-one home spray garbage). If it turns out that this isn't enough, then I'll look at adding other fungicides in future years. Since my trees are young, and IÂm not dealing with a whole orchard, IÂll be bagging my apples again this year to deal with insects.
    Thanks,
    -Glenn

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    While this discussion is ongoing, I thought I would raise this issue again.

    I have had a large number of my granny smith apples develope bitter rot while in storage. I stored about 2 bushels in plastic bags with holes in garage refrigerators last fall. At least 2-3 of the apples in each bag have developed bitter rot spots about the size of a quarter to half-dollar. I have since sorted all the bad ones out and stored them in my chest freezer (cooler set at 32-38 degrees as there is a 6 degree spread)Some were left in the bags and others have been stored loose. The rot has not penetrated the apples too deeply yet, so I have been using those first. I had the same problem with bitter rot on some of the fruit before storage and used those apples in recipes. I posted a picture on this site several weeks ago, but did not get much interest in the topic. I wonder if I am using the wrong chemicals, not spraying the chemical late enough into the season, or some other reason I have not thought of.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    In my low spray I always use highest rates but fewest possible applications. No one at Cornell would ever suggest that you could control scab with only 2 fungicide applications. Materials are not nearly as expensive as my labor so I have sought to find the minimum number of applications approach that doesn't require frequent monitoring becuase of the quantity of orchards I manage. I am always trying to keep my prices down.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hoseman, that sounds like a calcium deficiency. You probably need to spray your trees with a few calcium applications but diagnosis this way is not reliable.

    Glen, Nova is excellent for CAR control but be sure to make 3 applications including the delayed dormant (1/2 inch green through tight cluster) where you mix Nova with oil.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Al,

    I believe you're thinking of bitter pit. Hoseman has bitter rot, which is a disease from those boys way down south:-)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Harvestman:

    I didn't get the impression that you were being very critical and wouldn't be concerned if you were. Mostly, I was writing to provide info on extension and research that might help others understand what it is about and, as you point out, that it must be taken with a grain of salt. I personally know of a researcher or 2 whose research field work was good but their statistical methods were, let's say, questionable. So much for those experiments. Looking into this stuff is like trying to find a good mechanic, you have to know alot about it to know if you've found one.

    Any tips on how commercial and small scale are different other than the obvious (IE 2 gallon vs 100 spray tanks) would be appreciated.

    Michael

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Glenn, Re: the strength of Immunox vs Nova, it is all balanced by how much water you mix it with. You need to use a lot more Immunox per gallon of water than you do Nova.

    BTW I would use the Eagle 20EW I mentioned above instead of Immunox -- Eagle is 1/5th the price when you take into account it is 20% myclobutanil and not the 1.5% of Imunox. Eagle is labeled for use on home orchards.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Michael, aside from the sheer potency of the chemicals, and container size/cost, here are some other differences between small scale vs. large commercial spraying:

    Most commercial products, unlike garden products, don't add a surfactant to the formulation. They expect the grower to add the surfactant. Not all commercial formulations require the producer to add a surfactant, but some formulations recommend it.

    Some crop protectants recommend adding other pesticides in the mix to reduce resistance buildup, or increase effectiveness on certain pests.

    Unlike some homeowner pesticides, many crop protectants have a more limited use on the label to avoid resistance buildup. For example, Pristine can not be used more than 2 consecutive applications, without rotation of a different class fungicide, and no more than 4 times per season on certain crops. While it is true there is less risk of resistance buildup for small growers, nevertheless, using Pristine more than 2 consecutive times is off-label and illegal. Other crop protectants have similar labels.

    Unlike homeowner formulations, many crop protectants require a buffer before mixing. Pesticide manufacturers expect commercial applicators to know this. I use a small pH tester to test the carrier (water) before adding the crop protectant. pH can be adjusted by adding citric acid, or some other buffering agent.

    Commercial applicators are expected to know all parts of the label. For instance, what are the three "action" words and what they mean. Danger/poison; Warning; Caution. Its also good to know the LD50 values of what you're spraying and what they mean. Other things helpful to know - What products are Cholinesterase inhibitors. Some growers have their Cholinesterase levels checked periodically.

    Because of potency, there is a higher level of caution needed with commercial products. Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) is a must.

    Obviously, one should be familiar with REI, and PHI, on the label.

    That's all I can think of of the top of my head.

    Basically, one needs to get as much education as possible, before using commercial products. I'm in the process of getting my pesticide license, which is more involved, but have learned more about the responsible use of pesticides.

    For anyone wanting to start learning about pesticides, there are several good resources on the internet.

    The Michigan Fruit Management Guide is an excellent resource for the serious grower. A small grower need not spray as often as the program outlines, but the Management guide lists when diseases are most susceptible to control and the best products to control them. It is not available on the internet, but can be ordered for a small cost. This is much more preferable, to developing a spray program from a forum on the internet. I'm not dissing the forum, I'm just saying I've seen some information regarding pesticide timing, that was incorrect. I'm making NO reference to this particular thread. I have little experience with apples and have never read the labels of many of the products listed in this thread.

    Other resources: The Midwest Fruit Management Guide and the Midwest Fruit Management Pest Handbook are very good (for my area). I believe they are available in downloadable form on the internet.

    And above all, read the label, BEFORE YOU PURCHASE THE PRODUCT. What you find there might surprise you. Labels can be obtained from CDMS.net.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hi Scott-
    Thanks for the info.

    Well, at this point, I already have already procured the 1.5% Myclobutanil Immunox. Back when I started this investigation last year, it sounded like Immunox might work based on some West Virginia Univerity info (link below, page 3-3) and from Michael357s info. Back then, there wasnt a lot of forum talk going about CAR & Myclobutanil, and I felt like I was a bit on the fringe. Because I now also have Ferbam, really using the Immunox is more of an educational exercise. I want to know which spray will be simpler (less sprays) and will be most effective. Then, when others here on the forum are being devastated by CAR (like I was), I/we can give them a simple, legal, clear-cut solution like I needed 2 years ago.

    As of today, Im thinking that I will still go ahead with my 2 sprays off Immunox (along with other sprays of oil, copper, deer repellent) on a couple of my trees (the other trees are getting Ferbam instead). Although CAR has eaten me alive in years past, it wasnt super terrible last year. My thinking is that maybe my CAR problem isnt as bad as previously thought, but rather, it was the fact that I wasnt treating it at all. (I thought I was at the time because Bonide All-In-One says it was, with only Captan, theres no way it could).

    If it turns out that the 2 sprays are ineffective, next year, I can up it 3 sprays of Immunox, or Nova or Eagle. Id rather not overdo the chemicals if possible.

    Unless of course people are now confident that my 2 Immunox sprays will surely be ineffective, and I really should get Nova or Eagle 20EW. Thoughts?

    The learning never ends thanks guys.
    -Glenn

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Glenn, I looked at the dosage rates and the net amount of the active compound you end up with on your trees is roughly the same with all three. So if you already have Immunox, just use it until you run out.

    Scott

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sounds like a plan Scott. And, in 20 years, when I run out, I'll consider the Nova or Eagle. Thanks again! -Glenn

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Olpea,

    You are right. I have bitter rot, not bitter pit. Actually, I do have a little bitter pit, but that is not my main concern at this time. A little bitter pit can be cut out when the apple is used. These apples store just fine with it. However, the bitter rot is another matter and storage becomes an issue.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hoseman,

    U of KY recommends Captan late in the season. Captan is readily available to anyone, and generally has a very short pre-harvest interval.

    http://www.ca.uky.edu/agc/news/2001/Jul/bitte.htm

    One small correction on my last post. I mentioned "action" words. The correct terminology is "signal" words: Danger; Warning, etc.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The difference between commercial production and home orchard type production is about pest pressure. Not only the obvious bit about commercial producers needing to grow pristine fruit either.

    I believe resistance pressure is expotentially increased as you go from a few trees to a few thousand. The mathematical odds have to increase and once a resistant strain of insect or fungus establishes on one tree it quickly spreads. It is much easier for such resistant pests to jump from tree to tree than from orchard to orchard.

    I succesfully use materials frequently that are no longer recommended because of highly developed resistance in fairly nearby commercial orchards (within 50 miles).

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Ditto on the importance of learning a functional understanding of PPE, LD 50 (oral and dermal), REI, PHI, etc.. Basically, everything on the label. I hadn't thought about buffered vs non-buffered until I ran into some info stating that captan and malathion are hydrolyzed above pH 7 leading to a less active compound. Also I vaguely recall but am not certain that fixed coppers have the same problem.
    As far as the labels go, commercial vs homeowner, never thought about that a whole lot either. I did notice that my Immunox bottle says not to use it more than 10x per season. With commercial formulations of myclobutanil, that would be a no-no on apple as would be too many successive apps.. Lots more to ponder.

    CDMS is a great resource. Frome the guides I'v seen on the net, the 2009 Midwest Tree Fruit Spray Guide is the most comprehensive including many notes comments. I ended up printing out most of it out to study and to have for reference.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Michael,

    Thanks for the link. I was in the Extension office the other day asking for it, and they didn't have it yet.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You are welcome olpea. The 2009 version just came on line in the last few days.

0