Software
Houzz Logo Print
temp31415

Asian Pear Tree Questions

14 years ago

Hello,

My wife and I bought 5 acres in North Eastern Washington and we are planning on planting some Asian pear trees this spring. I'm hoping you can help with some of my questions.

I am planning on buying the trees from Burnt Ridge Nursery and they put their trees on OHxF 513 rootstock. Is there any disadvantage to this root stock compared to a full size rootstock? I'm mostly concerned about disease resistance and drought tolerance from the rootstock. I've tried to research drought tolerance for pear trees but haven't found very many sources. In our area, some apple growers use M111 rootstock because it doesn't need to be irrigated after the tree is established. Would that be the case for OHxF 513?

I am looking at the following varieties: YOINASHI, CHOJURO, SHINKO, and KOREAN GIANT. I really like Asian pears so if they do well, I'll probably plant more varieties in the future. I tried to pick varieties that were disease resistant. If one of the trees does get a disease such as fireblight, does it negatively impact the other trees?

Deer and pocket gophers are a concern in our area. In the next few years I'll fence the area to keep the deer out but I was thinking about getting some 5ft tree shelters for the trees in the meantime. Does anybody have an experience with the tubex or plantra tubes and Asian pear trees?

I'm planning on planting goumi near by the trees as well as clover to help with nitrogen. The area we are planning on planting them in is mostly grass right now with some spotted knapweed.

Any other thoughts or words of wisdom you have would be appreciated.

Thanks in advance!

Comments (10)

  • 14 years ago

    Take care of the spotted knapweed first. If it is infesting the area you want to plant, you may need to wait a couple years to plant if you use herbicides to remove the knapweed as they will probably leave residual in the soil for a year or two.

    Knapweed is quite a survivor and a terrible pest. However, if you keep the area mowed, you may be able to live with the knapweed. Talk to the county weed & pest district about a control program before moving too far into getting the trees.

  • 14 years ago

    raintree has them on ohf97

  • 14 years ago

    I don't offhand remember ever seeing degree of drought resistance mentioned for any pear rootstock (such as one sees for MM-111 apple). I have noticed that several different pear rootstocks on mine (OHxF 513, 333, maybe 97; callery; and possibly just seedling pear) all seem reasonably good performers in frequently dry sandy soil.

  • 14 years ago

    OHxF513 will probably not be vigorous enough for asian pears they need a really vigorous rootstock. Where you at if you get fireblight I would try pyrus ussuriensis as a rootstock it is really blight resistant and takes the cold VERY well. It is hardy to about -30 F the only problem with it is pear decline with the asians not sure if you have that I would talk to your county extension agent and see what he says.

  • 14 years ago

    also OFXf513 is dwarfing so will mostly likely need irrigation my ussuriensis needs no irrigation and also takes large amounts of flooding. I have a few asian grafts on to this and all are doing great.

  • 14 years ago

    Thanks for your replies!

    The knapweed isn't too bad in the area I'm planning on putting the trees. There are only a few plants which I can dig up. Other parts of the property are a different story however...

    I'll see if I find trees on P. Betulifolia or P. Ussuriensis rootstock. I might end up doing a mix. I'd like to try grafting someday but I don't think I'll do it for my first planting.

    I'm curious about everyone one's thoughts on the tree protectors. There are quite a few deer in our area and fencing seems to be the only alternative to the tree protectors.

  • 14 years ago

    I use a ten foot length of 14 gauge 5' tall fencing and a single 2X2" 8' pressure treated stake. Use the fencing itself to close it and only close in 3 places for easy access.

    Deer rarely push into the fencing to graze trees but if you are so unlucky you may need 3 or 4 stakes and another couple feet of fence length.

  • 14 years ago

    matty,
    OHxF 513 has worked fine under Asians here. No more dwarfing than P.ussuriensis here - and no issues with with anchorage or handling drought conditions.
    I've recently gone to putting an 8" interstem of 513 between seedling callery understock and fruiting variety; jury's still out, as none of those are more than 3 years old, but have had a couple that fruited already, and they're all growing quite vigorously

  • 14 years ago

    Ditto here for 513 - I think it would be fine for you.

    Scott